I understand that part of the show but is it a little bit unrealistic for them to do all the things that they've been doing to Ray and Robert and their families without event she just cutting them out?
Driving the car through there living room? Inviting all of Robert's girlfriend's over to criticize him? Stealing the football from the college football kicker and the family having to deal with it?
I guess in my head I'm just trying to understand how it's realistic to deal with all that from the grandparents without eventually just cutting out of their lives.
Edit: I guess they're really more the parents in the grandparents. But my question still stands
When you have young children, you’ll understand why some people put up with overbearing parents in order to get some help with the kids.
35
tetoffensApr 25, 2026
+12
They also live across the street, so cutting them out would be even more awkward.
12
neo_sporinApr 25, 2026
+3
my sister in law and her husband passed up a greeeeeat opportunity because it would have meant leaving the safety net of grandparents being available to baby sit
3
TaskebabApr 25, 2026
+14
I mean, you need some plot points and conflict if you wanna reach syndication
14
Y-27632Apr 25, 2026
+13
Because not everyone is as willing to break ties with family members as American Listnookors from dysfunctional families?
The parents on ELR are sitcom caricatures, but the answer is really simple in that case, they all love each other despite the crazy shit.
And in real life, lots of people might not *like* their family members but still love them. You can argue that's not healthy, but neither is an atomized society with individuals without bonds aside from those they made on the internet, so...
13
metametapraxisApr 25, 2026
+7
It is a sitcom. It isn't representative of real life. It only has exaggerated echoes of real life, as per most sitcoms.
7
Marikk15Apr 25, 2026
+20
Because it’s a sitcom
20
BarkovitchApr 25, 2026
+11
It's a comedy show. If you want realism, you're looking in the wrong place.
11
RoseCutGarnetsApr 25, 2026
+4
Are you telling me Ork isn't a real planet? What about Alf's planet? Sweet Jesus WHAT ABOUT ALF?
4
greyfoggydaynlApr 25, 2026
+3
ALF?! Isn't he back now? In POG form, I hear? Right
3
helpusdrzaiusApr 25, 2026
+2
He's back in Pog form, baby!
2
NullhitterApr 25, 2026
+4
Ever had loving parents? You deal with their annoyances even when you don't want to.
4
Vincent_adultman98Apr 25, 2026
+8
In suburban areas, it was super frowned upon in the early 2000's to cut anyone off if they're family. As a society we've moved towards not being that way as much, but it was super rare when that show was on the air.
It's also a comedy show, so those types of events are obviously heightened and not treated as seriously as they would be in real life.
8
ssdissaorApr 25, 2026
+3
Italian (also applies to latino) family dynamics you are too anglo to understand
3
RoseCutGarnetsApr 25, 2026
Also Irish. Really most places in the world and most cultures besides white American WASP. Intergenerational living was the norm before the capitalist myth that each generation buying a home=success. Not having grandparents help raise kids and then not having your kids care for you when old is a raw deal for all 3 generations.
0
ssdissaorApr 25, 2026
+2
You are right, feel the same kind of of kinship watching Derry girls compared with the average American sitcom
2
Starbuck522Apr 25, 2026
+2
plus, the kids just play quietly in their room all of the time.
One time it's Christmas Eve or Christmas day. Parents and uncle and grandparents are opening gifts in the grandparents living room. No kids in the room nor coming in asking for anything.
2
zachthepersonApr 25, 2026
+2
Mostly just because the writers decided so.
In-universe though it's because Raymond is a major mama's boy, the mom treats Raymond as her favorite and showers him in praise, and Robert always felt jealous of his brother so he still fights for the attention of their parents. Meanwhile the mom is either knowingly or unknowingly manipulative, and constantly enforces the behavior of both brothers by feeding Ray attention. This causes both brothers to overlook their parent's negative behavior because they both want to be on their parent's good side.
2
Potential-Piano256Apr 25, 2026
+1
Because of the grandparents, the show is hilarious, not real, just fun, quit nitpicking.
1
Charming-Report1669Apr 25, 2026
+2
What you're describing is referred to as a "premise"
2
MySmellyRacoonApr 25, 2026
+1
It’s a sitcom genius. It’s not real.
1
QuePasaCasaApr 25, 2026
+2
Why does Robert, the largest Barone, not simply eat the other Barones?
2
boomosaurApr 25, 2026
+2
I dunno, why does raymond constantly lie to his wife to get sex, and then she's magically cool the next episode?
2
EyeWasAbductedApr 25, 2026
+2
Because it’s funny
2
Horny_GoatWeedApr 25, 2026
+2
Have you never watched a sitcom before?
2
OchevesakoApr 25, 2026
+2
This just sounds like expecting realism from a sitcom. Don't.
2
bishop375Apr 25, 2026
+1
For the same reason Ray stays married to Debra. His latent masochism coupled with his wild insecurities, which are both stored in the empty space where his actual spine should be.
27 Comments