· 3 comments · Save ·
For Sale Mar 28, 2026 at 10:28 PM

And Justice for All

Posted by SeaworthinessKey3654


It came at the tail end of Al’s legendary 70’s run, and after some of the greatest movies ever made…so it’s easy to overlook this movie, but don‘t I know the courtroom scene gets all the attention, but it shouldn’t - not because it‘s not phenomenal, but because the entire movie builds up to it beautifully  I love Arthur - he‘s such a decent, warm hearted man, full of compassion…who is juxtaposed against the cynical, often cruel, world of the so-called justice system. Al thoroughly deserved his Oscar nod - not just for the big, flashy climax, but for his entire portrayal of a man  fighting the good fight…in a fight he likely can’t win My favorite scene is also one of the most heartbreaking I’ve ever seen.  Arthur confronting his colleague over that man’s casual disregard of his client’s life - well, he’ll get out in 10 months, so it doesn’t really matter- and just his attitude towards these people as transactional is everything I love about Al.  He’s special because he brings such humanity to his roles - he FEELS everything- and his despair & anguish here pour out of his soul. It’s devastating. And we see again and again that life in the system is unfair….that scene where the kid who’s been unfairly jailed is shocking, but by then not a surprise.  Apparently Al rewrite the courtroom scene to make it more realistic for an attorney’s breakdown. Assuming the original script had legalese..I’m glad, because no amount of legal jargon could ever convey the passion and desperation that Arthur felt. Maybe the Judge won’t ever be tried again, but this will hang over him regardless.   That’s the only justice we see in the film…. I adore this movie- I highly recommend it On a lighter note, I love seeing Al and his teacher, Lee Strasberg (again, following Godfather II)

🚩 Report this post

3 Comments

Sign in to comment — or just click the box below.
🔒 Your email is never shown publicly.
moon-dustie Mar 28, 2026 +1
Spot on. The courtroom scene gets all the love but the real gut punch is Arthur confronting his colleague about the kid. Realizing some people in the system don't even see the people they're 'helping' as human. Pacino in the 70s was untouchable. Every role felt lived in, not acted
1
SeaworthinessKey3654 Mar 28, 2026 +1
💯💯 Beautifully said.   I had seen that scene on YT, and it hurt then, but seeing it in context…getting to know Ralph, and how desperate he was to stay out of jail, cuts WAY deeper  When I saw Al in Dog Day Afternoon, I was blown away - I knew I was watching a genius, and I still feel that way about him.  There’s no one like him
1
SeaworthinessKey3654 Mar 29, 2026 +1
I meant to add- It was really funny in some some parts - Al is so good at t comedy when he’s given a chance 
1
← Back to Board