· 41 comments · Save ·
News & Current Events Mar 28, 2026 at 2:03 PM

Liberal Party of Canada MP Michael Ma sparks backlash after casting doubt on forced labour of Uyghurs in China

Posted by Alarmed-Cake812


Liberal MP Michael Ma sparks backlash after casting doubt on forced labour of Uyghurs in China
The Globe and Mail
Liberal MP Michael Ma sparks backlash after casting doubt on forced labour of Uyghurs in China
Ma, who accompanied Carney on his Beijing trip, questioned an expert during a Commons committee meeting on whether her testimony was ‘hearsay’

🚩 Report this post

41 Comments

Sign in to comment — or just click the box below.
🔒 Your email is never shown publicly.
Christian-Rep-Perisa Mar 28, 2026 +46
Ma was originally a conservative party candidate in the Markham-Unionville riding in the Toronto metro area. During last year's election, his Liberal opponent, incumbent Liberal MP Paul Chiang, got a lot of heat from a similar pro-China scandal The liberals made him withdraw and then put in another candidate, but Ma ended up winning and became one of the handful of Toronto area seats which flipped conservative, denying liberals a majority government However, just a few months ago Ma decided that he actually wants to be a liberal so he switched sides and joined the liberal party, which caught national news attention. A lot of voters in the riding felt betrayed and protested Now he is in a weird spot where he has to rebuild a support base, and then he goes off and does something like this
46
Forsaken-Plantain553 Mar 29, 2026 +1
Well it’s perfect for building a Liberal party base since the Liberal party loves the CCP so much
1
Glass-Touch7228 Mar 28, 2026 +13
C'mon, Ma.
13
Educational-Elk4305 Mar 28, 2026 +10
Every time I see people on Listnook discussing Xinjiang and Tibet, I feel like I'm in a parallel universe. In fact, much of the related public opinion within China is complaining about the existence of forced labor driven by capital in Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, and other cities. Many people have become the so called "right-wing"or "left-wing"....some sort of conspiracy theorist. Many also complain that people in Xinjiang and Tibet are living off subsidies, and that the government is handing over hard-earned money from developed regions to these areas. Even though these places are sparsely populated, they still get road and high-speed rail construction, bridge and tunnel building after bridge.Vigorously promote and cultivate certain role models. Even their cultural preservation spending is at least a billion dollars annually. As for the so-called Han-minority conflict, it's largely instigated by the claim that "the government gives them too much money and too good treatment" or "Privileged Citizen". How Ridiculous…
10
Outrageous_Studio302 Mar 29, 2026 +2
Those American outlets don't care minor ethnics or so-called forced labour in China. It is all about to build the 'China bad' vibe for future war mobilization. If the same forced labour is in Japan, they would say it is admirable qualities of the hardworking Japanese.
2
Concern-Visual Mar 28, 2026
Those people neither speak Chinese nor understand China. All they want is a country they can bash to prop up their ego. 
0
[deleted] Mar 28, 2026 +5
[removed]
5
captainpro93 Mar 28, 2026 +14
A good chunk of Vancouver and Richmond are still quite anti-China. You look at them and you just see them as being "Chinese," but culturally it is pretty divided on polar ends depending on which social circle you're in. A lot of older HK immigrants and their descendents who fled after the handover too. Unless you're just talking about the food.
14
Tleilaxu Mar 28, 2026 +10
The MP in question is from Markham, Ontario
10
markhpc Mar 28, 2026 +12
I live in Vancouver. About 20% of the Vancouver metro area population is Chinese. Calling it "Beijing 2.0" is ridiculous.
12
Hannibal_Barca_ Mar 28, 2026
You mean Hongcouver.
0
zenbowman Mar 28, 2026 -3
If you observe the actions of the major powers - China, Russia, and the US - China is currently engaging primarily in internal repression, whereas Russia and the US have engaged in external action that is destabilizing to the world. Given that, I don't think too many countries are going to line up with "punishing" China for its actions, and you're going to see a lot more of this.
-3
markhpc Mar 28, 2026 +10
Sooner or later China is going to try to take Taiwan. They will consider it an internal action while any country that relies heavily on TSMC and Taiwan in general will see it as external. It's going to get messy.
10
yisuiyikurong Mar 28, 2026 -2
In that model actually China has approx 3 - 4 million square km territory to claim/reclaim. Taiwan is just one of the unsettled “internal actions”. 
-2
zenbowman Mar 28, 2026 -9
Yeah, and they will likely succeed with little resistance. Given how susceptible the US has been to Iran in this latest insane war, there's no hope of "defending Taiwan". China does see it as internal, and my guess is they'll get most of the world to go along with that narrative in the long run. Chips will keep flowing to most countries and people will learn to live with it.
-9
xX609s-hartXx Mar 28, 2026 -4
China is also bullying a bunch of neighbours, violating their waters and fishing in foreign territories.
-4
Tinelytolmit Mar 28, 2026 +1
EEZ is international waters, Chinese ships have freedom of navigation.
1
Dispator Mar 28, 2026 +8
I know listnook/usa has a hate boner against China but there is sooooooooooo much misinformation about most of the topics. Though it's probably the case that most everything is inundated with misinformation and I'm afraid it's only getting worse.
8
xX609s-hartXx Mar 28, 2026 +3
Everybody hates Russia and America for their pointless wars & violence, the harm they do to the environment and the constant bullying on the international stage. Why shouldn't China get some hate for that as well? Why are China's crimes not worthy of criticism?
3
InsectDelicious4503 Mar 28, 2026 +7
You can't fish in someone else's EEZ. And you definitely can't go into someone else's EEZ and start blasting their ships with water cannons. Illegal under international law and yet China does it anyway.
7
Bowmore18 Mar 29, 2026 -2
Well you can't go kidnap a country's president and steal their resources, but here we are today. I think we know how both place on a scale. No sense for China to follow the rules if everyone else isn't.
-2
InsectDelicious4503 Mar 29, 2026 +9
Sure. I'm perfectly happy to say both are bad. The difference is Chinese users are only ready to badmouth the US, but always give China a free pass.
9
xX609s-hartXx Mar 29, 2026 +1
So you admit that China is evil and we are right for calling them out?
1
Bowmore18 Mar 29, 2026 -1
I think you're smart enough to know that fishing and arguing is vastly different vs invading and attacking another country without provocation. Unless you think I'm mistaken about you being smart enough?
-1
xX609s-hartXx Mar 29, 2026
Well China has done so as well in multiple cases. Entering foreign waters and attacking the foreign coastguards with water cannons if they tried to react. Or cruising around Taiwan for almost a year straight, showing them what they might be doing to invade in the near future. Got a lame hidden insult for that as well?
0
Bowmore18 Mar 29, 2026 -1
Yeah, either way that's not the same as shooting missiles and kidnapping leaders on a whim, is it? China isn't the one trying to start WW3 either. If you don't like the insults then don't treat us like idiots. We can see clearly what the US and Israel are doing.
-1
xX609s-hartXx Mar 29, 2026 +1
Yeah yeah, we get it. China can do no wrong, their crimes don't count. Please buy from temu.
1
xX609s-hartXx Mar 28, 2026 +3
This isn't about international waters and you know that.
3
Skythewood Mar 28, 2026 -1
Russia and US are primarily engaging in internal repression though. The external action is a side show. The US has incarcerated 0.55% of its population, and they are no different from forced laborers. To contrast, the world average prison population is 0.14%.
-1
zenbowman Mar 28, 2026 +3
Sure, so Russia + the US are engaging in internal repression + external action, China is seen as only doing the former. So its unlikely that there will be any international repurcussions for China.
3
PMJamesPM Mar 28, 2026 -3
This grossly underestimates CCP oppression worldwide. You can bash Trump all you want whenever you want. Different story if you bash CcP leadership
-3
zenbowman Mar 28, 2026 +6
Perhaps, but the point is that there are no "good guys" to partner with, every major power is some different flavor of abusive. So middle countries are going to adopt more of a vague commitment to human rights over time, rather than point out specific abuses, because there is no viable trading coalition that has clean hands.
6
markhpc Mar 28, 2026
Unfortunately, it seems that the recurring trend is that when humans get power, they overwhelmingly end up abusing it. How a middle country attempting to conduct itself ethically should try to survive in this world is not an easy question to answer.
0
curorororo Mar 28, 2026 -6
China is basically eternally on internal repression, they are a relatively young country. Less than a hundred years.
-6
WintAndKidd Mar 28, 2026 -3
Liberals compromised by China and Conservatives compromised by America when it comes to Canada. Sucks
-3
LittleGreenSoldier Mar 28, 2026 +1
And the NDP are just nowhere to be f****** seen (except Marit Stiles, she's getting some good traction by actually calling out Ford on his bullshit. How you gonna say we're training hundreds of new healthcare workers, then slash OSAP? Be so f****** for real.)
1
markhpc Mar 28, 2026 +1
It sounds like Ma has quickly walked back his statements. His claim is that he was referencing the wrong region: >By Thursday evening, Ma posted an apology on social media that said his aggressive line of questioning referred to Shenzhen, a global hub for Chinese EV manufacturing, but not Xinjiang, where the aluminum at issue in the Human Rights Watch report originates. >"I condemn forced labour, in all its forms. Canada has amongst the most rigorous forced-labour import laws in the world, and I am proud to support the government's work to eradicate forced labour from supply chains and enforce Canada's import prohibition," his apology to both the witness and other committee members concluded. [https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/michael-ma-china-forced-labour-investigation-9.7144931](https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/michael-ma-china-forced-labour-investigation-9.7144931)
1
Makgraf Mar 28, 2026 +22
He still didn’t say there is forced labour in China, and was asked repeatedly whether there was forced labour in China by a CBC reporter and refused to answer.
22
markhpc Mar 28, 2026 +5
Yeah, I see that in one of the other CBC articles. Pretty telling: >On his way out of the House of Commons, Ma was asked by CBC News whether he believes there is forced labour in China. >"I believe there is forced labour around the world," he said, refusing to say it happens in China specifically.  [https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/liberal-mp-uyghur-forced-labour-9.7143558](https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/liberal-mp-uyghur-forced-labour-9.7143558) Edit: fixed to the correct link
5
IndieDevLove Mar 28, 2026 -9
what a sacrilege! Never question what we tell you about our enemy.
-9
Alive_Internet Mar 28, 2026 -2
Revoking citizenship or remigration should only be reserved for the most extreme cases, like terrorism or treason. Siding with an adversary like was done here could potentially be considered treason, so this is a rare instance where Canadians may support revoking citizenship/remigration. 
-2
← Back to Board