ListNook

mrdannyg21 Mar 24, 2026 +223

Really enjoyed the first season. Second wasn’t bad, but felt like they misunderstood what made the first great and pushed in the wrong directions.

223

AgentElman Mar 24, 2026 +128

I thought the second season was good in the individual moments but the overall plot was just redoing the first season down to the break up and getting back together.

128

ROBtimusPrime1995 Mar 24, 2026 +55

Same. In fact, I'd go as far as to say the supporting cast got more to do & better plot beats than both main characters.

55

palinsafterbirth Mar 25, 2026 +35

I will always root for Sasha even though I hate Jonah

35

Infamous-Lab-8136 Mar 25, 2026 +36

It's not his fault he looks like a police artist's sketch of a r*** suspect

36

awake-asleep Mar 25, 2026 +6

I found it sooooooo hard to accept Sasha after Jonah lll

6

palinsafterbirth Mar 25, 2026 +6

If you didn’t know, he was responsible for casting for that brother/sister Folgers commercial

6

ROBtimusPrime1995 Mar 25, 2026 +3

Holy shit, this is an actual fun fact.

3

awake-asleep Mar 25, 2026 +1

I’m Australian I don’t know that commercial we don’t have Folgers here.

1

cantonic Mar 25, 2026 +4

It is a notorious coffee commercial from several years ago and you can draw your own conclusions for why it’s notorious! https://youtu.be/uMwFWDIFVCU

4

AgentElman Mar 25, 2026 +3

Have you seen the new Percy Jackson series on Disney+ The actor who plays Sasha is Tantalus in the second season of PJ. It was odd going directly from him as Sasha to him as Tantalus

3

palinsafterbirth Mar 25, 2026 +1

All I know is Jason Mantzoukas is in Percy Jackson. I have no idea what it’s about but I’m always open to new shows if you think it’s enjoyable

1

mrdannyg21 Mar 25, 2026 +3

I didn’t know he was in it but would pretty much give anything a chance if Mantzoukas is in it

3

AgentElman Mar 25, 2026 +1

It's a YA show with some mythology. I recommend it if you like those things, but only if you like those things.

1

caninehere Mar 25, 2026 +2

It's very much a franchise that isn't that much fun for adults, at least in my opinion. Every time I've seen a bit of it I've thought man, I would have loved this when I was 9 (but the first book came out when I was almost an adult).

2

flcinusa Mar 25, 2026 +2

F****** Jonad

2

mrdannyg21 Mar 24, 2026 +10

Well put, mostly felt like a worse version of the first season. They could’ve made it lighter and more jokey or if they were looking at it as a long-running show, pushed deeper into their relationship. Mostly seemed like they weren’t sure what direction to go.

10

Stinkycheese8001 Mar 25, 2026 +10

What was ultimately the point of the second season if it ultimately just hit almost all of the same beats as the first? It’s one of those shows that feels like something is missing, the ingredients are there and sometimes it works but overall it’s not ‘there’.

10

Avitpan Mar 25, 2026 +6

I’d argue that it’s the most realistic depiction of a restock ship ever put to film. S1 is the honeymoon phase but still dealing with their individual problems as a couple then s2 expands to the couple dealing with their individual problems external pressures of being a true couple and trying to merry all the different aspects of both lives together.

6

Ancient-Dust3077 Mar 25, 2026 +1

sashas hair style was hilarious in 2nd season

1

Senators_1992 Mar 24, 2026 +8

I enjoyed the second season although, if we’re being honest, it was pretty much just a rehash of the first season (also, Noah’s mother threatening to break them up at the end of one episode and then never following through seemed odd as hell).

8

Clorc_Kent Mar 25, 2026 +7

Yea, it wasn’t bad. It just… Was? Me and the GF thoroughly enjoyed S1, but I couldn’t tell you a single thing that happened this season.

7

jonsnowme Mar 25, 2026 +3

The second season kind of hit the same exact beats as s1 and ended exactly the same. I was like - this is déjà vu?

3

IncurableAdventurer Mar 25, 2026

And just really didn’t like the Kristen Bell character

0

timshel_life Mar 25, 2026 +45

The show is good, but honestly, season 2 felt like the same plot, just a different font. Hopefully season 3 will be different.

45

echothree33 Mar 25, 2026 +9

Papyrus font for S3?

9

Shanntuckymuffin Mar 25, 2026 +1

I was always partial to Chiller

1

HankHillPropaneJesus Mar 25, 2026 +20

Actually really enjoyed this show. Plus I love Seth cohen so his revival is a welcome one. Yes I know his real name is not Seth cohen

20

caninehere Mar 25, 2026 +1

If you haven't seen it go watch The Kid Detective. Really fun movie starring him that unfortunately got buried because it came out during the pandemic.

1

Moooney Mar 25, 2026

I hadn't seen Seth in anything after The O.C. until I saw him play Seth in Fleishman is in Trouble.

0

West_Coach69 Mar 25, 2026 -7

It isnt? Is it is just Jewish guy

-7

Accomplished-City484 Mar 25, 2026 +15

I like the actors in this show but I kinda hate the characters

15

DBY2016 Mar 25, 2026 +21

Awful second season. My wife and I were actually rooting for Noah to break up with Joanne.

21

Bandit_Heeler2026 Mar 24, 2026 +48

*The content of this post is no longer accessible. It was removed using [Redact](https://redact.dev/home), for reasons that may relate to privacy, security, or personal data protection.* cause birds absorbed merciful complete intelligent juggle smell dinner expansion

48

champion_dave Mar 25, 2026 +19

Honestly, the reason I enjoy this show is because it’s comforting and the wider cast is enjoyable, the families feel real. It’s not really about the plot for me, so I like it as a show.

19

West_Coach69 Mar 25, 2026 +3

100. Its run its course

3

ffordedor Mar 25, 2026

No

0

Fidrych76 Mar 25, 2026 +15

Not sure anyone wants this 🤷🏻‍♂️

15

ChuckGreenwald Mar 24, 2026 +7

Ah, shit. Thought Chris O'Dowd was given more work and got excited.

7

OneReportersOpinion Mar 24, 2026 +1

Ha!

1

joe_dirty365 Mar 25, 2026 +3

Adam Brody is great in Ready or Not as well. Just watched that last night.

3

ElmarSuperstar131 Mar 25, 2026 +2

I love this show but they really dropped the ball with the second season. Hopefully it will not become the latest victim of The Third Season Curse!!!!

2

West_Coach69 Mar 25, 2026 +2

Worst show title

2

bfsfan101 Mar 25, 2026 +2

I adored the first season and couldn’t tell you a single thing I remember about the second, other than a fairly annoying last episode.

2

Early-Eye-691 Mar 25, 2026 +2

I’m glad Adam Brody gets more work.

2

hammnbubbly Mar 25, 2026 +1

Hoping season three is a repeat of season two which was just a repeat of season one

1

Tenoch_12 Mar 25, 2026 +1

Good show

1

longdustyroad Mar 25, 2026 +1

I find the main plot kind of dull, it was cute the first season but by the season 2 I was bored of their relationship. I mean it’s fine but it’s nothing special. But I absolutely love Sasha and his wife and the sister. Their weird friend triangle situation is hilarious. There’s some subtle emotional depth there too. Timothy Simons is just phenomenal. The Esther character is also really good on her own. They do a good job layering in some insecurities under her brash demeanor

1

ludicrous_copulator Mar 26, 2026 +1

I thought they really did a good job with Esther. She could have just been a 2 dimensional harpy, but they made her more an actual person.

1

No_Factor_1269 Mar 25, 2026 +1

I feel like a third season is set up to explore sasha and morgan while the main two stabilise. This whole ‘are u converting’ thing is so worn out. Tbh the early episodes of the show were the best, the feeling of nervous excitement perfectly encapsulates that feeling of sparks flying and falling in love

1

sharponephilly Mar 24, 2026 -14

Show is kinda ass

-14

NOVA_OWL Mar 25, 2026

When the f*** did they make a season 2????

0

Taskebab Mar 24, 2026 -24

If nobody wants this…then why are they making it?

-24

kingcolbe Mar 24, 2026 -2

This deadline article says this show is expected to premiere in the fall of this year. How is that possible? There is no way right?

-2

ObviouslyTriggered Mar 24, 2026 +3

November is still fall, this isn't a show that requires a significant time in post production, each season is only about 250-300 minutes long in total, which is 4-5 hours, so you are looking at about 30-50 days of shooting and probably about as much in ADR/editing and other nonsense. So if they start primary photography around April/May they will still have plenty of time to release it in the fall.

3

LB3PTMAN Mar 25, 2026 +1

Shows can easily come out in 6 or so months from end of filming if there’s not much work done in post. See stuff like Letterkenny, Only Murders in the Building, Slow Horses, The Bear.

1

caninehere Mar 25, 2026 +1

The Bear is a perfect example - it releases every year in June (at least the first 4 seasons did, I assume this last one will be the same) and they typically wrap filming like 1-2 months beforehand. This time I think they wrapped a bit earlier because iirc it is already done.

1

Accomplished-City484 Mar 25, 2026 +1

10 half hour sitcom episodes don’t take long to shoot or edit, The Bear usually films around this time and releases in June

1

Miffernator Mar 25, 2026 -2

If Nobody Wants This? Why does it keep getting seasons.

-2

ButthurtBilly Mar 25, 2026 +2

Joachim Gutiérrez Karlsberg-Nøbody is a senior executive at Netflix and he's been a very outspoken fan of the show from the beginning.

2

Miffernator Mar 25, 2026 +1

I made a joke

1

Ancient-Dust3077 Mar 25, 2026 -1

sashas hair style was hilarious in 2nd season

-1

parsimonious Mar 24, 2026 -36

Oh cool they made a show about AI

-36

tteuh Mar 25, 2026 -4

Proceeds to jump shark

-4

‘Nobody Wants This’ Season 3 Begins Production In Los Angeles

💬 Send a Message

64 Comments