· 199 comments · Save ·
For Sale Mar 31, 2026 at 4:58 AM

I frickin love Prometheus (2012)

Posted by Status_Wrongdoer_152


Yes, I know this movie has some of the dumbest character choices ever put to screen. Yes I know all the payoff in the next movie was very disappointing. I get it. But this movie just has the sauce. Just LOOK AT THE IMAGE of David's finger and the scene after where David drugs Holloway after Holloway says "we made you because we could." You can't convince me that this movie is bad. Is it partially because of nostalgia? Yes, but shut up.

🚩 Report this post

199 Comments

Sign in to comment — or just click the box below.
🔒 Your email is never shown publicly.
iXeons Mar 31, 2026 +1154
Fassbender’s best performance IMO, and that says a lot since the dude rarely gives less-than-stellar performances
1154
Variable_Shaman_3825 Mar 31, 2026 +553
He has the veneer of politeness while interacting with humans but also an underlying disdain and superiority over them, kinda like Hal 9000.
553
dakotanorth8 Mar 31, 2026 +171
Your description also applies to a young Erik Lehnsherr. Also known as, Magneto.
171
iXeons Mar 31, 2026 +109
Fr, him and McAvoy were perfect choices
109
preyforkevin Mar 31, 2026 +49
I was really upset at the casting of James McAvoy as Professor Xavier. So I saw the movie anyway. James McAvoy was the correct choice.
49
koyre Mar 31, 2026 +37
I felt this way about Heath Ledger in the Dark Knight. I was like, “that dude? As the joker? The 10 things I hate about you guy? No way, this movie will suck”. I was clearly incorrect.
37
iXeons Mar 31, 2026 +9
Same holy “brokeback mountain guy, what??” *proceeds to cry with sister at 11 years old watching him win best supporting* As a kid he scared the shit out of me lol still does
9
_Football_Cream_ Mar 31, 2026 +5
people said the same about Pattinson as Batman as well
5
mikehatesthis Mar 31, 2026 +5
That one had at least people who watch movies said stuff like "oh he's good, like in Good Time and The Lighthouse!" and the guys who were still mad about Twilight some 12 years later thankfully looked like fools lol.
5
themobiledeceased2 Mar 31, 2026 +17
Concurrently being 10 steps ahead.
17
misteraskwhy Mar 31, 2026 +14
Streets ahead
14
DankStew Mar 31, 2026 +10
Coined and minted
10
Artemis_21 Mar 31, 2026 +17
I liked it more in Covenant
17
Rhino-Ham Mar 31, 2026 +8
For sure. He killed that dual role.
8
SinkHoleDeMayo Mar 31, 2026 +4
Just watched it again a few days ago. One bot is warm and fuzzy, the other cold, calculating, and creepy. What a performance.
4
Namath96 Mar 31, 2026 +3
Genuinely a transcendent performance imo. Unfortunately almost nothing else about the movie is any good lol
3
phonylady Mar 31, 2026 +31
I'd say that's from Shame, easily.
31
000100111010 Mar 31, 2026 +22
Bro. Hunger, Shame, and Frank are Fassbender's best. Prometheus was like.. ok.
22
BTJPipefitter Mar 31, 2026 +31
Everybody in this thread sleeping on his brief but memorable role as Lt. Archie Hicox in Inglourious Basterds. “I must say… damn good stuff sir.”
31
SlaterVBenedict Mar 31, 2026 +3
"'And like the snows of yesteryear, gone from this earth.' ....Jolly good, sir."
3
Zurich_Is_Washed Mar 31, 2026 +14
Hunger, Shame, and Frank sounds like a boring ass movie
14
RightWrighter Mar 31, 2026 +7
All three were actually epic. They absolutely are his 3 best performances.
7
Zecharai Mar 31, 2026 +6
Hunger was incredible. I'd never heard of Bobby Sands until that movie. It led me down a rabbit hole of reading about the whole Irish movement in the 70s. If anyone wants a real great book about the troubles; check out: Say Nothing by Patrick Radden Keefe. Fantastic read.
6
Son_of_Macha Mar 31, 2026 +3
Try living through it
3
deko_boko Mar 31, 2026 +2
Iiiiiii love you allllllll
2
N8CCRG Mar 31, 2026 +2
Recently I thought I wanted to do a rewatch of the X-Men prequels, but the more I thought about it what I was really craving was just Fassbender's scenes.
2
iXeons Mar 31, 2026 +2
Especially DOFP
2
TowerOk9578 Mar 31, 2026 +3
smh gotta agree that scene was wild n Fassbender legit kills it every time, fr
3
Revolutionary_Bee251 Mar 31, 2026 +471
Deleted scene between Captain Janek (Idris Elba) and Meredith Vickers (Charlize Theron) Meredith Vickers: Please don't touch that. Captain Janek: You know before I sold my soul to corporate, I was in the military? Yeah. Before I did that, though, I was, uh, flying Saudi's out of Jordan. And uh this one base that I was on had this building. No windows, pure steel, surrounded by barbed wire fence. I see some men in white coats running in and out of it. We knew they were making something in there and we knew it was bad. Anyway, one night, the alarm goes and we get ordered to do a full evac, everybody out. And I'm running towards my transport and I see these men in white coats, trying to get out that building. Screaming. Crying for their lives. Turns out that fence wasn't to keep us out. It was to keep them in. Anyway, we get in the air. And I see my CO flip open the box that he had on his lap, with a grey button on it. And he closes his eyes, and he starts to pray. And then 6 km out decides to push that button, and even that far out we felt the heat of that explosion as 1100 souls give or take vaporized just because some idiot spilled something. Now I know it was a long time ago, but I felt the same thing happened here. Those things, those engineers, they made something they shouldn't have and they spilled it. Now it's your turn to push the button.
471
ThreeLeggedMare Mar 31, 2026 +240
Damn why'd they cut that, that's great
240
Legitimate_First Mar 31, 2026 +240
It also explains why Janek was so weirdly quickly gung-ho about kamikazing himself and the crew on the alien ship.
240
marapun Mar 31, 2026 +101
I bet it was because it implied that bioweapons were being made in the middle east. Some investor kicked up a stink and made the movie worse
101
DeNiroPacino Mar 31, 2026 +20
Especially if delivered by the excellent Idris Elba. Damn!
20
Revolutionary_Bee251 Mar 31, 2026 +25
I too love Idris, loved this scene when it came up on the deleted reel and am glad others can read what could have been. I'll speculate it wasn't in the film because like others have said it's a bit on the nose. It kinda messes with the pacing of the film. Idris was still working on his "American accent" and it was all over the place through this monologue. Lastly, this scene is a reminder history repeats itself, whether it's in-universe or back in our reality. To quote from another piece of the franchise: "It means this space bug is proof of how stupid smart people can be. Smart enough to build ships capable of space travel, of splitting the atom and decoding the genome, but too stupid to realize you don't bring parasites home with you." - Rahim, Alien Earth S1E5 Always, always watch the bonus features! Long live cinema!
25
tjvs2001 Mar 31, 2026 +5
He should probably still be working on it now, amazing how someone so unbelievably impressive as Stringer Bell could ever be so bad at being a yank in anything after.
5
UnholyLizard65 Mar 31, 2026 +6
Cool story, but in the context of the story it would be too on the nose I think. It would be like the Xmen movies actually spelling out that Xavier and Magneto are MLK and Malcolm X.
6
Vanquisher1000 Mar 31, 2026 +12
The whole "Xavier is MLK and Magneto is Malcolm X" thing is a popular interpretation, but it wasn't what Chris Claremont had in mind when he started writing for Marvel in the 1970s. >Actually, Claremont says he always saw Professor X and Magneto as echoes of David Ben-Gurion and Menachem Begin. “My view of Magneto” – originally created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby as a magnetic-powered supervillain who wanted to take over the world – “is that he’s the terrorist who might someday evolve into a statesman.” Source: [The X-Men Files - Nymag](https://nymag.com/nymetro/arts/features/3522/) >"It was too close. It had only been a few years since the assassinations. In a way, it seemed like that would be too raw. My resonance to Magneto and Xavier was borne more out of the Holocaust. It was coming face to face with evil, and how do you respond to it? In Magneto's case it was violence begets violence. In Xavier's it was the constant attempt to find a better way." >"As we got distance from the '60s, the Malcolm X-Martin Luther King-Mandela resonance came into things. It just fit." Source: [The secret to 'X-Men's' success - CNN.com](https://web.archive.org/web/20200804122552/https://edition.cnn.com/2011/SHOWBIZ/Movies/06/03/xmen.legacy.go/) >There’s a lot of talk online now that Magneto stands in for Malcolm X and Xavier stands in for Martin Luther King, which is totally valid but for me, being an immigrant white (*Claremont was born in England*), to make that analogy felt incredibly presumptuous. An equivalent analogy could be made to \[Israeli prime minister\] Menachem Begin as Magneto, evolving through his life from a terrorist in 1947 to a w***** of the Nobel Peace Prize 30 years later. That evolution was something I wanted to apply to the relationship between Xavier and Magneto. Source: [Exclusive: X-Men’s Chris Claremont talks through five key storylines | Movies | Empire](https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/x-men-wolverine-jean-grey-chris-claremont-five-key-storylines/)
12
LeBronGOOD Mar 31, 2026 +17
Do they explain what the scientists were making? Makes me curious now.
17
alexbrobrafeld Mar 31, 2026 +28
Captain Tripps
28
MaxRichter_Enjoyer Mar 31, 2026 +3
I got that reference!
3
monarc Mar 31, 2026 +40
Almost certainly a bio-weapon, like an engineered virus. Imagine a pathogen far deadlier than COVID, but just as contagious.
40
Particular_Wear_6960 Mar 31, 2026 +12
From that I've read, stuff like that exists. There's a whole bunch of bio-warfare stuff that we don't know about that absolutely can destroy a major chunk of the human race, but we go about our days in naive bliss.. The reality is, we are an accident away from living like we are in the Fallout universe.
12
Brownbear97 Mar 31, 2026 +6
The U.S. bought all the Japanese research from World War Two about the effects of chemical and nerve agents and didn’t prosecute their crimes as an exchange
6
Bull_Rider Mar 31, 2026 +7
T-virus
7
Labyrinthy Mar 31, 2026 +6
No but it’s neat given the context of the franchise. Could be anything. It expands the universe in a compelling way. I love mysteries like that. Like the original space jockey in Alien. Didn’t love what they did with it in Prometheus but I’ve gotten over it.
6
Ascarea Mar 31, 2026 +6
> Before I did that, though, I was, uh, flying Saudi's out of Jordan. That doesn't sound like a line that should be in a movie set in the future.
6
RandomStrategy Mar 31, 2026 +45
The Ottoman Empire began in 1299 and ended in 1922. Things stick around longer than you think.
45
qtx Mar 31, 2026 +23
Why not? Countries have existed for hundreds of years, no reason for them not existing hundreds of years in the future.
23
craft6886 Mar 31, 2026 +84
The ending they set up was so cool, and I was so mad to discover that Covenant was not the big Prometheus continuation I was hoping for. "Elizabeth Shaw? Oh yeah, she died offscreen on the way to the Engineer homeworld. And the Engineer homeworld? This may or may not be it, we'll never tell. Regardless, David killed all of them in a flashback. But we've got Xenomorphs! You guys like Xenomorphs, right? Well, technically these aren't Xenomorphs, they're actually *Praetomorphs.* Don't worry, this will be very obvious to viewers."
84
reticenthuman Mar 31, 2026 +20
How I felt going from Aliens to Alien 3, so it felt nostalgic in that way lol
20
serke Mar 31, 2026 +5
In much the same way that they had the William Gibson treatment for Alien 3 with Newt and Hicks alive, I like to imagine an alternate version of Prometheus 2 that was Shaw and her creepy half a robot exploring the dark mysteries of the alien universe.
5
BattledroidE Apr 1, 2026 +2
And xenomorphs exist because humans... No. Just no. I view Prometheus as its own self contained thing. Alien is something else.
2
meatloafpoptarts Mar 31, 2026 +447
I share this opinion. There's absolutely a plethora of dumb shit in the movie but the vibe is immaculate.
447
snoogins355 Mar 31, 2026 +97
If you root for the alien from the beginning, it's an easier watch. The visuals are great
97
Several-Target-1379 Mar 31, 2026 +21
It's also an incredible experience in 3D. Easily in the top 10 movies where this technology shines. When the space craft lights up, when we see those holograms - magic moment.
21
PVTZzzz Mar 31, 2026 +7
Yes exactly!
7
Raznilof Mar 31, 2026 +22
Agreed - it endures in a way some of the other films in the franchise don’t. Indeed some characters make “plot must go up“ short term decisions that don’t seem to be in/character - but despite that disconnect (or inability to sell it as confusion or stress, which is where the first film shined) it looks, sounds and feels serious and convincing throughout. In the best Scott tradition, the setting and spaces are presented as another character.
22
InertiaCreeping Mar 31, 2026 +7
I just pretend there’s a gas leak on the ship.
7
emperorOfTheUniverse Mar 31, 2026 +7
The score saves it.
7
RosbergThe8th Mar 31, 2026 +2
Yeah, its one of those movies I really desperately wish was better because the feel of it just delightful. The pitch felt custom crafted for me to love and that initial trailer had it looking like exactly my thing. Just wish the actual substance was better.
2
BrightLuchr Mar 31, 2026 +2
I do like this movie a lot. But every time I watch it I think... why not just park the space ship closer? Did they need to walk all that way in the storm? Were the spots closer to the entrance handicap parking?
2
RonnieD63 Mar 31, 2026 +227
Did you read the engineer dialogue that was cut from the release? Fascinating. 
227
larrylurk3r Mar 31, 2026 +60
Link?
60
angelofox Mar 31, 2026 +186
I don't know of a link but I do remember the gist of it. Basically he states that Jesus was an alien sent to tell mankind of their creators, the Engineers, and man crucified him. The actual dialogue is cooler but it does come off as preachy so I think it was the right decision to cut it, but it's still neat. Edit: I get it, some fanfic dialogue is fake but there is a connection between the Engineers and Jesus. He was either going to be one of them or taught by them. Either way it doesn't matter, it was going to be a deeper plot point and confirmed by the director Ridley Scott.
186
brainkandy87 Mar 31, 2026 +56
Kinda neat, never knew that. At the same time I agree, good cut. All I’m thinking about is, did this alien have to wear a wig and fake facial hair? Like they’re all bald right? He’d stick out like one of those early model rubber skinned Terminators.
56
LWM-PaPa Mar 31, 2026 +77
From what I've heard on a couple film podcasts it wasn't that Jesus was an engineer himself but a human the engineers taught their knowledge to. Mankind rejected old JC then one thing led to another and now we eat chocolate eggs on a holiday that changes date every year.
77
jerog1 Mar 31, 2026 +21
Amen
21
FrogBoglin Mar 31, 2026 +2
Yeah chocolate eggs f****** rule
2
angelofox Mar 31, 2026 +35
Lol, no he didn't wear a wig or a skin suit or anything weird. Remember, that the Engineers created man according to the movie's original feature so mankind's ancestry originates from an alien, the Engineers not the Xenomorph. I think the same virgin birth story would apply except here it would have been an Engineer that would have impregnated Mary, miraculously. The Engineers were way more advanced and superior to humans in every way.
35
Low_External9118 Mar 31, 2026 +16
This concept deserves its own movie to elaborate further. Glad they left it alone to be honest.
16
rabidsalvation Mar 31, 2026 +4
There are several different versions of various scene. A lot of stuff never even got filmed, but some did and didn't make the final cut. I've read parts of the various screenplays, and they are wild as hell. It's no surprise the movie is so messy
4
DarksteelPenguin Mar 31, 2026 +3
The modern representation of Jesus is not based on any historical (or even biblical) elements.
3
badken Mar 31, 2026 +31
This was not “cut from the release” … it’s the fan fic that wouldn’t die. There was a screenplay with that Jesus stuff in it, but it was written by a fan. Presumably written after watching the movie extras, which included extensive interviews with screenwriter Spaihts. In one of the interviews, or maybe in his commentary, don’t remember which, he mentions that early in preproduction they had considered the Jesus thing. Right away both he and Scott agreed it was too on the nose.
31
Vanquisher1000 Mar 31, 2026 +5
The part about Jesus being a human baby taken and raised by Engineers comes from that fake script, but I know that Scott confirmed the link to Jesus in an interview in 2012. >**Movies.com:** You throw religion and spirituality into the equation for *Prometheus*, though, and it almost acts as a hand grenade. We had heard it was scripted that the Engineers were targeting our planet for destruction because we had crucified one of their representatives, and that Jesus Christ might have been an alien. Was that ever considered? >**RS**: We definitely did, and then we thought it was a little too on the nose. But if you look at it as an "our children are misbehaving down there" scenario, there are moments where it looks like we’ve gone out of control, running around with armor and skirts, which of course would be the Roman Empire. And they were given a long run. A thousand years before their disintegration actually started to happen. And you can say, "Lets’ send down one more of our emissaries to see if he can stop it." Guess what? They crucified him.  Source: [Dialogue: Sir Ridley Scott Explains 'Prometheus,' Explores Our Past, and Teases Future 'Alien' Stories | Movie News | Movies.com](https://web.archive.org/web/20120614074942/http://www.movies.com/movie-news/ridley-scott-prometheus-interview/8232)
5
renaldomoon Mar 31, 2026 +4
I mean if you're paying attention to the movie you can surmise. They say that they sent that ship to Earth about 2000 years ago.
4
BrightLuchr Mar 31, 2026 +2
I love the original Jesus plot premise but it seemed like they backed out from using that. It suits the religious undertone of most of Ridley Scott's scifi. It would probably offend people.
2
opacitizen Mar 31, 2026 +2
~~https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rFjTxnb2l04~~ **edit**: deleted the link as the script it discusses is apparently fake. see u/TheEasterFox 's comment and link below. (sorry, TIL)
2
TheEasterFox Apr 1, 2026 +2
Unfortunately that's from a fake script. See [https://www.listnook.com/r/LV426/comments/108ddn8/prometheus\_the\_fake\_script\_kroft\_talks\_about/](https://www.listnook.com/r/LV426/comments/108ddn8/prometheus_the_fake_script_kroft_talks_about/)
2
SqueezyCheez85 Mar 31, 2026 +15
I thought a lot of that was basically fan fiction. Somebody correct me if I'm wrong.
15
ObiHobit Mar 31, 2026 +7
You're not.
7
Minereon Mar 31, 2026 +136
I’ve lost count how many times I’ve rewatched this. All I need to do is think about the breathtaking first landing scene with the ship soaring slowly over the alien landscape and I have to see it again.
136
epichuntarz Mar 31, 2026 +21
I saw it in IMAX and everything up to the ship landing was some of the best shit I've ever seen on a big screen. Then like...the characters start like...doing shit and talking to each other more and it only goes downhill from there.
21
tetrahedronss Mar 31, 2026 +32
That scene was really awesome seen in theater.
32
kevinnoir Mar 31, 2026 +12
Thats the exact scene I think about any time someone mentions the movie and it makes me want to put it on again!
12
Particular_Wear_6960 Mar 31, 2026 +4
I've got the Blu-Ray. Me and my dad say it in theaters and loved it. One of the few action horror movies that really had me freaking out. I'll never forget the experience of the freaking C-Section scene. Whoa man, that has me squirming around in me seat.
4
CarolingianDruid Mar 31, 2026 +19
I am a sucker for the Alien universe. Love the mystique and universe building of it all.
19
Historical_Leg5998 Mar 31, 2026 +233
The biggest problem with Prometheus was the desire/need to have it in the Alien universe. There was a really, REALLY good, original sci-fi movie in there somewhere (especially the original script that had a more religious flavour) but all of that was squandered on the altar of cramming it into an existing franchise.
233
Lazlow_Morphine Mar 31, 2026 +66
The original script seemed to explain a lot of the stupid decisions the characters make, I just wish these movies weren’t based around the android so much I really don’t care about David or Walter would rather they weren’t so much the focus. And are the characters in covenant dumber than Prometheus? It’d be a close tie for stupidest scientists in movies
66
froyork Mar 31, 2026 +30
>And are the characters in covenant dumber than Prometheus? I'd say they're less dumb but they actually get punished this time around for making the same dumb mistake at the beginning by taking their helmets off. The Prometheus guys are supposed to be professionals that just keep making a bunch of monumentally stupid decisions that shouldn't make sense given their background.
30
epichuntarz Mar 31, 2026 +26
The reason the original Alien works so well is that the characters are so believable and relatable. They're literally a space tugboat crew. They talk to each other like real people. They have real life concerns. "But what about the shares?" They're just like us. But also, they're thrown into a mission they're completely and wholly unprepared for...first contact. They're not qualified for this. Not even the science robot (that we only find out is a science robot placed there by the corporation later in the movie) is qualified for this, none of them are. They have to use whatever tools they have on the ship and pray that's enough. There's a hierachy, a command structure that comes into play regarding quaranting a potentially infected individual as opposed to Charlize Theron just being angy and mad and in charge because she said so!!! We would actually expect a crewmember of the Nostromo to f*** up and do something wrong because they're not biologists, botanists, archaeologists, philosophers...and this is why the horror aspect of Alien works so well. Everyone pushes the theory that the crew of the Prometheus is a bunch of idiots on purpose, but nothing in the script insinuates or suggests this and it's total headcanon (like the aliens in Signs being demons).
26
Roadside_Prophet Mar 31, 2026 +18
Keep in mind, the crew in prometheus signed up for a trip that was going to cost a large chunk of their life and guaranteed they will never see anyone they know ever again. Despite what they say about bringing only the best people, a job like that is going to attract desperate and unstable individuals. The real tops of their fields are still on earth with their families.
18
froyork Mar 31, 2026 +24
>The real tops of their fields are still on earth with their families. It's not even a matter of being top their field, remember that map guy with those neat drones that was mapping out the ship from the start? Yeah, he's the one that gets completely lost somehow. The biologist? Yeah, he gets done in by putting his face right into a very unfriendly looking snake-like goo monster. Also they just take an engineer head and zap it until it explodes because...maybe they somehow knew the audience was watching and wanted to show us something cool I guess???
24
Familiar-Banana-8116 Mar 31, 2026 +3
I have been pointing this out since the movie came out. No one on that ship was 'top of his field'. Maybe the pilot. Maybe. They were the lowest bidder. All of them. This was a vanity project for a dead founder, the board threw only as much money at the project as they had to. This movie forces the viewer to play very close attention to every little detail to flesh anything out. It is a flaw in the movie. They did those stupid things because you get what you pay for and they were the lowest bidders.
3
epichuntarz Mar 31, 2026 +13
> This was a vanity project for a dead founder, the board threw only as much money at the project as they had to. Completely disagree. This is Weyland's ONE chance at potentially meeting his maker and maybe gaining life eternal, he's not going with the lowest bidder because...why would he? He's f****** Weyland...he can afford this. He can afford to bring a crew that will give him the best shot at achieving his end. He's low-balling everything just to have some dumbass petting a space snake, or a rogue robot putting black goo in a random person's drink, to ruin it all. The simpler explanation for the shit script is that they wrote a shit script that just contradicts itself all over. If the movie wanted us to bellieve your theory, it needed to just come out and say it, because otherwise believing as much is just headcanon.
13
Wes_Warhammer666 Mar 31, 2026 +2
>Maybe the pilot. I always kinda figured Janek truly was a top guy, *but* that he likely had a black mark of some sort on his record which is why a job like this is the only kind he can get. Dude is one of the only truly competent people in the film, and his willingness to make a kamikaze run lends credibility to the idea that he's trying to make up for something. Maybe that's just all in my head, but I definitely got the vibe that he's uniquely qualified amongst the ragtag team in the film.
2
Roadside_Prophet Mar 31, 2026 +3
You mean the guy who sees a giant storm coming upon them and abandons his post to go have sex? Whats funny, is you're probably still correct that he's the most competent person on the crew, its just a very very low bar.
3
BigTool Mar 31, 2026 +5
> and abandons his post to go have sex? I mean, it was with Charlize Theron so ....
5
Wes_Warhammer666 Mar 31, 2026 +2
I never said he was perfect. And as the other guy said, it *was* Charlize...
2
epichuntarz Mar 31, 2026 +8
There is a zero percent chance Weyland brings a dummy crew that will, in any way, endanger his chance at meeting his maker. This is largely why the movies crashes and burns. Weyland would have no problem finding "the best of the best" who weren't total nimrods to go on this mission. Like, this mission is likely going to challenge everything humans know about everything, he can find better people than Beavis and Butthead to crew his ship.
8
DarksteelPenguin Mar 31, 2026 +2
That is a fair point... shame the movie never really emphasizes or uses this beyond dumb decisions.
2
tdasnowman Mar 31, 2026 +2
It's funny how much people complain about taking the helmets off when it has 0 impact on what happened. It's a misdirect. There are 0 deaths or infections due to not having a helmet on. They discuss how bad an idea it is. Do it, then the moment there is anything suspicious they put them back on. If they kept them on the entire time everything still would have happened. >The Prometheus guys are supposed to be professionals that just keep making a bunch of monumentally stupid decisions that shouldn't make sense given their background. Even with their background they are still human. They were confronted by what many would consider the impossible. None of the scientific crew outside the Shaws were aware of the true mission. They signed up for some back water planet survey wake up and are told oh by the way we are here to explore the possibility of intelligent alien life. This is the last wish of the arguably most important person on earth. And then the actually find proof of an alien civilization. That's gonna knock a lot of people off their game. Professional or not they didn't sign up for that mission, may have never wanted to sign up for that mission, and likely would be struggling with the implications.
2
Maeglin75 Mar 31, 2026 +13
The movies need to have some kind of plot besides the (proto) xenomorphs. Even the original Alien recognized that a (more or less) mindless alien that kills one crewmember after the other isn't enough, and added the Ash/evil corporation subplot. The xenomorph is an iconic monster but ultimately not a very interesting antagonist, because it lacks emotions and complex motivation. And it gets less interesting the more we learn about it. Maybe Prometheus and Covenant could have put less focus on the synths and more, for example, on the Engineers. But in my opinion Scott completely dropped the ball in that regard, making the mysterious Space Jokey into a big pale human. And even if he made better choices, I think, the less we know about the mystery of this ancient alien race the better.
13
Lazlow_Morphine Mar 31, 2026 +2
I agree with you and that is a great point.
2
die-jarjar-die Mar 31, 2026 +2
Totally agree. The Engineers are so much more interesting than the Xenomorphs.
2
TokiStark Mar 31, 2026 +5
They were capitalising on Michael Fassbender
5
pasher5620 Mar 31, 2026 +9
Covenant’s characters are largely better at making decisions save for taking off their helmets. Unfortunately that one decision caused a cascading effect that ended up killing them. If those neomorphs never get created, enough of them are alive that David never gets the chance to create the Protomorph, or if he is able to, they have enough to kill it and then kill David.
9
Blackadder18 Mar 31, 2026 +10
>Covenant’s characters are largely better at making decisions save for taking off their helmets. [It was the first TV tropes page to have a subpage for how stupid its characters acted lmao.](https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WhatAnIdiot/AlienCovenant)
10
pasher5620 Mar 31, 2026 +2
Imma be honest, that list reads like a CinemaSins blog post, with most of them relying on the characters making the perfect decision and behave completely rationale at all times despite what is happening to them. Most of the ones that are actually valid are about all the stuff in the beginning, which is stuff I largely already agreed with in other posts. Once shit hits the fan, the characters all make about the best decisions as can be expected with the information they have.
2
Meet-me-behind-bins Mar 31, 2026 +18
I watched Covenant again a couple of night ago. The first 30 minutes are almost a comedy. The acting is laughably bad and their decision making is so stupid that I almost started laughing. It’s a ridiculous film. So dumb. The only good thing about it is the Fassbender bits.
18
pasher5620 Mar 31, 2026 +8
Eh, I do genuinely like the introduction of the Neomorph. It’s a great evolution of the original Alien lifecycle and its portrayal is particularly painful looking. The Protomorph is a bit disappointing as it doesn’t feel particularly unique to the Xenomorph, but it is still used well so I’ll give it that. But yeah, the beginning of the movie is almost detached in how stupid the characters act and their motivations. Honestly, the entire reason for their landing being that they heard music was just painfully dumb. I’d have rather they crash landed or it was their destination planet to begin with over them just happening upon it by chance.
8
Meet-me-behind-bins Mar 31, 2026 +2
It’s a shame really. There was a good film in there somewhere. Just needed a better first act, some better casting and a few tweaks of the script. I’m really surprised that it got through pre-release screening without someone demanding a new first act. But then again I’m not sure Ridley Scott gave shit at that point.
2
umbium Mar 31, 2026 +5
one character died by slipping in blood c'mon. I just hate when cool movies have to be made into horror movies. Even if this is alien, this trilogy could be just about engineers, what is to be a creator and the responsability of it. And in the last movie the alien reveal. That could be fantastic.
5
MaxRichter_Enjoyer Mar 31, 2026 +2
It would have been so simple to solve this: "Yeah Cap, scanners show the right amount of oh-two and no issues on the bio-hazard scanner." "Got it, thanks, f****** hate when we have to wear these helmets" ANYTHING LIKE THAT. Could be done and addressed in a 5-second clip.
2
pasher5620 Mar 31, 2026 +2
I’m pretty sure they do say that the atmosphere is breathable on the ship, but that was still only a ship scan. I don’t think I’d have taken off my helmet until I had on the ground confirmation after at least walking around for a bit.
2
epichuntarz Mar 31, 2026 +2
> Covenant’s characters are largely better at making decisions save for taking off their helmets. And looking at weird, pulsating wet eggs.
2
Quantentheorie Mar 31, 2026 +6
I actually thinkt problem with the David/Walter character is that they don't commit. I love a good Alien-Universe female protagonist, but Prometheus and Covenant both don't give us a Ripley to root for, while pushing Fassbenders roles into the foreground without making him the main character. In Prometheus there is all this setup about Waylands actual daughter being angry and driven by how much she's pushed back for his "artificial son" and they don't commit to this plotline enough to let her flesh herself out as antagonist. Had they explored that more, the "turn" David takes in Covenant could have set up more organically and as a more coherent next step from where we leave him in Prometheus. These movies just have a bad habit of giving characters simplified motivations that they then act on in ways we don't relate to and that are primarily used to set up either an action scene or confusing, but arguably aesthetic shot.
6
MaxRichter_Enjoyer Apr 1, 2026 +2
Really well said! Yeah, Charlize Theron was wasted here.
2
cefriano Mar 31, 2026 +12
Ehh… of all my problems with Prometheus, the fact that it’s set in the Alien universe isn’t really one of them. Could it have worked well as a standalone sci-fi movie? Sure. But I also think it works as an expansion of the Alien mythos.
12
byPCP Mar 31, 2026 +7
i actually knew nothing about prometheus and assumed it was just a sci-fi flick and watched it on a whim. i enjoyed it and only realized it was an alien movie at the very end lol. so i don't necessarily agree that it being put in the alien universe detracted from it.
7
succsforever Mar 31, 2026 +10
Hell yeah. Alien is all about "we don't know where this came from" And we don't need to know. I think he blew it with Prometheus and the rest
10
SiriusC Mar 31, 2026 +6
>Alien is all about "we don't know where this came from" Alien is "*all about*" not knowing where it's from? What does this even mean? It's about way more than just this single aspect of the film.
6
thrillho145 Mar 31, 2026 +8
Yeah if they had changed some of the dumb behaviour of the trained specialist astronauts (touching alien plants, taking off your helmet) as well as not force it into the Alien universe, it xould have been great. I still love it though
8
Status_Wrongdoer_152 Mar 31, 2026 +5
I totally agree but I don't think it would've done as well financially if it wasn't connected.
5
NOTcreative- Mar 31, 2026 +2
The only difference would have been the story connection. It was still a Ridley Scott film and had he not connected the stories there would be a bunch of fan theories. It was connected regardless being the same director.
2
abagofdicks Mar 31, 2026 +2
Not really. The best parts were the ship and the engineer. The worst parts (besides the dumb characters) was that they hardly did anything with the alien parts and it seemed liked they intentionally dodged it. If it didn’t have a storm derail the plot and had it let the characters actually dig and learn about the ship, it would’ve been excellent.
2
Vanquisher1000 Mar 31, 2026 +2
*Prometheus did* start life as an *Alien* prequel, but during development it turned into something else and became a new story that just happened to be set in the *Alien* universe. Ridley Scott wanted to go even further away from *Alien* in *Prometheus 2,* saying in 2014 that "the best is done. Cooked;" but Fox would have been aware of *Alien* fans criticising *Prometheus* for its lack of *Alien,* and when Neil Blomkamp announced his plan to make a sequel to *Aliens* and released concept artworks, Fox would have also seen that fans responded positively to the news. What I think happened is that Scott compromised and agreed to turn *Prometheus 2* into an *Alien* movie so he could retain some creative control, and that's how we got *Alien: Covenant.*
2
zeekaran Mar 31, 2026 +2
> There was a really, REALLY good, original sci-fi movie in there somewhere It's based on Lovecraft's _At the Mountains of Madness_. I don't think the plot even makes sense without having read it. A live action movie of AtMoM would be great and it's too bad this sort of cancelled any chance of us getting it.
2
kuuups Mar 31, 2026 +74
One of my favorites as well. I just love the "point of no return" / marooned in space type of movies. Idgaf if its wifely panned.
74
SimilarSimian Mar 31, 2026 +54
Wives. Always panning things.
54
Legitimate_First Mar 31, 2026 +15
Stop looking for gold in that river and review this Ridley Scott movie with me.
15
CuffMcGruff Mar 31, 2026 +37
Overwhelmingly negative reviews from wives
37
nendu367 Mar 31, 2026 +6
Yep.. that is also my favourite genre. Landing on an unknown planet, exploring & they find something sinister there. This is why Riddick series is my favourite as well.
6
kuuups Mar 31, 2026 +5
Got really bummed out that Raised by Wolves got cancelled by HBO
5
catalystxxx Mar 31, 2026 +3
Got any any recs? I love The Martian and Prometheus.
3
nendu367 Mar 31, 2026 +2
If you liked prometheus, watch the sequels too.. Covenant & Romulus. They are also about planet exploring. Other than that, here are couple movies.. 1. Riddick Series >> Pitch Black (2000), The Chronicles of Riddick (2004), Riddick (2013). The second movies isn't really planet exploring, but to understand the 3rd one, you need to watch it. 2. Annihilation (2018) 3. Europa Report (2013) 4. Life (2017) 5. Event Horizon (1997) 6. Predators (2010) 7. Alien (1979)
2
ItsScaryTerryBitch Apr 1, 2026 +3
Annihilation is incredible, and while it isn't exactly "planet exploring", it certainly feels like it given the circumstances and area that's explored. Cannot recommend it enough, but fair warning some parts are a bit disturbing. I watched it while high the first time and will unfortunately never experience that beauty/horror ever again.
3
Notak_bo Mar 31, 2026 +64
I loved it when I first saw in theaters and still do.
64
neohanime Mar 31, 2026 +17
That intro was great with the soundtrack and grand feeling of the universe, but lots of stupid characters doing stupid things like you said. Still fun movie to watch from time to time.
17
Extension_Big6747 Mar 31, 2026 +69
Ya know my PRIMARY complaint about this show? It had a lot of good and some dumb going for it. But when it dumbed, it REALLY dumbed. Suspension of disbelief level dumb. Here's ONE example. The map guy and the biology guy find a funny space snake. One guy says hey let's be careful. The other guy says " will be fine I'ma touchy". Death happens. Another guy freaks the f*** out. He's a scientist not a soldier. He wtf noped out. Then gets lost cause he has no map and no sense of direction... Reasonable enough. But who do you think touched the danger noodle when he was told not to, and who do you think got lost cause he didn't know where to go? Obviously map guy touched the sneaky snek and bio dude got lost in the maze right? Noooooo. Bio dude forgets everything he should know about xenobiology and like being careful. Map guy forgets his map. Literally you could have had the same plot and just shuffled characters around and been pretty compelling. But nooo. Instead, every single one of the super specialized crew in who have no reason at all to be competent in anyone else's field.... Fucks up ONLY THEIR FIELD. Like... Literally keep the same plot and shuffle the deck. Could have been a satisfying show of competent overspecialization being bad sometimes. Instead.... Every " smart guy" is exposed to exactly what he's good at.... The. Fucks it up. Damn that killed it for me.
69
Extension_Big6747 Mar 31, 2026 +23
They made every smart guy exactly stupid at their ONE JOB... Instead of dying to the job they brought another smart guy to be good at. Fucks sake. So close.
23
Victernus Mar 31, 2026 +15
And this happening specifically in an *Alien* prequel, the movie full of professionals making reasonable mistakes in the face of the unknown.
15
BamBodZ Mar 31, 2026 +17
Yeah, and in the original Alien the Nostromo is just a cargo ship. Like it’s truly incredible how much dumber and reckless these supposed world class scientists looking for alien life are than the crew of a tug boat in space.
17
SpehlingAirer Mar 31, 2026 +3
Map guy also got high to calm down, which at least helps explain his own decisions haha
3
mermaidrampage Mar 31, 2026 +3
My theory is that they are supposed to be incompeten.  The entire expedition is a front for Weyland's true purpose to go meet the engineers and figure out how to prolong his life. He just hired the cheapest "professionals" he could who he knew would want to take a less-than-desirable job like this.  
3
arazamatazguy Mar 31, 2026 +15
I'm still trying to figure out why the creators were totally ripped? Did they work out a lot? With that kind of technology why did they have big muscles?
15
greebly_weeblies Mar 31, 2026 +36
They're The Engineers! How can the answer not be "good genetics"
36
arazamatazguy Mar 31, 2026 +10
Because they were bald.
10
ineyeseekay Mar 31, 2026 +8
Exactly. God-like, duh!
8
PRSArchon Mar 31, 2026 +18
They are a different species, just like a silver back gorilla is shredded without ever training a day of its life.
18
dwpea66 Mar 31, 2026 +5
Bangable aliens are a time-honored tradition
5
MalIntenet Mar 31, 2026 +2
Maybe gravity is stronger on their home planet so they need the extra muscles (idk if that makes sense scientifically lol)
2
bliceroquququq Mar 31, 2026 +53
It's a visually striking film, filled with talented actors, that is terribly conceived and horribly written.
53
AnonMuskkk Mar 31, 2026 +31
I concur. Then Scott said “You think that's bad? Hold My Beer” and made Covenant.
31
DarksteelPenguin Mar 31, 2026 +8
I don't think I know any director who has as much of a split between their best and worse movies as Ridley Scott. Like, I know Spielberg made Indiana Jones 4 and Jurassic Park, but I still can't wrap my mind around the fact that Blade Runner and Covenant are from the same guy.
8
zeekaran Mar 31, 2026 +3
Alien, and Alien: Covenant, being the same guy is shocking on its own.
3
DarksteelPenguin Mar 31, 2026 +3
Also the same guy who made Gladiator and Gladiator 2.
3
zeekaran Mar 31, 2026 +2
I'm just so happy that Denis Villeneuve exists and that he made BR2049.
2
Lunsj Mar 31, 2026 +5
Scott Ridleys greatest sin is Covenant. I’m one of those who love Prometheus, and I was so excited for the next movie, hoping it would follow Elizabeth’s journey. Instead he had to add horror flick elements to get a bigger audience and totally butcher the lore and story.
5
VibrantCanopy Mar 31, 2026 +7
Written by Damon Lindelof, writer of Lost. I should have known better.
7
Newez Mar 31, 2026 +43
I wish we get an extended cut some day
43
monarc Mar 31, 2026 +23
Yeah the theatrical version is pretty clunky but the fan edits are killer IMO. There’s one called “Chaos Edition” that’s about as perfect as we could hope for. There are two subtle technical errors that *could have been* fixed by selectively muting audio (i.e. CO2 → CO) but the editor didn’t do that, sadly. In completely unrelated news, I am not averse to DMs.
23
Maximum_Shine_2474 Mar 31, 2026 +36
I absolutely hate this movie. I think it’s an abomination. The characters, the timeline that doesn't make any sense whatsoever, the overall illogical nonsense, I could go on all day. And yet, every time it pops up on a streaming service, I end up watching the whole thing usually while yelling at the TV about how stupid it is. I don’t know what that means, but the fact that I keep coming back to it has to mean something
36
bozoconnors Mar 31, 2026 +2
lol - concur. I remember reading that it was finally coming out & was a prequel, probably centering around the engineers. My imagination ran wild with a sci-fi epic that didn't even have humans in it. Minimal subtitles as well. Instead, we got "idea! let's plug these energy leads into this severed alien head and increase the power until it EXPLODES!!! SCIENCE!!! BOOM!!"
2
Maximum_Shine_2474 Mar 31, 2026 +2
Haha!
2
monsooncloudburst Mar 31, 2026 +9
I was not sure about your post until I looked at the image. The image changes everything. Good that you focused on this image.
9
dakotanorth8 Mar 31, 2026 +44
…is the image…in the room with you? Also, the worlds leading biologist thinking a hissing snake means “it likes you” was a bridge too far for me. Edit: you said “LOOK AT THIS IMAGE” so it’s hard to have an actual discussion… There’s no image.
44
dub-fresh Mar 31, 2026 +20
Point out on this doll where the image touched you. 
20
Podgeman Mar 31, 2026 +12
This post reads like stealth marketing. As you say, there's no point of discussion. It's one paragraph of "Don't question, consume product." Don't be surprised if an Alien-related announcement is released soon.
12
SpaceBowie2008 Mar 31, 2026 +5
Yeah bots but I can’t tell since the kids raised on iPads from birth are starting to use listnook too. Listnook has become a cesspool of corporate promotion, bots and people who haven’t socialized in person.
5
acros198d Mar 31, 2026 +4
Seems like there’s been more frequent Prometheus related posts the past week or so. Was thinking the same thing that this is some kind or promotion or feeling out interest in another film.
4
maximum_oblex Mar 31, 2026 +5
Point of contention but he isn't the world's leading biologist. Prometheus's crew are explicitly the academics desperate enough to join a highly secretive decades long interstellar mission. It doesn't fully explain their incompetence, but does marginally justify its position. Besides the Covenant's crew make the Prometheus's look like geniuses.
5
Legitimate_First Mar 31, 2026 +3
> Besides the Covenant's crew make the Prometheus's look like geniuses. They *really* don't. "Hey let's all take our helmets off. Hey someone immediately started getting sick, surely there's no correlation between those completely separate events."
3
ToastGoblin22 Mar 31, 2026 +9
I liked it when I saw it in high school but nowadays I think it’s lacklustre at best and obviously completely nonsensical at worst. Much has been said on this though so I won’t beat this very dead horse. For some reason my girlfriend loves this movie too though lol, which is bizarre because she’s not really into sci-fi, and on the whole I would probably say that she has a more ‘refined palate’ when it comes to movies. Usually I’m the one that’s willing to give a ‘dumb’ movie a pass purely because I found it to be fun, but not her. This movie is the one exception to the rule haha.
9
Inside-Bunch4216 Mar 31, 2026 +3
If they just made the characters not do stupid things it would have been almost perfect. Its still a good film but just disapoints with the dumb characters.
3
I_ama_Borat Mar 31, 2026 +3
It seriously doesn’t feel like it came out 14 years ago
3
Odd_Contact_2175 Mar 31, 2026 +3
Well... I'm glad someone liked the movie at least.
3
RandomStrategy Mar 31, 2026 +3
I'll be the bad guy here. As good as some of the performances were, it was the real end of the Aliens franchise for me, personally. Not to say AvP and those c*** movies were good, just that the entire poont of the Xenomorph was something incomprehensible to us in almost every way...Aliens made the mistake of making them relatable similar to ants in societal structure, but at least it was well done. Prometheus took all that mystery and scariness away, now they're just CRISPR on steroids.Also, it wasn't an actual Aliens movie, it was some dumbass ancient aliens book that the studio demanded he make another Alien film and he wanted to do his ancient aliens instead. IDK, if you like it, cool, not my deal, the series dtops at Aliens for me. Maybe Alien 3, but that's pushing it.
3
milkmon1 Mar 31, 2026 +7
This film is horribly written. Damon Lindelof is just a very bad and lazy writer who creates inexplicable gaps in his stories and never offers details and claims it’s “ambiguous” when really he leaves the audience to do the work…
7
Cruel2BEkind12 Mar 31, 2026 +4
Honestly I absolutely love the first 35 or so minutes of that movie. Just the exploration, shots of the ship and landing. It makes a great sci-fi adventure before the aliens and inept crew decisions bring the movie down.
4
RickyMAustralia Mar 31, 2026 +14
I frigging HATE this movie confusing nonsensical badly edited nothing burger of a movie Sincerely Alien franchise megafan
14
Data_Chandler Mar 31, 2026 +9
I'm a happier person pretending Prometheus and Covenant don't exist!
9
RickyMAustralia Mar 31, 2026 +6
Yeah same For me its not Canon Romulus was decent and even alien earth was ok and fits in the universe I was litrally angry walking out the cinema when I saw it lol
6
Storm1k Mar 31, 2026 +2
You know, after watching Alien Earth, I don't feel so bad about Prometheus and Covenant anymore. At least Ridley knows how to film...something. AE was just tragically bad. I really hoped to see something good about it until the very end but it was nothing but disappointment.
2
kaskayde Mar 31, 2026 +5
I watched this when it came out and I remember sort of just being confused and not thinking much of it. I can't remember any of it now other than that Michael Fassbender was in it. Maybe I should rewatch it.
5
cuntrolaltdelete Mar 31, 2026 +14
It’s still just as bad and forgettable
14
blahblah19999 Mar 31, 2026 +3
Spare yourself an aneurysm
3
conscientiousrevolt Mar 31, 2026 +5
Damn bro that shit sucked lmao
5
TheKrakenLord Mar 31, 2026 +5
I hate how everything is so high tech when it takes place DECADES before Alien. Did technology devolve????
5
Mynameisbebopp Mar 31, 2026 +5
Oh boy. Don’t we all have a soft spot for the Prometheus school of running away from things.
5
nofranchise Mar 31, 2026 +5
Another post about loving this stupid mess of a film? It has to be marketing by now. But for what!?
5
LunchyDude101 Mar 31, 2026 +3
I too am a graduate of the Prometheus School of Running ina Straight Line Away from Massive Rolling Objects.
3
Ishvale Mar 31, 2026 +3
I gotta turn in a meh for this one.
3
dumbBunny9 Mar 31, 2026 +5
I don’t like it, for all the reasons you listed and more. Can you tell me why you like it? What is good or entertaining about it for you?
5
nemojakonemoras Mar 31, 2026 +2
Ah yes, the namesake of the movie inspired school of running away from things.
2
Phantommy555 Mar 31, 2026 +4
I’ve always liked it. Yes it has its flaws. The one criticism I never got though was about Milburn trying to pet the Hammerpede and that no biologist would be that stupid. Like have they might any biologists(or just people)? Humans have an insatiable curiosity that ventures into hubris. There are so many examples of people irl trying to handle venomous snakes or other dangerous wild animals even though they should have “known better”.
4
WhatPayne Mar 31, 2026 +7
When I was studying biology, we definitely had some people who would have happily stuck their face to some unknown hissing alien snake, had they have the chance. They had very little self preservation when it came to curiosity... Most of those people did not end up graduating. But some did. And some of those people were our professors, telling us these really crazy stories about dangerous encounters.
7
monarc Mar 31, 2026 +9
Haha exactly. There's [a deleted scene](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHat2vtcfzU) that explains Milburn's behavior really nicely. He sees a tiny, harmless worm... and he's over the moon since it's the first time anyone has encountered alien life that wasn't just some microbe. It builds his character and prepares us for him being naive during the later encounter. FYI /u/Phantommy555
9
StuntID Mar 31, 2026 +2
It's a collection of brilliant short stories, with a few stinkers in the mix. Stitched together like a corpse after an autopsy with all the pieces thrown in the chest willy-nilly. Brilliant bits do not a great movie make when thrown together with trash.
2
Nautilidae1 Mar 31, 2026 +2
Seeing it in 3D at midnight at my local multiplex remains one of my favorite theatrical experiences. I had just seen Blade Runner and Alien for the first time, and I had peaked at Roger Ebert’s gushing four-star review, so I was primed to love it before I ever walked in. I was so swept up in the vastness of its world that I genuinely didn’t notice any of the flaws. Seeing it at home diminished the film’s shimmer for me in a number of areas, sadly, but I still love it for all the things it does get right, the painterly visuals in particular. >! The abortion scene still churns my stomach in the most satisfying way. !<
2
← Back to Board