The show by an experienced team should work fine as long as they nail the art style. The video game is less likely to see the light of day, the rights holders aren't great.
482
Mino_18Mar 19, 2026
+108
Aren’t great is an understatement
108
Sonichu-Mar 19, 2026
+49
Yeah, everyone excited about this (myself included) needs to take a breath and remember how trash iWoT is and how often they announce and cancel projects.
49
FernandoPooIncidentMar 19, 2026
+129
None of this will ever happen. In the last couple of years, iwot has announced:
* An Age of Legends movie trilogy.
* A "White Tower" animated movie.
* A "AAA" open-world RPG. (The studio they created for this was apparently quietly shut down a couple of weeks ago.)
* Some "immersive" WoT experience (nobody knew what the f*** that meant).
* Some AI-related projects (including some collaboration with Framestore announced a few weeks ago) apparently needed to manage their vast "transmedia strategy".
* And now apparently an animated series *and* another video game.
None of these projects will ever come to fruition, since no industry executive is going to greenlight anything WoT-related after the cancellation of the Amazon show. There is no market for this stuff.
129
13pr3ch4unMar 19, 2026
+56
There absolutely is a market for a well-made WoT series. The issue is just that "well-made" part
56
FernandoPooIncidentMar 19, 2026
+25
The way an executive would look at it: the Amazon show had a big budget and an 88% RT critic score, so it's "well-made" enough. And yet people didn't watch. So there is no reason to think a new adaptation would fare better. That's especially true for an animated show, which has a much smaller potential audience.
25
Sonichu-Mar 19, 2026
+12
Execs aren't going to care about Rotten Tomatoes. There were glaringly obvious problems with the Amazon show. That's why Salke was fired.
Someday in the not too distant future, they'll make another WoT show. The market is there, Rafe and co. just alienated that market with their disastrous storytelling.
12
KumagawaUshioMar 19, 2026
+12
Doing a new film adaption of a book years after release that's easy but a 15 book series? no, that's way to large an investment for anyone to seriously take on.
12
FrodoFragginsMar 20, 2026
+5
I don't see another live action show coming for decades. It's too many books
5
coldmonkeys10Mar 20, 2026
+2
I started getting into the book series at the same time I watched Rafe on Survivor and it blew my mind when I was like “Oh I wonder what this guy is up to now- Oh. Oh God. Oh God no”
2
NeoSethMar 19, 2026
+37
I disagree that there isn't a market. I agree with your conclusion though. There has been a lot of stuff announced that never came to be. This announcement is way, way too early to be worth being excited about.
37
Sekh765Mar 19, 2026
+13
I don't even think its a market issue. WoT is just *too long* to finish as a media property other than a book. Imagine current almost 2 years per season turn around on big animation projects. 1 season per book you are loooking at ***28 years*** to finish the story if you stuck to that, provided nothing happens.
13
cheesegoatMar 20, 2026
+4
The only way to do it is to adapt the material. Slice a piece of the story out to make something.
Doing a beat-for-beat conversion of the book is just too much work.
4
deagle746Mar 20, 2026
+2
I honestly dont think its to long to be made into a show. I don't know if you have read the books but what readers call the "slog" could easily be condensed. The whole series could easily tell its whole story in a more condensed way. Jordon was very long winded when it came to writing and there are whole books where it seemed basically nothing was resolved.
2
Routine_Condition273Mar 19, 2026
+12
I dont think the WoT amazon show failed because of a lack of market. They deviated wildly from the source material.
12
SufficientCaloriesMar 20, 2026
+7
It failed because the writing team didn't really like the books and thought they knew better.
7
_PaddyMACMar 19, 2026
+5
If they respected the source material and the fans there would be a market for it. The Amazon show did neither so it failed.
5
Deadlocked02Mar 19, 2026
+11
A WOT CRPG would be interesting. There are plenty of rules they could add from the books. Different weapons for channelers of each gender, different element affinities and weakness, weapons that require a certain gender composition to use, party compositions that favor single damage vs parties better for AoE, healers/buffers not being able to use the power on themselves, etc.
11
bros402Mar 19, 2026
+4
oh shit, a WoT CRPG would be great. Imagine Larian doing it
4
HomersApeMar 19, 2026
+201
Before I even clicked on the article, I knew it was with iwot.
For those who don't know, that company is notoriously both disgusting and disingenuous with how they've attached themselves to the franchise like parasites. I will believe when I see it, but in the meantime, I don't put so much power in their words. Be hyper sceptical.
The Wheel of Time deserves better treatment, but I doubt you'll see it from those people.
201
Sonichu-Mar 19, 2026
+45
Legally it has to be iWot. They own the rights
45
ryhaltswhiskeyMar 19, 2026
+12
What does the little i stand for? Anything?
12
jakeisbakinMar 20, 2026
+6
No, in that case it would have been aWOT.
6
ryhaltswhiskeyMar 20, 2026
+2
Cute
2
Karl_Hungus_42069Mar 19, 2026
+2
Uwot mate?
2
polygramfanMar 19, 2026
+3
I still want to see as little involvement from them as possible. Their track record is abysmal
3
Sonichu-Mar 19, 2026
+4
Total garbage company for sure. Sad they have any claim to the rights at all
4
modixMar 19, 2026
+977
That's what it always should've been. The colors of Arcane and the city itself felt perfect for Wheel of Time. They can draw the patterns and show weavings as well as the crazy stuff that happens without billions in development.
977
Logan_No_FingersMar 19, 2026
+119
>without billions in development.
Arcane was insanely expensive. If you are trying to do WoT but this time without the crazy budget, the guys who spent $250m on as series of Arcane are not your template
119
MindestinyMar 19, 2026
+77
Right? Riot *literally* threw an unlimited budget at Arcane. It was a passion project they didn't care about the ROI on.
77
jokekiller94Mar 19, 2026
+6
There’s no why Amazon would can 3 completed episodes and reboot the entire thing like riot did.
6
FernandoPooIncidentMar 19, 2026
+28
Yes. Arcane was more expensive than the WoT live action show and had much lower viewership. It only existed because it was a glorified ad for League of Legends.
28
Cross55Mar 20, 2026
+19
>and had much lower viewership
That one's a lie, no one was watching WoT, lol
19
scaradinMar 19, 2026
+277
Agreed! Plenty of high fantasy works would be better served with an animated adaptation.
277
TliblemMar 19, 2026
+125
Been saying this about Stormlight Archive but pretty sure Sanderson is pushing for live-action.
125
hunteddwumpusMar 19, 2026
+28
A lot the action almost feels written for animation. The whole thing with the radiants breathing and glowing stormlight feels like its basically dragonball’s auras and imo shit like that looks goofy as hell in live action, and the combat in mistborn idk how they do it justice with live action without it looking goofy like last airbender LA. Its just written to be so over the top fast, like Vin is beyond superhuman in speed and agility. Stuff like would look better in animation imo.
Not even getting into the fact that a lot of the characters are meant to be not exactly standard humans
28
TliblemMar 19, 2026
+17
Well put. I think Mistborn is better suited for live action versus Stormlight during to the environments and eventually set design. Looking forward to both and I think the production companies involved will be a great fit. Cautious optimistic.
17
livinitup0Mar 19, 2026
+4
I’d prefer mistborn but for a tv series but I think Stormlight has broader potential viewer appeal due to GoT.
Both would need some massive edits to work on tv ….which is concerning.
I don’t know why these companies are trying to continue to shove epics into live action when properties like Red Rising are a much MUCH better fit for a big budget live action series and things like WoT are obviously perfect for a big budget animated series
4
ChiefBlueSkyMar 19, 2026
+15
Bro Wax and Wayne was *meant* for live action. Perfect cowboy movie.
Given they're talking about era 1 right now, which imo is... not a mistake but like era 2 would be far, far better for adaptation, and if successful would prime the audience for era 1. Might make things like "death", "the survivor", and "god" tricky though in the context of era 1 spoilers.
15
TliblemMar 19, 2026
+3
Absolutely. Great point on Era 2 being better for live action. Western-fantasy is a lot easier to do than even medieval fantasy, let alone epic fantasy (Stormlight).
3
LuinAelinMar 19, 2026
+54
To be honest, while not a popular opinion, I think him having so much control may end up not being a good idea.
54
jfa03Mar 19, 2026
+37
Idk, his take on the WOT live action was pretty spot on. I’m not saying it will be all anybody could ever dream of, but I’m letting myself be cautiously optimistic.
37
0dias_ChrysalisMar 19, 2026
+21
I think too much control is sometimes just as detrimental. Being an authority on lore is one thing, but screenwriting? He’s basically self learning it for his movie adaptations that he himself is doing most things for. And arguably his writing has suffered since his old editor retired and that’s within his own comfortable medium. Think in part he’s gonna suffer from George Lucasisms where too much freedom and no restriction will result in a mess
21
kevp453Mar 19, 2026
+27
He commented on his recent YouTube podcast that while he is writing the screenplay he will be working with professional screenwriters to tighten it up and better adapt to the medium. I find that encouraging; he isnt too proud to get help as he is learning the new business of Hollywood.
27
TheJoshider10Mar 19, 2026
+14
I'm glad it's Apple who are involved with it. That gives me higher hopes for its quality especially with just how much they've gone all in on Sanderson. It *has* to succeed.
14
retardboristMar 19, 2026
+7
It's an experiment for sure. I'm excited to see what they come up with, though!
7
LuinAelinMar 19, 2026
+3
We've seen this experiment before when Stephen King did one of his short stories as a movie......
But for he the problem is more that writers can be too close to the work. And a lot of great adaptations are something the authors hate (The Shining) or would have hated. Tolkien would most likely hate what Peter Jackson did to the movies
3
schreibenheimerMar 19, 2026
+5
Yes, but that experiment was also affected by a lot of cocaine.
5
EpistemifyMar 20, 2026
+2
I hope he doesn't exercise it often in Stormlight Archive. The fact that he has it means the series can't stray from the ideas in the books, which is great. But yeah, I can't imagine that it would be productive for anyone of he's meddling all the time
2
HerbsAndSpices11Mar 19, 2026
+5
I hope he listens to the editors if they adapt the last stormlight book. That one needs a touch up.
5
Tulidian13Mar 19, 2026
+13
Is the general consensus that the last Stormlight book is a slog to get through? Because I'm about 60% in and am straight up not having a good time.
13
ChaosengelMar 19, 2026
+8
It has its moments during the Sanderlanche, but it's probably one of the weaker SLA books in my opinion. Not as low as RoW.
8
damage3245Mar 19, 2026
+7
Overall I think the book was one of the weakest of the series, yet it had one of the best endings of the Stormlight Archive so far.
7
AcknowledgeableRealMar 19, 2026
+8
I think the conceit of it covering 10 days really held it back. It meant that you have to visit each of the disparate groups of heroes on each day and so something has to happen to all of them every single day.
I found for some of the storylines that made them quite repetitive.
8
LuinAelinMar 19, 2026
+2
I agree. Not all the characters stories needed to be visited everyday.
2
HerbsAndSpices11Mar 19, 2026
+3
I think the reception is mixed from what I've heard. I guess the biggest issue I had with it, is that the chapters are so short and it switches between characters so much it kills any momentum for reading it. That wouldn't be as much of an issue adapted to tv, as long as they didn't get bogged down too much with the side characters.
3
Jackmac15Mar 19, 2026
+8
I bloody loved it, I listened to the whole thing in like 3 days.
But every Stormlight book is about half a million words, slogging is just a built in feature of every book.
8
onarainyafternoonMar 19, 2026
+6
To be honest, listening to it as an audiobook versus reading the thing, is a completely different experience.
6
Sonichu-Mar 19, 2026
+3
Can't be worse than what Amazon plopped out for WoT
3
MrBensvikMar 19, 2026
+2
My worry is that he'll do a GRRM and stop writing books when distracted by film and TV adaptions. I have faith he's more disciplined, but the written output is bound to be affected.
2
LuinAelinMar 19, 2026
+12
He's already said some of the standalone books will be delayed
12
onarainyafternoonMar 19, 2026
+3
Sanderson *loves* writing, though. Especially novels. GRRM is a great writer, but he's always been way more interested in writing for television. That was his original goal, even.
3
AuryGlenzMar 20, 2026
+2
More importantly, he has an actual work ethic with set hours that he writes every work day.
2
7thpixelMar 19, 2026
+3
Sanderson magic systems + live action are going to be a hot mess.
3
_PaddyMACMar 19, 2026
+2
Stormlight is pretty much an anime in novel form, especially in the more recent books. People flying through the air fighting each other with oversized magic swords.
2
Protoman89Mar 19, 2026
+7
Yep, Red Rising should be animated as well
7
Nickk_JonesMar 19, 2026
+19
But then your potential audience is cut in half minimum.
19
OkayAtBowlingMar 19, 2026
+16
Yeah, even apart from the "animation is for kids" segment of the audience, I think that for a lot of people the appeal of a sci-fi or fantasy adaptation is seeing a realistic depiction of things that don't exist in real life.
16
NimonicMar 19, 2026
+7
Right. I've already got the books, I can imagine it however I want. If I want an adaptation, the appeal is for it to appear real. It's also why I wouldn't read a comic book adaptation.
7
MadManMax55Mar 19, 2026
+23
It really is frustrating how engrained the idea "animation is for kids" is in our culture. Even to the point that most "adult" animation is overly raunchy and/or violent in an explicit attempt to separate it from kids animation.
Though what makes it even more frustrating is that most big budget movies and TV shows are basically animation anyway. With the amount of CGI and digital effects, modern Marvel movies are closer to Who Framed Rodger Rabbit than Tim Burton's Batman.
23
anonymous_orpingtonMar 19, 2026
+4
Red Rising for sure!
4
plutoglintMar 19, 2026
+2
SF too.
2
LuinAelinMar 19, 2026
+2
Agreed. Some of the worlds are just difficult to do in live action without losing something or an insane budget. And even then may look silly in live action
2
bigbluethunderMar 19, 2026
+25
I mean Arcane cost a shit load of money too, just because it was animation does NOT mean it was c****.
25
WitchOfKyivMar 19, 2026
+13
Producer =/= Animation studio
Is Fortiche animating it?
13
monkpunchMar 19, 2026
+5
Also not a writer. Just one of literally dozens of producers. Not saying he's good or bad, but this is about as important as a game "from ex-Blizzard developers" these days.
5
EnkundaeMar 20, 2026
+3
The headlines misleading. This guy had almost nothing to do with Arcane and the company, iWoT, are basically scammers that have been squatting on the ip for decades. The original author described them as “pissing in his soup” or something to that effect iirc.
3
Dodo_BaronMar 19, 2026
+9
Wheel of time will get cancelled in 5 min if it's close to the budget of arcane though.
9
GobblewicketMar 19, 2026
+16
I mean the Amazon WoT show had a bigger budget per episode and was godawful with its faithfulness to the IP and it somehow lasted 3 seasons. So, anything is possible?
16
Salvage570Mar 19, 2026
+20
Season 3 was actually pretty damn faithful, tbh. I def think any adaptation NEEDS to change stuff, just not from the GD very start! The ending of the first book is super sloppy but the rest is so good, you dont need to mess with it much. Now, the middle of the series? That needs a lotta work, lol. Coming from a guy who loves the novels and read it 3-4 times counting audiobooks
20
GobblewicketMar 19, 2026
+20
Yeah the changes to Mat and Perrins backgrounds was wholly unnecessary
20
Yodl007Mar 20, 2026
+2
Not to mention that they didn't know if the dragon is a man or a woman. Or making Rand look like a baby that needed to be saved by Egwene, which was the showrunners favourite char.
2
[deleted]Mar 19, 2026
+4
Honestly that bothered me less than watching a few episodes and realizing that I as a reader of the books, had no freaking clue what was going on in the show. The plot proceeded at light speed while the characters languished.
4
onplanetbullshit-Mar 19, 2026
+5
Doesn't help if you're so turned off by season one you can't get through it.
5
fullsaildanMar 19, 2026
+3
Reading through the series now, it definitely feels like books 5-9 could be like an episode or two each. There’s so much extraneous exposition in these books that it’s very painful. And not in the Tolkien way of making me envision these beautiful backdrops, but in the why do I care that another random woman is “handsome but not pretty” way. 😂
Haven’t hit 10 yet, I know that’s the big hump, (I can make it through this…!) and I expect from what I understand of it, that it too could be a consolidated episode as well.
3
Sonichu-Mar 19, 2026
+7
Season 3 wasn’t that faithful. It had one episode that (more or less) followed an amazing chapter in the books. But everything else was the usual ignoring of the source material.
Especially considering the character deaths at the end of the season.
7
NeoSethMar 19, 2026
+8
Yeah it blows my mind that people consider Season 3 "faithful." More faithful than the first two? Alright, sure. But *actually* faithful? Bruh moment.
8
gsauce8Mar 20, 2026
+3
You gotta keep in mind that the show had fairly large drop offs. If someone stuck around till s3, its cause they were either hate watching or already had a positive opinion of the show.
3
Dodo_BaronMar 19, 2026
+8
It's the same experience when ever I see someone argue witcher s1 was faithful
8
Cross55Mar 20, 2026
+3
Reddit picks weird little hills to die on.
They also say that Lower Decks is "Faithful to the heart of Star Trek" but soonly after claim the first word to describe it as "Dysfunctional" which is the exact opposite of anything Star Trek.
Reddit doesn't really know what Faithful means, tbh
3
monkpunchMar 19, 2026
+3
"I was faithful to my third wife. I only cheated on her twice!"
3
Pool_SharkMar 19, 2026
+74
How involved was he in Arcane? A single producer could range anywhere from helped secure funding to had fingerprints all over
74
KiltmanenatorMar 19, 2026
+63
>**Previously head of creative and IP franchise at “League of Legends” maker Riot Games**, Vu is best known for shaping the massively popular online video game, which boasts more than 100 million monthly active players, and a franchise spanning esports, music, games and television. **Vu was also an executive producer on Netflix’s “Arcane,”** a critically acclaimed animated series adaptation of the video game.
EP is still a wildly vague credit to have. He may have gotten it simply for having been the head of creative and IP franchise at Riot
63
YourmomgoestocolIegeMar 19, 2026
+35
From the BTS series for the first season of Arcane, it seemed like Christian Linke Was the main force behind the direction of the series
35
KiltmanenatorMar 19, 2026
+5
Ah, thank you. I was hoping someone could answer this
5
KiltmanenatorMar 19, 2026
+10
These are the real questions. The heart can hype but the brain is a cynic
10
RosekingMar 19, 2026
+7
While I do not want to downplay Riot's involvement in Arcane, as they are the creators of the show, I think most people read the title and are immediately thinking of Arcane's animation as Arcane's visuals are a masterclass.
The animation studio for Arcane was Fortiche. While Riot is a heavy investor in Fortiche, they are basically the reason Fortiche was able to expand enough to handle a project like Arcane, they are separate. And none of this announcement is mentioning them.
Now moving past animation, I think most people like the writing, at least in terms of season 1 (2 had more criticism). Very tight paced show with great characters. The most public facing creators of Arcane on Riot's side are Christian Linke and Alex Yee, the co creators. Amanda Overton can also be mentioned, she was a writer and executive story editor and specifically involved a lot in the Cait and Vi story. If you look at the AMA from season 1 it was those three (AMA started with Christian and Alex, Amanda popped in)
https://www.reddit.com/r/arcane/comments/yp9d4b/s1_spoilers_were_christian_linke_and_alex_yee/
While I have not watched everything on the behind the scenes stuff available, I have seen a decent amount. Take with a grain of salt as maybe he an important figure and is just in the background, but I have seen basically nothing from him in regards to Arcane. And even just doing a quick search while writing this comment, I am not finding much. A few interviews where they mention Arcane as it was popular, but then the interview didn't really seem to have much about Arcane. Internet searching after news is dropped makes things harder as SOE prioritizes recent news, but pretty much everything I can find relating him to Arcane is just this announcement.
7
Mino_18Mar 19, 2026
+24
IWoT so don’t expect this to actually happen 😂
24
travioMar 19, 2026
+270
Animation might serve a series like that better than live action, though I enjoyed the live action version, even with the changes from the books.
270
Zauberer-IMDBMar 19, 2026
+152
I thought it had its strongest season by far when they canceled it.
152
Bird-The-WordMar 19, 2026
+76
Took too long to find itself. S1 was just ass, s2 was changes just for changes, and then it finally started to gain it's footing but you can't take 3 seasons to do that.
76
zephyrtrMar 19, 2026
+25
You can, but not if you're an extremely expensive fantasy epic.
IMO S1 was okay, S2 started slow but ended so damn strong. I'm not shocked they said ok to one more season, and S3 was great but could've been better if they were able to take their time.
But I know my take is not the popular one. The numbers simply didn't materialize.
25
Bird-The-WordMar 19, 2026
+9
I just couldn't stand Egwene in S2, and then felt like Nynaeve kept taking 1 step forward, 2 steps back, plus they just didn't know what to do with Perrin and Mat.
If they didn't start the whole series off with "Who could possibly be the Dragon!?!?!" nonsense that didn't make any lick of sense anyway, they may have been able to build each one out more rather than try to do that in S2.
I hated the end of S2 as I felt like Rand just had no agency. I get it, he was new to it, and didn't know how to use his powers, but it just felt like they had to keep shoehorning Egwene in to save him.
I didn't read the books so I don't have much of a comparison, just from the show itself it seemed like a mess, until they started to really get into the lore/prophecy stuff in S3 more-so and Rand made some progress forward.
9
ExIsStalkingMeMar 19, 2026
+15
As someone who is reading the books for the first time (I am past the point where Jordan passed and Sanderson took over), your first paragraph applies to the books too. Egwene is just kind of a b**** for a long time, Nynaeve can't stop getting in her own way, and we just kinda check in with Perrin and Mat when Jordan remembered they existed
The first thing any adaptation is going to have to overcome is that half the characters' storylines don't have climaxes in each book; so you either leave the audience wondering "wait, aren't the girls still in Ebou Dar for the third season in a row without anything resolved?" or you move some shit around to fix the pacing
As much fun as I've had with these books (and it's been a lot), there are riddled with foundational issues from a storytelling perspective. The forward by Sanderson on his first book in the series even mentions it. Jordan left behind notes for what he though was a single book, and, almost immediately, Sanderson knew there was still a trilogy left of story to tell
15
Radix2309Mar 19, 2026
+3
They renewed for S3 before S2 aired. I assume they figured first season was just messed by the pandemic. I doubt they would have renewed if they had to decide after S2 aired.
3
DeX_ModMar 19, 2026
+2
> IMO S1 was okay, S2 started slow but ended so damn strong
Im not sure i can take anyone seriously that liked s1 and 2
They were so bad, and broke so many things
Just awful
2
ChiefWatchesYouPeeMar 19, 2026
+4
Agree completely.
I never read the books but like fantasy movies and shows and I couldn’t get past season 1
4
IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTESMar 19, 2026
+4
I grew up on these and read em all several times over and season 1 was terrible so I stopped. Someone told me to watch some of season 3 and said where they were in the books and……that was decent.
4
tasbir49Mar 19, 2026
+3
I didnt read the books, but that scene where the wizard lady and the gang were on horses, and she gave exposition on the fall of some region was such bad exposition that it turned me off the show entirely.
3
FernandoPooIncidentMar 19, 2026
+3
Moiraine relating the Fall of Manetheren is straight from the books. The executives didn't want to include it, but the showrunner insisted on having it. Sounds like the executives were right!
3
tasbir49Mar 19, 2026
+2
Good example of a case where you dont want to adapt 1:1!
2
epicfail1994Mar 19, 2026
+24
Yeah, it was finally a great show
24
BigCommieMachineMar 19, 2026
+19
I don't think it was ever bad. I just think it deviated too much to satisfy book readers while was never simple enough for mass audiences.
Game Of Thrones was such a hit because it was a political thriller masquerading as a fantasy show. Everything was kinda "Oh, I get this"
19
epicfail1994Mar 19, 2026
+7
The last episode of season 1 was pretty fuckin awful, but that was largely due to production issues caused by COVID.
What they did do wrong was the whole confusion over who the dragon was- it took away time for exposition for people who hadn’t read the book and annoyed those who had
7
WischiwaschbaerMar 19, 2026
+1
Oh season one was bad. To be fair they got screwed royally by COVID, but still.
1
andwhatnowthoughMar 19, 2026
+4
They captured Rhuidean perfectly. Easily my favorite scene in all books, and the one I dreaded the most. But they did it justice.
4
mileseverettMar 19, 2026
+41
As someone who hasn't read the books, I mostly enjoyed the tv show and honestly when it finished was really enjoying it. I absolutely loved the setpieces and costume design especially
41
Typical-Blackberry-3Mar 19, 2026
+12
I've read the books many times and could never imagine a live action version doing it justice. I never ended up watching the live action version, but I would be hopeful for an animated series. There is a lot more you can do to express the ideas of the books through animation than you ever could with LA.
12
TheNerdChaplainMar 19, 2026
+7
Do yourself a favor and watch the Rhuidean sequence at least, sometime. It really did nail the book. Watching the evolution of the Aiel and the fall of the Sharom was as good as I imagined.
7
RyenStarr9Mar 19, 2026
+2
Definitely see your point I just don’t know how’d they ever get close to a decent conclusion without it taking forever. Animation just takes so long (Arcane took like three years in-between seasons right? And Blue Eye Samurai I think is coming up on two years now)
2
VanimalCrackerMar 19, 2026
+31
Episode 1 when Perrin not only had a wife but accidently killed her was a massive red flag. I tried to like the show after that, but it was garbage.
Not one swear word is said in the entire book series besides "blood and ashes" and the like. For some reason Mat keeps saying shit and f***. Terrible adaptation
31
TheNerdChaplainMar 19, 2026
+2
The wife was insisted on by some producer.
I think the show was right to have Perrin accidentally kill someone to visually establish a lot of what the book does through his internal monologue, but it should have been Master Luhhan, not Laila Dearn.
2
ReasonableFruit1Mar 19, 2026
+8
It was a terrible way to show the fear he has for his size and strength vs his non violent nature. I think season 3 made it better, but it felt so out of left field in season 1.
8
wildwalrusaurMar 20, 2026
+2
My controversial opinion was that they should have cut Perrin altogether.
He's far and away the least consequential of the emmonds fielders to the overall story. His mid series storyline is infamously the books' worst. He interacts very little with the core cast once you get past the first couple books. And so much of what parts of his story are actually compelling are entirely solo in the dream, or driven by internal monologue.
He's just ill suited to a television adaptation, particularly when they have so much material they needed to pare down to make it fit.
2
scaradinMar 19, 2026
+3
Very much agreed. I did have to just ignore that there was a book series because many of the changes were incompatible with the world in the books.
3
Hydroponic_DonutMar 19, 2026
+9
As a book reader, I hated the changes they made simply because they were moving things around from later books and storylines, into other seasons that were supposed to focus on one major arc at a time. It made no sense to move things around the way they did
9
SpoonacusMar 19, 2026
+11
I thought moving the Aiel stuff before Tear was a great move, honestly. Book version, the Aiel are just there at Tear in the third book like, "Yeah, we thought you might be here so we're here too. Not sure if you're our guy, but just in case, we made the trip..." Having Rand go through Rhuedian first and prove himself to the Aiel and their prophecies so they can help him take the Stone after just flows better to me.
11
randomaccount178Mar 19, 2026
+4
I would disagree because it skews the point of the third book. Rand is less trying to win and more trying to force a resolution to his own doubts from what I recall. It makes no sense to change the order because then it doesn't actually force the issue.
4
NeoSethMar 19, 2026
+3
Exactly, The Dragon Reborn is one of my favorite books in the series for that very reason: Rand isn't after a big triumph, he is just working on simple, almost meta logic: "I don't know if I am the chosen one or not, so let's just try fulfilling the biggest prophecy I know. If it works, I'm the chosen one! If not, I'm free!"
3
WischiwaschbaerMar 19, 2026
+3
It got a lot better towards the end. Though I can understand why most people wouldn't sit through the first season just for a promise of it getting better later.
To be fair, the production was screwed royally by COVID, a lot more than others.
3
DjbearjewMar 19, 2026
+34
Hopefully he stays faithful to the books and doesn't just make shit up.
34
funke75Mar 19, 2026
+6
THIS, this is the number one reason I've always thought animated series are the best options for epic fantasy series. the special effects cost the same as the regular animations so you can actually tell the story without cutting corners. i mean it we can have a dragon ball z episode where its basically the villain grand standing and then goku powering up for 20 minutes we can add the smaller scenes from a book series with a huge dedicated fan base.
6
Tulidian13Mar 19, 2026
+4
Hopefully not strictly to the books. Or there will be 50 seasons and half of them will be filler.
4
mrcosanMar 19, 2026
+9
Then only the arcane producer is involved. for a moment I thought it would be the work of the studio fortiche This does not ensure quality. arcane is the sum of the parts
9
fythismobileMar 19, 2026
+9
Saw iwot mentioned. Immediate no.
9
daddytwofootMar 19, 2026
+6
Iwot is essentially a scam company and nothing will come of this.
6
Elisian_KnightMar 19, 2026
+12
The best way to make Wheel of Time imo. Legitimately excited about this.
12
Resident_Step_191Mar 19, 2026
+29
It's iWot. The project will be cancelled in 3 months
29
StormblessedFoolMar 19, 2026
+11
Unfortunately true. I don't even know what iWot gets out of their cycle. They announce "New wheel of time project!" Then a few months later "nevermind, it's cancelled." Have any of their projects actually gone anywhere?
11
SemiFormalJesusMar 19, 2026
+17
Hopefully they use source material beyond the names of people and locations.
17
Mino_18Mar 19, 2026
+9
You don’t want Maksim fighting the dark one?
9
Yodl007Mar 20, 2026
+2
Or Egwene saving Rand when he fights Ishamael in Falme ?
2
thamradhelMar 19, 2026
+6
Best i can do is a director that creates a new character for his boyfriend.
6
ThatGuyFromTheM0vieMar 19, 2026
+3
Sounds good until you see this dude was Exec Producer which means f*** all
3
st-avasaralaMar 20, 2026
+3
I said this years ago prior to the tv show that WoT should be an anime.
3
Deadlocked02Mar 19, 2026
+16
Rand here looks a lot like book Rand. Hope this time the characters match what I imagined them to look like. There’s no excuse in animation.
That said, those books are huge. I’m a huge nitpicker when it comes to adaptations, but this is the one adaptation where I wouldn’t blame them for condensing things.
16
Mino_18Mar 19, 2026
+16
Everyone knows that WoT should be condensed. Hopefully if this goes ahead, they will actually let Rand be the main character and cut unnecessary filler instead of the main characters development
16
keepfighting90Mar 20, 2026
+3
Crossroads of Twilight could legit just be one episode in a season without losing anything
3
FernandoPooIncidentMar 19, 2026
+2
Eh, that "Rand" image is pretty clearly AI generated.
2
kroqusMar 19, 2026
+4
Most interesting
4
-cyg-nus-Mar 19, 2026
+2
I won't watch it until the series is finished. Won't get burned again.
2
nashfrostedtipsMar 19, 2026
+2
This could be absolutely incredible. I think animation is a better medium than live action for the material. I'm really, really, really hoping that they minimize narrative edits as much as possible, because there is so much potential here. Very excited.
2
TheNakedOracleMar 19, 2026
+2
This seems like a smart use of the IP. Frankly, more of these things should live in an animated space. If we’re going to actually take animation seriously it starts by not thinking adaptations need to be live-action to be legitimate.
2
AnfinsMar 19, 2026
+2
Yeah good, this should have been an animated series in the first place. As should all of the Cosmere novels.
2
ShuraeMar 19, 2026
+2
Best news after the overall disappointment the live action was
2
vaati4554Mar 19, 2026
+2
Oh this is awesome, exceptionally exciting news
Shame about the cancellation announcement by iWoT in about 3-7 months.
well, that or it will be radio silent for 3-5 years and then put out a singular rushed episode with the CGI equivalent to that of Hoodwinked, and THEN be cancelled.
2
Jsr1Mar 19, 2026
+2
Please don’t make the same mistakes as the live actions, be true to the source material
2
AonswitchMar 19, 2026
+2
Awesome. I’m on book 4 rn, and damn, I’m a huge fan already.
2
VOIDsamaMar 19, 2026
+2
nice, this is how justice can be done for this.
2
Many_Entrepreneur452Mar 19, 2026
+2
If Perrin kills his wife in the animated series I will immediately stop watching
2
TristanDuboisOLGMar 19, 2026
+2
Hopefully he follows the books instead of the bullshit slop Amazon put out.
2
adamsputnikMar 19, 2026
+2
This is 100% not happening.
2
KingBlackthorn1Mar 19, 2026
+2
More animated adaptations ease. The show was doomed to fail being costly live action
2
thatdudefromoregonMar 19, 2026
+2
This would be the correct way to do this, live action was incorrect.
2
Zestyclose-Pay-1889Mar 19, 2026
+2
Reckon this will do way better than the live-action. Some novels are better brought to life through animation
2
LyradepMar 19, 2026
+2
Yesss! This is what it always should have been. There’s no way they could have gathered so many actors that could have the ageless appearance of the Aes Sedai doing live action. Also, there’s no way they could handle a series as long as the Wheel of Time with live actors. I mean they already lost one main actor between seasons 1 and 2.
On top of that, there were soo many things that the live action butchered, and so many more that made the series come off as abysmally average.
2
RocketsledCanadaMar 20, 2026
+2
Get an Expanse Animated series and then we will talk.
2
Ol_QwertyBastardMar 20, 2026
+2
I have high hopes for this. I’m going support the hell out of this and then hope it’s successful enough for Stormlight to get the same treatment.
2
nottostirthepotbutMar 20, 2026
+2
Please for the love of how good that series is. Keep true to the actual plot instead of inventing new shit
2
OzempicDickMar 20, 2026
+2
They have already animated over 400 hours of nyneve tugging her braids!
2
edcculusMar 20, 2026
+2
I’m not particularly a WoT fan, but we absolutely need more animated series
2
joliette_le_pazMar 20, 2026
+2
Glad to hear. The show was absolute Amazon Prime b-show garbage.
2
fuckyou_redditmodsMar 20, 2026
+2
My prayers are answered. Please learn from Tomorrow Studios and follow the source material faithfully. That's literally all you have to do to print money.
2
Protoman89Mar 19, 2026
+7
Oh god please let there be new writers that will actually follow the books
7
AlugarMar 19, 2026
+4
Please be good , please don’t disappoint
4
jiminuatronMar 19, 2026
+8
I hope they actually adapt the thing. Not make a modern sensibilities version like wheel of Prime
8
NightgasmMar 19, 2026
+4
Let's hope they actually get some writers / directors who respect the source material this time. It's understandable that some things have to be cut / condensed but you shouldnt be utterly inventing things and completely changing plotlines and characters that you do show as the TV series did.
The Expanse did it right. They cut some plotlines and merged some secondary characters but they didn't invent whole new plotlines, promote a secondary character to be the main character, or completely miss some of the main themes of the books.
4
TheNerdChaplainMar 19, 2026
+2
IIRC didn't Riot Studios *lose* money on Arcane since it was so expensive to make?
Wonder if they'll go with the same animation house as Arcane.
That said, as much as I enjoyed most of the show, animation is certainly a better medium for this story.
2
kemosabe19Mar 19, 2026
+2
Been saying this for years. Though I’d prefer an art style like Castlevania. But as long as it’s faithful and good I’ll be ok with whatever style.
2
nin_ninjaMar 19, 2026
+2
I dipped out of the live action adaptation super fast. I really hope an animated series can do justice to one of my favorite book series
2
SmellsofGooseberriesMar 19, 2026
+2
More adult animated series is the way to go moving forward. The sooner broad swaths of western audiences stop viewing the medium as childish, the better.
2
marccoogsMar 19, 2026
+2
Animation is so much better for this series. Great news.
2
Newui101Mar 19, 2026
+1
Anything from someone who worked on Arcane I’m in. Arcane is absolute cinema
1
ScruffMacBuffMar 19, 2026
+1
IMO they need an easier art style than Arcane to speed up production time.
1
KiltmanenatorMar 19, 2026
+1
For he *is* the Car'a'carn!
1
rp_361Mar 19, 2026
+1
When they adapt the stormlight archive for Apple TV…. This is what they should do too
1
monchotaMar 19, 2026
+1
Well maybe it will be semi entertaining, unlike the slog the live action was. Love the books, it was obvious who was in charge of the show did not.
1
FrancosteinMar 19, 2026
+1
Please be good… by the light and my hope of eternal salvation please be good!
1
ctz123Mar 19, 2026
+1
Don’t give me hope
1
ZeopherMar 19, 2026
+1
Just give me Nyna vs Moghedien and i will be happy. And Dumai wells
1
Radix2309Mar 19, 2026
+1
Wow, that is faster than I expected it to be.
1
Weird_donutMar 19, 2026
+1
Ooh
1
MovieGuyMikeMar 19, 2026
+1
This has some serious potential. I hope they nail it.
1
Slight_KnightMar 19, 2026
+1
This is the best news I've heard in a long ass time
1
ThisOtterBehemothMar 19, 2026
+1
Heeeell Yeahhhh!
1
FreyziMar 19, 2026
+1
Game of Thrones was an anomaly of a show and worked because its fantastical elements are minimal, and yet all these companies kept trying to strike gold again with other high fantasy properties in live action when animation has always been king.
1
_gneatMar 19, 2026
+1
Does anyone remember the DragonLance cartoon that was released in 2008? It was unwatchable.
197 Comments