A leader who can't handle satire is a weak leader.
832
ai99091 day ago
+281
That is one thing, but acting to suppress satire and freedom of speech is something worse..
281
alematt1 day ago
+136
Part of the fascist playbook
136
ai99091 day ago
+25
And it's American corporations delivering on the censorship requests. Land of the Free indeed.
25
alematt1 day ago
+13
America has been doing a great job using the playbook and adding to it
13
Major-Tom-21121 day ago
-8
How so exactly?? Please be specific.
-8
alematt1 day ago
+8
Authoritarian Rhetoric and Actions: Comparisons are drawn to fascist leaders regarding the use of dehumanizing language against political opponents and the press, including describing them as "enemies of the people".
Immigration and Nationalism: Policies such as family separations and calls for mass deportations, combined with white nationalist rhetoric, as an effort to define the nation through a narrow, exclusionary lens.
Erosion of Democratic Norms: Efforts to overturn the 2020 election, the Jan. 6 Capitol attack, and the questioning of electoral legitimacy and dismantling democratic checks and balances.
Use of State Power:Militarization of law enforcement agencies like Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and their use to target specific groups.
Cult of Personality: The development of a fervent, loyal base around Donald Trump—the MAGA movement—is analyzed by some experts as aligning with a cult of personality often seen in fascist movements.
I can do more but I'd doubt anyone who loves Trump would not believe anything negative about their precious leader.
8
rbb361 day ago
+4
> I can do more but I'd doubt anyone who loves Trump would not believe anything negative about their precious leader.
A recent meta-study - titled, "Responses to Belief-Conflicting Information: Justification of Support for Donald Trump" - supports your belief that contradictory information regarding Donald Trump is likely to be disregarded by his supporters.
* https://www.psypost.org/cognitive-dissonance-helps-explain-why-trump-supporters-remain-loyal-new-research-suggests/
* https://jspp.psychopen.eu/index.php/jspp/article/view/16085
4
alematt9 hr ago
+2
Yah I know, but damnit if even one can be reached it's progress
2
rbb367 hr ago
+2
Right on, friend - we gotta keep pushing in the right direction. Orban lost; it does work sometimes.
2
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
-70
In this case, it’s not so simple as to to knee-jerk blame the govt, because it’s become so much more difficult to differentiate between the guy living in Delhi, poking fun at the PM satirically. And the guys from Pakistan/China/Turkey troll army spreading disinformation to create unrest, manufacture riots and tension among the populace and deepen divisions in society.
The govt has a duty to protect and prevent bad actors from hostile nations advancing their agendas in the country; and propaganda from adversaries is a form of cyber warfare, that the state needs to act upon. But how do we know the govt isn’t overreaching and going after dissent as well? It’s just not as easy and cut and dry as many think.
IMO the death of free speech online was finalized with the advent of social media.
Edit: man all I’m saying is that there is more than one thing to consider, and maybe reading or knowing about the details is better than jumping to conclusions? I’m being downvoted for saying just that?
-70
FuckMyLife20161 day ago
+39
Alright I'll bite. Why does it matter if non-Indian actors propagandize against Modi?
India's the biggest democracy (by number of voters) in the world isn't she? Her PMs will come and go as elections happen. How will propaganda against one PM destabilize the country?
Popular unrest means exactly that, popular. It'll happen regardless if crybaby leaders make laws to "plz stahp" criticizing them.
39
picastchio1 day ago
+26
The PM's cult of personality is built upon an army of trolls and mainstream channels worshiping him at prime time everyday. The PMO actively feeds the channels on what to run and how to spin it. Social media makes it harder. Now they want to let them run amok but restrict anyone who speaks up. Consider what Elon did to Twitter.
Very recent example: Teenagers were made to stand in this heat for hours to "welcome" the PM. A vlog exposing it was restricted by the govt. What national security problem would have it caused?
26
_AkasunaNoSasori1 day ago
+10
Yeah, we even have Mao's red guards. Gutka regiment will beat you to death if you speak against any leader.
10
Ny_takenover1 day ago
-5
Yeah it's all roses when UAE curtails misinformation and you cannot question the regime, but god forbid indians stand up against false propaganda and social media provocation by miscreants. I dare you to run your mouth in the UAE
-5
DescriptionDapper8071 day ago
+17
Whataboutism final boss.
Everything against the govt is f\*king false propoganda !!! You andhbhakts never fail to amaze me !
17
Ny_takenover1 day ago
-2
When you say things with "everything bla bla bla" that is a true example of whataboutism! I stated a fact and you responded with generalization.
-2
DescriptionDapper8071 day ago
+3
What fact did you state? Please enlighten me.
Cause I didn't see anything except you comparing India with UAE, which is whataboutism because nobody was talking/praising the situation of UAE anyways.
How is criticism of a politician propaganda?
3
FuckMyLife20161 day ago
+8
I will absolutely run my mouth "in the UAE" if it starts "acting" like it's a democracy. And you're really comparing your country to a repressive semi-religious absolute monarchy whose 90% population are temporary foreign workers, really?
And what's so good about standing up against "false propaganda and social media provocation by miscreants" against a person? I hear some of you guys don't like Indira Gandhi or even Mahatma Gandhi for some reason. I bet it'd grind some of your gears if you couldn't criticize them?
8
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
-1
If the criticism was provably false, I’d have no qualms with not being able to criticize those you mentioned. Truth should always be prioritized. But yes I agree comparing to UAE isn’t a good thing, you should always compare to those doing things better to improve. However, I don’t think you’re realizing the gravity of false propaganda: armed rebellions and insurgents are propped up and supported by hostile external forces, and this is one of the tools that they use. By stoking secession narratives based on false information is very dangerous to **any** govt. I think it’s just that when **only** the govt can determine what’s true or not is also dangerous to free thinking and free speech. There needs to be a check on govt overreach as well, but expecting the govt to do nothing about propaganda against the highest office is also naive IMO.
-1
Nerevarine911 day ago
+2
Tbh a superpower is actively trying to stoke separatism in the country where I live, but even that doesn’t make me approve of this sort of crackdown on satire
2
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
Which country? How many insurgent groups, armed rebellions and terrorist organizations are there? Any recent attacks? What’re the death tolls? Are the people demanding that the govt do something about it instead of shrugging and saying “well I know your family was slaughtered, but the we can’t disallow them from having a platform”? And you know for a fact that this satire was based on facts and not foreign funded or foreign organized?
0
Nerevarine911 day ago
+4
How many people are rioting and killing each other because someone posted a meme calling Modi a clown? Because, according to the article, that’s one that was removed. If I say Modi is a clown, should I be stopped by law?
4
Ny_takenover1 day ago
-1
Wars are no longer waged on land alone... Social media does hold a strong impact. Any ruling party should work towards monitoring it, period.
India being a vast diverse country definitely needs to control distorted facts. If this grinds your gears for some reason, so be it.
-1
crimsonhues1 day ago
+9
So you are comparing against another fascist country to normalize the censorship? That’s a weird flex. Maybe should have gone with North Korea in that case.
9
Ny_takenover1 day ago
How do you control hate violence sparked by someone sharing false videos of attacks on a certain community under a propoganda? What do you think should be a solution then to stop regional violence in a diverse country like india?
0
Nerevarine911 day ago
+2
Please explain specifically why you believe the tweet calling Modi a clown, which was removed by legal action, would cause regional violence
2
Nerevarine911 day ago
+3
Please find one person in this entire comment section who supports the UAE’s laws on that topic
3
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
-5
Riots, violence and crime along religious and ethnic lines can be sparked by such disinformation, resulting in the erosion of safety among normal citizens just wanting to get by. Just because something is popular doesn’t mean it should be allowed. In that vein, bigotry, racism, unscientific rhetoric if left unchecked, can lead to serious health and safety hazards. (Eg religious mobs and lynchings)
For example, if another country starts propaganda against a measles vaccine, and people start to avoid it, many children will die from a preventable disease. Stopping the spread of lies is in the interest of everyone that wants peace and truth to be prioritized in a society.
-5
FuckMyLife20161 day ago
+10
But the OP is not about measles vaccine is it? It's about India taking action against satirists mocking the PM.
10
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
-5
Blocking the accounts that spread disinformation has the same concept, it’s the spreading false information and AI deepfakes that the core issue, and that can be used on anything, whether unscientific views, or views to malign that aren’t based in the truth. And it’s not that I agree with everything that the govt is doing, but I can see that there are other concerns as well that many aren’t acknowledging compared to what most people are focusing on.
-5
Nerevarine911 day ago
+6
But it’s not about the measles vaccine, it’s about the PM. There’s nothing unscientific about telling jokes about him.
6
Scypher_Tzu1 day ago
-10
Because India is Incredibly diverse. Unlike videos of trump dancing with netanyahu Ai videos could literally incite so much bs. Its not about Indians mocking their pm its more about other countries trying to cause problems. No matter who the PM is external forces shoudnt be able to change any outcomes inside India
-10
FuckMyLife20161 day ago
+7
So you're saying Indians actually hate their PM. It's just his good guy image keeping the country together? Gotcha. You answered my question in your own way. Thanks.
7
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
-1
***”its more about other countries trying to cause problems. No matter who the PM is external forces shoudnt be able to change any outcomes inside India”***, I think you glossed over this important part of their comment.
-1
Nerevarine911 day ago
+2
But the people stopped from mocking the PM were Indian citizens, including an elected official
2
OccamPhaser1 day ago
+6
You're being downvoted because NOTHING you said justifies this response from the government. Better to have a kneejerk reaction against the government than for it
6
Future-Analyst-667718 hr ago
The govt is made up of people too, with families and friends. Why are you treating it like some AI overlord akin to Skynet? Or is dehumanizing a govt of another country easier for you when the people look different?
0
OccamPhaser18 hr ago
It's not an ai overlord and I never said anything like that. You're just being emotional and dramatic because I disagreed with you and you don't have a good answer for your stance. I don't even look white at all so no it's because of appearance either. You're literally commenting on a post about a government leader trying to put a stop to jokes he doesn't like and defending those actions. It's just bootlicker behavior. No self respect.
0
crimsonhues1 day ago
+4
This guy has bought into all the Modi propaganda forwarded on WhatsApp
4
ai99091 day ago
+1
Naw, good point. Don't know what is up with the downvotes. Downvotes bury comments.. it's basically censorship in my books.
1
CthulhusSoreTentacle1 day ago
+82
Dictators don't fear the professor with statistics and arguments guided by reason. Dictators fear the drunk poet who tells a joke people remember.
Paraphrased (and horribly butchered) quote I read a few years ago.
82
Barry_Burton_19741 day ago
+37
Look at the whole Xi Dada Winnie the Pooh furore for a good example.
37
NoSwordfish19781 day ago
+21
Not suprising in his case because he's widely considered to be a narcissist and they can't bear to be made fun of in any way.
21
Academic_Idea131 day ago
+86
India ranks Number #1 for misinformation and disinformation according to Statista.
https://www.statista.com/chart/31605/rank-of-misinformation-disinformation-among-selected-countries/
India also ranks 159 out of 180 countries on the press freedom index
https://rsf.org/en/country/india
86
BostallBandits1 day ago
+27
That actually makes a lot of sense, given how some Indians behave in online spaces.
27
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
+4
Did you actually read his 1st link? It says that India is the most at risk of disinformation and misinformation being spread in its society. Which means that both local and foreign actors are pervasively spreading false information and lies on a myriad of things. This only provides more context and reasoning as to the govt actions and gives them actual justification.
Did you take it as Indians themselves spreading disinformation and misinformation alone? Why else would you dunk on Indians online?
4
BostallBandits1 day ago
-3
Made a lot of assumptions there based on 2 lines. Regardless of where the mininfo comes from, the end result is the same, no? The Indian population is one of the most poorly informed populations who devour propaganda, and then a portion of that population come on social media sites and spew that propaganda as fact. Sorry if that reality hurts your feelings. Also, the fact that India have such a low ranking for freedom of the press kind of hints that a lot of that propaganda and misinformation is coming from internally, no?
-3
LazyAd777221 hr ago
+8
like 50 muslim countries with mostly monarchies along with african countries with literal dictators and you think India which is the worlds largest democracy has less freedom of press than those countries ? that's hilarious but it seems you've been a victim of misinformation here yourself.
Pretty sure every bad thing that happens in India gets published by the media there in english for the whole world to talk about, if you look at the list there's countries ranked better than india like mexico(most journalists disappeared) and many in middle east and africa where journalists regularly get jailed and disappear/killed, I just wonder how they are ranked better.
8
BostallBandits17 hr ago
-2
I've been a victim of misinformation because reporters without borders wrote a report? What? RSF is a world renowned and highly respected organisation with no reason to be biased against any nation. Instead of getting triggered why don't you actually read the report that comes along with the ranking in which they explain, quite thoroughly, why India has achieved this ranking. Btw, what was the need to bring up muslim countries? Indian brainwashing at it's finest, any criticism of India and it whiplashes to but what about the mooslims? You proved the point yourself.
-2
megaplex6623 hr ago
-4
100% I noticed they didn't respond..
-4
megaplex6623 hr ago
-3
There is no justification to limiting one's freedom of expression or speech.
-3
Royal_Radish_306920 hr ago
+2
That lie was broken by Armin himself.
2
Tresialwe1 day ago
+9
Their disinformation is all over social media targetting the UK, EU, US, and many other countries.
>Any attempts by analysts and activists to expose this spread of disinformation by India’s ruling party is immediately attacked by ‘troll armies’, with death threats
https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/148518/html/
>EU Non-Profit Unearths Massive Indian Disinformation Campaign
https://thediplomat.com/2020/12/eu-non-profit-unearths-massive-indian-disinformation-campaign/
>Many of the most influential personalities in the “Make America great again” (Maga) movement on X are based outside of the US, including Russia, Nigeria and India, a new transparency feature on the social media site has revealed.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/nov/23/rightwing-influencers-outside-us-x-twitter-tool
9
bhramam331 day ago
What a great example for misinformation you have
I went through the source and the graph is based on this particular question in an internet based survey
> Which five risks are most likely to pose the biggest threat to your country in the next two years?
And it doesn't rank India as #1. It ranks misinformation as the #1 threat in India (amongst a list of 34 threats). This survey was taken few months before a national election in India in 2023.
Similarly misinformation was #6 threat in US, #11 in UK, Mexico, etc.,
0
Undernown1 day ago
+6
Like how a king killing their court jester was often poorly received.
6
tiradium1 day ago
+8
You mean Putin's best buddies are all all weaklings?
8
I_like_spaceships1 day ago
+4
JD Vance rolls with the punches pretty well
4
saptsind1 day ago
+1
Calling these online grifters satirists is the stretch.
1
Royal_Radish_306920 hr ago
Untill he gets 700 million votes for actual work done for his citizens.
0
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
-54
In this case, it’s not so simple to knee-jerk blame the govt, because it’s become so much more difficult to differentiate between the guy living in Delhi, poking fun at the PM satirically. And the guys from Pakistan/China/Turkey troll army spreading disinformation to create unrest, manufacture riots and tension among the populace and deepen divisions in society.
The govt has a duty to protect and prevent bad actors from hostile nations advancing their agendas in the country, and propaganda from adversaries is a form of cyber warfare, that the state needs to act upon. But how do we know the govt isn’t overreaching and going after dissent as well? It’s just not as easy and cut and dry as many think.
IMO the death of free speech online was finalized with the advent of social media.
-54
megaplex661 day ago
+19
You posted that already.
19
crimsonhues1 day ago
+9
He is getting g paid per post
9
More_Piccolo40051 day ago
+162
Cracking down on satirists sets a bad precedent for free speech and accountability.
162
[deleted]1 day ago
+21
[deleted]
21
Quiet_Lie49781 day ago
-5
It never existed in india. And it hasn't gotten worse under modi either
-5
Dr_NitroMeth1 day ago
+1
Yep that's why Tanatan Sanstha killed rationalists across the country.
1
ai99091 day ago
+13
American corporations are the ones fulfilling censorship requests by the Modi government. Probably for pay..
13
Niceguy9551 day ago
+150
Erdugan and Xi vibes. "Strongmen" syndrome. Trump keeps wishing he could do the same.
(Fun note: you'll go to jail in Turkey for calling Erdugan "Golum", or in China for calling Xi "Winnie the Pooh". Guessing that in every "strong" leader there's a small kid who was bullied in school).
150
nishitd1 day ago
+38
This is why Trump likes these leaders
38
IOnlyFearOFGod1 day ago
+20
He especially likes North Korea's leader whose citizens are disappeared at the mere suspicion of rebelling.
20
walker33421 day ago
+2
They also like “disappearing” people by shooting them with artillery cannons in front of crowded stadiums full of people. I think that’s more Trump’s flair.
2
lllDogalll1 day ago
+16
All the news I have read from the Turkey guy and Hungary guy, I swear seem to be lifted from India wholesale. The playbook is same everywhere it seems.
16
Niceguy9551 day ago
+12
Don’t forget “Project 2025” in the US, Belarus, Poland (previous president), Georgia, and several other places. There’s a group going around the world, assisting leaders in eroding democracy. They pretend to be “conservative”, but it’s basically meant to entrench global conditions that benefit the billionaire class and their lackeys.
12
lamplighter101 day ago
+176
Has he tried not being a punch line?
176
lllDogalll1 day ago
+78
He's tries so hard. That I think thats what seprates our respected leader Modiji has over the moron American leader Trump. He knows he's an idiot so he never takes questions from press and only gives interviews to folks that have been licking his taint for years where the questions are sent beforehand to these pliant syncophats and he reads these pre-written answers off a sheet.
78
AiyyoIyer1 day ago
+34
True. He does a very good job of covering up his lack of knowledge. He can't speak without a teleprompter and a speech written by someone else. He and his party are all about setting up narratives, to fool the citizens into believing that he's the know-all strongman when he's quite the ignorant fool.
34
vu2tve1 day ago
+28
Suppressing dissent is easier than changing one's habit patterns. So no, he has not. We are stuck with our own version of the orange clown here.
28
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
-46
I think in this case he just doesn’t like being the punchline, when the joke is being made by someone outside of India’s borders (eg Pakistan, China)
-46
megaplex661 day ago
+28
In that case, he sounds like crybaby.
28
Nerevarine911 day ago
+17
Well, he should get over that. I don’t live in India either, but I think this is ridiculous and I’m free to say so
17
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
-1
Well yes I agree, but it’s not only just about that. If somebody torches a house of an Indian govt official based on ai altered deepfake videos, questions will be raised against the govt for not taking steps to stop the spread of disinformation and lies.
You can say whatever you want, not saying you can’t, I’m just trying to provide some context and perspective. Of course there exists scope of govt overreach, but I’m just saying it’s not just there to cater to the prime minister’s whims. Apparently just saying that is enough to get me downvoted to oblivion.
-1
Sorry-Water-85301 day ago
+8
What’s the difference between a democracy and china? If Xi can ban Winnie the Poo memes and India does this.
8
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
-4
To be fair, if the CIA were running troll farms to malign him based on provably false info and deepfakes, I think it’s well within their rights to take steps to prevent that, but any Chinese citizen should be allowed to post whatever satire they want *(as long as they follow any hate speech or defamation laws of course, but that’s besides the point)*.
**That’s the difference: the citizens of the country should have complete freedom to satiricize, but outside the country? Then intentions are suspect and can be malicious.**
-4
megaplex6623 hr ago
+1
I can see that you're not a huge fan of freedom of speech or human rights.
1
Future-Analyst-667722 hr ago
-1
Huh? How’d you get that from my comment? I just don’t think I should be allowed to tarnish and destroy somebody else’s reputation based on lies?
-1
megaplex6621 hr ago
I highly doubt they're lies. Modi is a well known Fascist.
No response? Didn't think so..
0
Future-Analyst-667714 hr ago
+1
I know when I’m dealing with pettiness and stupidity, why would I knowingly subject myself to that.
1
Sorry-Water-853021 hr ago
There’s no real way to monitor that. There can be free speech or whatever India does.
0
Future-Analyst-667718 hr ago
+1
I don’t think hand waving it away as impossible is the right move, it’s just a question of will and effort. And it’s really easy for you to shit in India, but I doubt you’ve had your family member beheaded in front of you, because someone spread lies that the family member insulted someone’s religion or prophet. Or your house torched and burned for a similar reason. Easy to insult an entire country from your ivory tower of safety and condescension. One would think after the decolonization period, this line of colonial thinking would lose its luster.
1
BitterConstruction981 day ago
+52
This dumbo is taking down reels and posts that were trending a month ago, reigniting interest in them lmao
52
HussingtonHat1 day ago
+97
What a p****.
97
Arhn171 day ago
+39
He's making X withheld accounts posting satire against him and even made insta take down a reel
that was hilarious, if you get all the context and references.
19
VeggieTofuManifestor1 day ago
+2
Galgotia, my phrend!
2
nishitd1 day ago
+35
Streisand effect on full force right now. The satire being blocked had already run its course and now it's being reported by the global media. Thank you dear leader, you played yourself
35
trojen_thoughts1 day ago
+20
He declares himself as non-biological entity publicly and expects no satires
20
Gold-Appearance-44631 day ago
I mean look at that picture - He looks like he is ready to perform Swan Lake and is confused why the guys are not in their outfits.
0
TheVenetianMask1 day ago
+9
That's one respectable thing about Spain, here we understand that if you aren't someone's punch line you aren't actually successful. The biggest honor is seeing people burn a caricature effigy of yourself.
9
VagueSomething1 day ago
+15
Even Kings paid jesters to keep them humble...
15
UnknownGamer0141 day ago
+14
Yeah this one ain't something I can defend. There are a lot of things that I like about current government, but this f****** authoritarian tendency is the single most glaring issue. Don't like it one bit. And even their tendency to try and encroach on internet anonymity - well, tbf, nowadays every country is doing it so it may as well be normal. And why I consider leaving this country.
14
uvberot9 hr ago
+2
What do you like about the current govt?
2
SirMrAdam1 day ago
+25
In before the Hindu Nationalists contort themselves trying to explain why this is a good thing
25
Much-Mess76271 day ago
+8
Whenever I try to comment on this old bag here as an indian, all the other nationalists start to downvote me. This guy is the main reason that India is losing democracy. He has done all kinds of crimes and supports them
8
LethargicDemigod1 day ago
+10
Indian political discourse is a cesspool of shitshows. Both the left-right are clowns and we have no centre (maybe regionally). This gov. can getaway with a lot bcuz somehow inflation is low, growth is moderate and opposition is pathetic. If they don't lose the next general election (assuming without Modi) we are in big trouble.
10
thechromatick1 day ago
+2
If a pathetic opposition wins the next election, wouldn't the trouble be much worse?
2
LethargicDemigod1 day ago
+14
INC is not winning the General elections with that clown ever.
14
Scypher_Tzu1 day ago
+2
Itd be much worse. Tho opposition has no chance to win anytime soon.
2
Crafty-Campaign-61891 day ago
Inflation is pretty high...growth is slow . Still braindead people vote for him in name of religion
0
Tresialwe1 day ago
+14
Journalists are also getting jailed for making fun of dear leader.
14
teshh1 day ago
+16
I'm going to get downvoted by the Indian brigade, but Modi is straight up a fascist. He actively suppresses anyone who opposes him, he's orchestrated or been party to numerous religious killings, he's a key figure in the backsliding of India's democracy, and he actively governs in a manner to gain personal wealth over the expense of his citizens. That's just the tip of the ice berg, there have been countless political, economic, and religious scandals with this guy as well.
A good leader isn't afraid of someone telling jokes. How thin is your skin as the leader of 1.2 billion people that you need to censor speech.
16
[deleted]1 day ago
-7
[deleted]
-7
teshh1 day ago
+1
If they were educated and/or raised in the us yea that's true. However for those born in India, there's a big segment of the population that blindly follow modi.
Modi appeals to indo Hindu nationalists, the same way trump appeals to Christian nationalists here. They're just stepping stones toward fascism.
1
vatsal_08101 day ago
+1
Weil there is still popular support for him and the regime but it’s waning a lot now which is why they are conjuring up phony freebies schemes and disenfranchisement tactics to win elections. Clearly they can’t rely on the cult personality anymore and ever since Trump has returned the global image has definitely taken a massive hit.
Of all the nasty things Trump has done, shattering the Modi narrative in India and abroad for the facade that it is is genuinely positive. He has constantly played them and forced them to bend to his will and they have largely complied. I genuinely don’t see Modi meeting Trump face to face for the remainder of his term because the guy is shivering at the prospect of his cult aura being smashed Trump’s u cough language in front of the world.
1
profShadow071 day ago
+6
Careful. You might hurt sentiments of some of his die hard followers here
6
Important-Fold68441 day ago
+15
Aah they claim to be a democracy yup!
15
vu2tve1 day ago
+19
the "world's largest (facade of a) democracy"
19
PhysicalImpression861 day ago
+13
U do realise that uk has the most amount of actions on social media posts and such right? Auth shitshow is nothing to do with democracy, and it’s by definition electing people to lead the government
People electing someone every 5 years is democracy, now if people are stupid and elect someone who is authoritarian then that doesn’t mean it’s not democracy. Their is a reason why the economist’s democracy index puts, india in the same category as the us.
13
mindful-hedonism1 day ago
+8
Do you people even understand what democracy means? There is censorship in UK today & yet it continues to be a democracy. The president of the US is corrupt, vile, & they have a lot of problems, yet they are a democracy.
Some of you have never read a book & it shows.
8
SamsonFox21 day ago
-9
Sooo.... how much is 8 RMB in rupees?
-9
Melodic_Situation5341 day ago
+6
HOW MUCH IS THE PRICE OF DOG MEAT
6
LazyAd777221 hr ago
+2
coming from tinanmen square, it's free.
2
mindful-hedonism1 day ago
+2
We’re having a discussion on democracy. Something you can’t buy. Sit this one out, mate
2
CheesecakeNo288021 hr ago
+2
it is a democracy
2
[deleted]1 day ago
-15
[deleted]
-15
DrogoOmega1 day ago
+21
Stop copying and pasting the same comment over and over. There are professional trolls spreading misinformation about pretty much every major leading political party and leader in the world. You don't have to react with something quiet textbook fascist.
21
[deleted]1 day ago
-1
[deleted]
-1
DrogoOmega1 day ago
+1
That is not what is happening. Either you are ignorant or purposefully disingenuous. He is blocking satirists, comic artists and comedians IN INDIA. Indian citizens with something to say. He can't take the heat, because he is thin skinned (as all fascists are) and want to block them. You are trying to twist it into "oh he wants to block bots and deepfakes". No. That isn't what is happening. He wants to curb freedom of speech. And that freedom comes with him being allowed to be criticised. Limiting that is textbook fascism. His government went out of their way to withhold and limit the reach of satirical posts on social media. Textbook fascism. He should be allowed to be criticised from outside of India too. This isn't about taking down deep fakes or bringing honesty - there is too much corruption in India for that to be remotely true. And like I said, everyone is dealing with misinformation - the way you handle it is not by trying to silence comedians.
1
notanfan1 day ago
+4
What punch line?
4
Adventurous-Wall-1221 day ago
+6
He basically mollycoddles around with foreign dignitaries and leaders which is true. It's hard to watch him at any international stage without cringing.
6
Soberdonkey691 day ago
+3
Leaders who can’t tolerate this are weak and pathetic.
3
[deleted]1 day ago
+6
[deleted]
6
lllDogalll1 day ago
+11
Nope they are not because they control the Election commission, the mainstream media and the judiciary.
11
[deleted]1 day ago
-6
[deleted]
-6
lllDogalll1 day ago
+8
Nope not even close. Dunno how malleable your local MLA is has to do with erosion of our institutions.
TV after it opened up to other channels when national broadcaster didn't have monopoly (and newspapers even long before that. Goenka published black front pages when government tried to censor them in 1970s).
Election Comission terrorized all politicians, if you remember TN Sheshan he was hated by all politicians.
Judiciary gave uncomfortable judgements all the time against the government (Supreme Court still does on some issues like 10-20% of the times but some judgements from the high courts are regressive even from the 1990s standards)
8
shriand1 day ago
+5
Can you cite examples for your first sentence please?
5
[deleted]1 day ago
+1
[deleted]
1
Rationalist401501 day ago
+8
Can you give examples of people being arrested for mocking Manmohan singh? Thats what is being asked here. Don't shift goal posts. Both of us know that Freedom of Speech was obv 100 times better under UPA as opposed to under BJP which is actors, artists, media, students were a lot more free to criticize under the Congress Era. Please don't resort to this both sides equal BS.
8
Much-Mess76271 day ago
You must be kidding. The reason why UPA fell was because of the media itself mocking and giving news against, which is what I call a true media. During their time, the media was free, they used to openly mock the government of that time and even in non-political tv shows. The Election Commission used to do its job very seriously and here we are today.
0
SingLyricsWithMe1 day ago
+2
Now do recruiting agencies.
2
kishorecmgb1 day ago
+2
Stupid piece of sh*t. What a fraud. Well am I in trouble ?
2
Casual_Scroller_001 day ago
+3
Great harassment ! (iykyk)
3
Dummy-Thilakan1 day ago
+1
Sapna sapna
1
macross19841 day ago
+1
Politicians need to have thick skin because they are often used in joke, meme or punch line bringing laughter to people.
Even though US is going downhill because of Trump, he still can't unilaterally order his goons to crack down jokes thrown against and people get even more laugh if he even react to it. :P
No doubt Trump is envious of what Modi can do and get away with it.
1
AshinWirathu1 day ago
+3
So the article explains that the "jokes" started after Israel visit byt doesn't mention it was mostly misinformation and not actual satire. It was mostly foreign actors spreading 2 clips of Modi, one where he said "India is motherland and Israel is fatherland" but the propagandists cut out the part where he said was talking about Indian Jews and the other clip where he was paying respect at holocaust memorial and people started spreading the video with captain "he started praying to the fire".
3
thechromatick1 day ago
+6
Sir, this is a mob. /s
6
Future-Analyst-66771 day ago
Thank you for providing context. I tried to do the same but got flooded with downvotes. Apparently just saying that maybe one should read and get more info on a topic before jumping to conclusions is looked down upon here. No wonder they have that president across the pacific.
0
Dummy-Thilakan1 day ago
Okay, that's one thing. That's the only thing.
Let us know if you have rebuttals for everything else.
0
No-Lobster-56737 hr ago
+1
Constitution is perfect but the guardians (judiciary) of constituional rights are xss lickers of the govt.
1
Dr_NitroMeth1 day ago
+2
Wait till y'all google 2002 and/or 2013 Snoopgate.
Hint: Supreme Leader is a member of a paramilitary org that was formed by a Hitler idolising group.
You can read more if you look up a book named "Bunch of thoughts" by one of them.
2
blairsmacaroon1 day ago
+1
first step to fascism or wtv
1
Much-Mess76271 day ago
+1
We are at the last stage of democracy. The last step would be to declare it a dictatorship.
1
StatisticianThin2881 day ago
-1
glad the world finally realises how stupid m\*di is. love from india
-1
Complete_Poem_27431 day ago
+1
Great Harrasment.
1
TonyTheTerrible1 day ago
Yo indias prime Minister can smdftb
0
jawndell1 day ago
+2
Feels like folks like Modi and Nethanyahu have been in power for decades in so called democracies
2
StayingUp4AFeeling1 day ago
-4
Can't deny this. What's shite is that the opposition does nothing much for actual issues like this while being a total git for nonissues.
Before someone says I'm blaming the opposition for a failure of the gobarmint*, I'm not. I'm just pointing out that unlike certain other nations, we have the numbers and the organisation for effective protests (see: the farmer protests, the various trade union strikes, and the long ago anti corruption protests). However, it is overwhelmingly the role of the opposition to mobilize such forces.
*Pun. Gobar=bullshit. Mint, as in currency printer.
-4
spacejockey961 day ago
+8
Have you forgot sonam wangchuk detention?why conviction rate in corruption cases filed by ed is below 0.1% ?You are blaming opposition for government failures. have seen this trend on X in past few months. Even if opposition start raising valid issues gov supporters will call it PR and non practical. Citizens vote based on freebies and religion, yet still expect opposition to raise issues like jobs and economy. opposition is in poor condition because of blind supporters. Gov knows that even if they destroy opposition completely. these supporters will still vote for them.
8
UnknownGamer0141 day ago
+12
Because the sheer majority of Indians don't give nearly enough shit about this as they do for caste, religion and freebies. F***.
12
vatsal_08101 day ago
+1
This. We can blame the opposition all we want but these kind of issues just don’t translate into votes in India. It often comes down to the 2k/5k they’ll get just before the election or their caste rep getting a ticket.
1
[deleted]1 day ago
[deleted]
0
SuspiciousNovel13581 day ago
+1
Punjab?
1
Steph1er1 day ago
+1
nothing say democracy like illegal parody
1
CanIHazSumCheeseCake1 day ago
+1
Is this going to turn into a Indian "Winnie The Pooh" revolution?
1
Top-Plane11971 day ago
-2
What a p****
-2
GlobalTravelR1 day ago
-1
Trump is taking notes.
-1
jarod17011 day ago
-7
Maybe stop dressing like a school girl.
-7
Scypher_Tzu1 day ago
+6
Humour in Bad faith, you should argue against his policies or actions, how he dresses is none of your concern
6
jarod17011 day ago
-1
How I judge his dress is none of your concern.
-1
PhysicalImpression861 day ago
-8
We are making whole trends, of Modi giving free femboys to memes about marrying with Benjamin Netanyahu. And they were never removed or even received a notice. Idk how much, removing content from social media can be called a crackdown as is.
This seems less like the nation state or government, from a centralised point of view talking actions and more like some people in lower levels of power trying to show their “love” for the current government. Too uneven and rare.
-8
DescriptionDapper8071 day ago
+6
Bruh. Completely incorrect. The Central Ministry of Information and Broadcasting of India is the primary source of these takedown orders, not some lower level people.
And btw who is drafting all these draconian IT laws, low power people ??
Central Govt launched Sahyog portal last year, which is a home-grown censorship platform, misusing a clause from IT rules.
[Back door censor: On the government’s SAHYOG portal - The Hindu](https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/editorial/back-door-censor-on-the-governments-sahyog-portal/article69382221.ece)
Who introduced this ? Union Home Ministry !!
6
PhysicalImpression861 day ago
The lower level people IN THE CENTRAL MINISTRY OF INFORMATION AND BRODCASTING ARE DOING THIS. They issue 10s of thousands of takedowns, with most being things that are actually an issue like teaching people how to make a bomb.
There are 10s if not 100s of thousands of posts making fun of Modi, conscious decision to actually block 10 of them would do nothing expect bad pr. If the Centeral government actually was doing censorship, then the amount of posts getting thrown out would be 1000x the current number. The 10 20 post they removed was doing minuscule damage to Modi’s image, and the whole ordeal of talking down those posts have done 10x the damage the posts did.
173 Comments