· 56 comments · Save ·
News & Current Events Apr 22, 2026 at 6:12 AM

Millions in India stripped of vote before critical state election, as government seeks to ‘purify’ electoral roll | India

Posted by Stunning-Common-9591


Millions in India stripped of vote before critical state election, as government seeks to ‘purify’ electoral roll
the Guardian
Millions in India stripped of vote before critical state election, as government seeks to ‘purify’ electoral roll
Experts say Muslims and other minorities have been disproportionately deleted from the electoral roll ahead of the West Bengal elections this week

🚩 Report this post

56 Comments

Sign in to comment — or just click the box below.
🔒 Your email is never shown publicly.
DungeonCrawler19 12 hr ago +128
Correction: millions with Zero paper trail and verifiable identity removed from voter list due to known illegal immigration issue.
128
ragequitteroffureh 12 hr ago +25
Where do illegal immigrants in India come from?
25
General_Booger 12 hr ago +77
Bangladesh.
77
[deleted] 11 hr ago +26
[removed]
26
Dry_Fudge8741 9 hr ago -2
No lol what. Border is guarded
-2
Marwaimusoont 9 hr ago +8
via nepal
8
Gorgrocco 8 hr ago +1
And kashmir, not much
1
ragequitteroffureh 9 hr ago +4
Thanks! I just wondered. I think that this is the first time hearing about it.
4
Short-Leopard-3715 8 hr ago +1
It’s a major concern which is changing the whole demographic. It’s illegal immigration. 
1
Pani_ki_bottle 11 hr ago +39
Bangladesh and Pakistan. Most of the grunt workers for personal use in Delhi-Gurgaon are Bangladeshi. Like housemaids (Pay them 25 $ a month and they'll come mop your apartment n do dishes 1 hour a day), car washers (5$ a month and they'll wash ur car 6 am daily ), cobbler, water tank cleaner and other jobs. All are Bangladeshi, previous CM of Delhi Kejriwal set up slums for these people and it's a major problem coz about half of them are good honest people who just want to make a living, then there are chainsnatchers, pickpockets and a few religious extremists in their midst as well. In India if you are middle class you essentially don't do anything physically exhausting coz someone would do it for the price of 1 McDonald's Happy Meal
39
gumnamaadmi 11 hr ago -26
So you mean to say incompetent amit shah and narendra modi allowed illegal immigration into india?
-26
madtoothbrush97 10 hr ago +13
No, the incompetent mamta banerjee is the responsible party. Have to clarify, not just incompetent but downright malicious.
13
Pani_ki_bottle 9 hr ago +5
Central Government needs to recieve flak for their failures as well, although TMC wants to increase this illegal immigration. They should investigate TMC and take action against any illegal activity found instead of just crying about it.
5
Budget-Turnover3231 10 hr ago +4
Illegal migration comes under central government and the border security force is responsible for curbing it, not the state government.
4
Much-Mess7627 8 hr ago +1
You think that lady should sit in the border with baseball bats in her hands to kick out illegal immigrants? Then what is defense ministry for? Your govt really can't take criticism
1
Senior_Tooth_5332 9 hr ago +2
Me when im spreading propaganda. Borders are controlled by the Central Government.
2
Pani_ki_bottle 9 hr ago +1
Yes, it is a massive failure of Amit Shah and Modi that they are not able to stop this mass illegal immigration
1
Budget-Turnover3231 10 hr ago +12
Bangladesh. It's a massive issue. Especially now, with Bangladesh joining hand with Pakistan, it's a serious security threat too.
12
anonymous_panelist 9 hr ago +1
The Guardian is at its peak, spreading misinformation with its twisted headings
1
jesonnier1 9 hr ago +7
Do you have a source? This comment could be propaganda to support voter suppression. Idk what it is, either way. I also don't have the burden of proof of your comment.
7
gamesbonds 10 hr ago +6
did the government there provide identification to these people beforehand? I know many in India live in poverty how many cannot afford identification? I have so many questions this entire phrasing you're using sounds like the same exact bullshit that Republicans in the US have been using to advance political gains. It's called demagoguery. The entire world did not over night get an immigration issue. This is a politician pointing at a group of people most likely a minority and saying that your problems are their fault, because they exist.
6
DungeonCrawler19 10 hr ago +14
People from Bangladesh cross over to India via the border state of West Bengal. As most of these people belong to muslim community, they are used for demographic shift by the WB state government. Most of these people get their identification proofs via black market or through political parties.
14
gamesbonds 10 hr ago -10
You cannot be claiming that 10% of your electoral are voting illegally right before an election that is absurd. Even the article here states that an official involved in the revision himself and people he verified were removed. Let alone the muslims it's targeting. What's more believable that you're being lied to by one political party , or 9 million people are lying to vote?
-10
DungeonCrawler19 10 hr ago +11
This clean up has been going on for 2-3 years now. And if you know anything about the agendas going on in India, 9 million illegal voters is absolutely believable.
11
gamesbonds 10 hr ago -6
They spent 3 years on this and still fcked it up
-6
DungeonCrawler19 10 hr ago +8
If you are not a legal resident of India, your opinion on the matter is void. Thanks for trying though.
8
gamesbonds 9 hr ago
The words being used in this article and to justify this purge are the same words used by conservatives here to describe a non existent crisis that blames minorities while pushing an agenda. Literally the definition of the word demagoguery. I dont expect you to understand how a political strategy is not exclusive to India. I was only taught this while becoming a political science professor.
0
0narasi 9 hr ago -7
The right wing in India is one of the worst I have seen. Atleast conservatives in other countries benefit from the system and deny access to others. The right wing in India has an ecosystem of people who themselves aren’t from means yet fight to defend those who keep defrauding them year after year.
-7
gamesbonds 9 hr ago +1
over the past 2 years i've seen insane amounts of this type of language being pushed because when it comes to elections it works. Far right politicians are winning all over the world and whats something they all have in common? They are all pointing a finger at immigrants and saying "These people are the reason your life is so difficult"
1
[deleted] 11 hr ago -10
[removed]
-10
DungeonCrawler19 10 hr ago +8
Right, because everything was hunky dory in WB before 2014.
8
AppearanceDizzy7006 11 hr ago +4
Get your own head out of your own you know what 
4
AppearanceDizzy7006 11 hr ago -1
Thank you 
-1
abodeadobe 12 hr ago +30
The headline and the article are both quite biased. It doesn’t at all acknowledge the cross-border illegal immigration TMC deliberately allows to sway the voter base demographics because they know it’ll favour them. TMC is pro-Islam and neutral-Hindu party in a state that has a vigorous Hindu majority population. These demographic shifts lead to severe social instability in future between communities (e.g.: European Jewish settlers in Palestine). It’s quite weird seeing international news outlets twist this and terrible seeing TMC lack foresight despite widespread simple history lessons. What BJP is doing is definitely beneficial to them, but also good for the larger Indian community. How can a country provide universal food and healthcare to people of other nations when we have our own developmental problems to solve. Irrespective, is BJP bad? 100%. Is TMC worse? Everyday. Kolkata regularly ranks as the worst Indian metro city. They have the same ‘old-man-conservative-views’ despite wanting to come across as progressive and opposite to BJP. I’ve lived there for work for a few years, and all I could see was potential. It has the potential to look like Bangkok or even better with its water channels and beautiful architecture, but TMC’s corruption has razed it to a massive slum. I want more young leadership that is not sponsored by foreign interests/lobbies/corruption so they can actually work honestly for the people and we wouldn’t have to choose between lesser of the two pathetic evils.
30
gumnamaadmi 11 hr ago -22
So TMC is responsible for border security now? These idiots who have their heads buried into Modis backside are willing to believe whatever right wing propaganda is dished out to them
-22
abodeadobe 11 hr ago +16
Yes, TMC is the state government, and state governments are responsible for land acquisition for national borders. You couldn’t even find one thing wrong with my comment and proceeded to spew hate. Dude, read and get educated. This is terrible yet fitting display of your sub-par knowledge. Calling actual facts propaganda diminishes your own credibility, argument and intellect. READ. GET EDUCATED. I IMPLORE YOU. It just sounds like you’re so deep into your anti-BJP narrative you clearly fail to see the failures of all the other political parties that do the same as if not worse than BJP just with a progressive mask. Get real. Wake up. [Land acquisition responsibility of the state](https://csep.org/blog/fencing-security-and-border-management-the-indian-experience/#:~:text=The%20state%20governments,in%20fencing%20projects) [Issues legally raised against West Bengal State Government](https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kolkata/hand-over-acquired-border-land-to-bsf-hc-tells-bengal/articleshow/127809618.cms#)
16
360tutor 9 hr ago
And what is BSF doing? Surely it's not under the state
0
Much-Mess7627 8 hr ago +1
What the hell is central government doing to stop the state government then? They have more power, they can easily override the decisions of the state, then why is defense ministry and modi shut about it?
1
[deleted] 8 hr ago +1
[removed]
1
LethargicDemigod 10 hr ago
Conspiracy theorists like u that believe everything under the sun from SC, EC, Delimitation Commission ,Media and Industrialists are sold to the BJP should join Rahul Gandhi Uni. Dumbass.
0
LordOfTheSevenSeA69 11 hr ago +13
Clickbait article 😂 People with 0 documents are supposed to vote now?? I am from the same state and will be voting tommorow. From my locality only deceased peoples name have been deleted or people who couldnt provide a single document from like list of 10 documents so do you expect the deceased to come vote? Or do you expect people who dont have any document to vote??
13
ChipsAhoy2022 12 hr ago +17
What a bs article title Totally missed the point and gives a wrongdoing impression on purpose? These low quality journalists should be banned from posting on these platforms
17
Shivamrocks5039 12 hr ago +10
Millions of Illegal immigrants from neighbouring countries who have came to country illegally by crossing open borders and made fake documentations have been identified and action taken on them. Right now they are just removed from election process, later process to deport them will be carried out if deemed necessary.
10
stu54 12 hr ago -10
Remember that you are property of your nation, and in the technofeudal era serfs will be returned to their lord's lands.
-10
Responsible_Tie5644 11 hr ago +7
Shit load article
7
008Zulu 12 hr ago +2
"In West Bengal, a total of 9.1 million names have been deleted from the register, more than 10% of the electorate. While many were dead or duplicates, about 2.7 million people have challenged their expulsions, but still been removed." Approx. 90 million, and 2.7 of them were cut. Mostly Muslims it seems.
2
okboiz123 12 hr ago +30
" Mostly Muslims" https://www.thehindu.com/elections/west-bengal-assembly/of-90-lakh-voters-excluded-by-sir-in-west-bengal-63-are-hindus-34-are-muslims/article70843569.ece
30
mindful-hedonism 12 hr ago +31
Bangladeshis. It’s very well known that there are tens of millions of illegal Bangladeshis residing in India, & the ECI is removing their names from the voter list. Does it help the BJP- yes, but it’s not like they are targeting legal citizens & going against the rules.
31
memesnmovies 12 hr ago -18
When they can identify Bangladeshis, why only remove from voter lists? why can't they deport to their country?
-18
Pani_ki_bottle 11 hr ago +23
No extradition with Bangladesh, Bangladesh doesn't take these people back. What the government does is that it often takes these people near the border region and asks them to go back. The border bw India n Bangladesh is not that well fenced or protected, you could in most cases walk or go via boat without any hassle.
23
mindful-hedonism 12 hr ago +12
Removing their names is much easier than deporting ‘millions’, & it is terrible optics, especially in a day & age when the western media leaves no stone unturned to bash india& its ‘far right hindu nationalist’ gov ( whatever that means)
12
themathmajician 12 hr ago +1
The label doesn't really matter when the reality is what it is.
1
StrictTotal3324 8 hr ago +1
Maybe single digit percentage are actual people legal or illegal. Most are dead, migrated or duplicate votes. States that underwent this process recently and had state elections saw increase in voter turnout.
1
mintynest 7 hr ago +1
[ Removed by Listnook ]
1
Important-Fold6844 9 hr ago +1
Aah the corrupt political entity of Superpower India strikes again!
1
gumnamaadmi 11 hr ago -19
Modi and Shah have been doing this in every state election. Take out enough votes oer polling booth. Pay off cash to some voters, register their own voters from other states to pad up their numbers and manage the bloody elections. India is dead as a country. With AI induced job losses, their only golden goose of software based revenue is going to get killed in next decade or so.
-19
← Back to Board