‘Nobody Wants This’ Season 3 Sets New Cast: Sarah Silverman, Andrew Rannells, Erin Foster, Keyla Monterroso Mejia, Avan Jogia, Poorna Jagannathan, Sadie Sandler, Stephanie Koenig, and Steven Weber
\> Below, discover all the new characters and the roles they’ll play as Noah and Joanne’s rom-com continues to unfold when Season 3 premieres later this year:
\> \* Andrew Rannells as Sebastien, Joanne’s nemesis in conversion class.
\> \* Keyla Monterroso Mejia as Amber, a single woman enrolled in Joanne’s Intro to Judaism class who is obsessed with finding a Jewish husband.
\> \* Sarah Silverman as Rabbi Eden, the warm, quirky teacher of an Intro to Judaism class, and a supportive presence for Joanne and Noah.
\> \* Avan Jogia as Travis, a confident and unbothered guys’ guy who enjoys getting under Joanne’s skin.
\> \* Erin Foster as Nicole, a terminally single, chaotic, and somewhat messy person ... She’s Joanne if everything had gone wrong in her life.
\> \* Poorna Jagannathan as Eleanor, Sebastien’s brassy and biting aunt.
\> \* Sadie Sandler as Denise, a young psychic who gives a reading to Morgan.
\> \* Stephanie Koenig as Poppy, an incredibly upbeat woman who goes on a date with Sasha.
\> \* Steven Weber as Julian, a funny, grounded, cool, and secure divorced dad.
I’m just happy Adam Brody is being employed with this show. Need him in more stuff.
100
Joey-WilcoXXXApr 9, 2026
+17
I want to see his Wife landing more roles
17
keving87Apr 9, 2026
+4
She had a show on CW but it was filmed in Australia, which probably presented some complications, and was cancelled. She was also on a few episodes of The Buccaneers... but yeah it'd be nice if she was on more.
4
Joey-WilcoXXXApr 9, 2026
+3
Maybe if she and Sarah Michelle Gellar combined forces they could unleash enough power to get a reeeaaaally good project made and stay booked and busy like they deserve
3
toohipsterforthisApr 9, 2026
+3
Love him. I'm also obsessed with Justine Lupe and Timothy Simons in this
3
Accomplished-City484Apr 9, 2026
+6
I love the cast of this show, but the show really sucks, the writing, the comedy, the drama, the characters all just suck
6
stoicsportsApr 9, 2026
+23
Season 1 as a standalone is great imo, solid rom-com-dram plot line and well done
23
JaxTangoApr 9, 2026
+6
Right? It’s an insane waste of an excellent cast. I just watch this show to watch them interact since the plot itself isn’t going anywhere.
6
SmallLetterApr 9, 2026
+1
Some of it kinda sucks but overall I've enjoyed it and I don't like almost anything new
1
wecangetbetterApr 9, 2026
+19
Just gimme more Jonah that's all I ask
19
Digi_DingoApr 9, 2026
+6
Jonad is the best part of this show
6
ilovedonuts682Apr 9, 2026
+2
The actor was awesome in Veep
2
Bdp17Apr 10, 2026
+1
Hitmaker
1
ExMOnotwiththeflowApr 9, 2026
+54
I watched the first season. There were parts I liked, but what I really didn't was the portrayal of all Jewish women to as overcontrolling and marriage obsessed harpies who make men miserable, in contrast with the refreshing, uber laid back cool girl who can't help but sweep the Jewish guy off his feet and free him from their clutches.
54
Signal_Reputation640Apr 9, 2026
+28
So you didn't like the whole premis of the show. LOL.
28
ExMOnotwiththeflowApr 9, 2026
+10
The premise was fine. It didn't need the stereotyping.
10
Ragnar_DragonfyreApr 9, 2026
+6
You didn’t really give it enough of a chance then because divorce and breakup is a strong theme too. My wife watches this show and I got sucked in myself.
The “uber laid back cool girl” needs to convert for the Rabbi guy and she’s a hot mess of non-commitment. Season 2 focuses on this part a lot more and it really isn’t clear that cool girl and Rabbi guy are gonna make it.
I’m married into a Jewish family and have seen these stereotypes myself. They’re pretty common, that’s why they’re stereotypes.
6
NYLotteGiantsApr 9, 2026
+116
Aka the show with people in their 40s who try to look like they're in their 30s, act like they're in their 20s, and have the mentality of teenagers
116
ROBtimusPrime1995Apr 9, 2026
+36
I thought this was fine for the first season, to drive conflict, ya know?
But Season 2 upped the ante to the point that this statement makes too much sense now.
The main characters became caricatures while the supporting cast got fleshed out more, which is a weird accident.
They seriously need to fix this in Season 3.
36
clycomanApr 9, 2026
+28
Doesn't help that s2 was almost a repeat of s1 - the characters ended the season in almost the exact same place.
"I can't be with you because im not ready to convert yet, let's break up, but I love you and we can make this work! I'll convert now for you."
28
LB3PTMANApr 9, 2026
+26
Season 2 literally just felt like a rehash of the first season for most of it. “Oh idk if we can be together because my religion”
26
MyrddinSidheApr 9, 2026
+5
I liked season one, but when they reset everything the first ep of season two, I lost interest.
5
[deleted]Apr 9, 2026
+7
[deleted]
7
ChataboutgamesApr 9, 2026
+6
No it didn't. He's a Rabbi for shit's sake lol. He chose her in spite of the inconvenience/conflict he knew marrying a non Jew would cause in his life and for his career.
And now they're living some of that conflict, and it's a lot easier to make a big proclamation than to live it.
6
AgentElmanApr 9, 2026
+2
Yep, S2 felt like The Force Awakens.
2
thatshygirl06Apr 9, 2026
+2
The main characters were the exact same as they were in season 1. There was literally no change.
2
JaqenHgharApr 9, 2026
+1
Didn’t even finish S2. Got to the Halloween ep and it became insufferable.
1
Stephen_GawkingApr 9, 2026
+16
I keep asking myself how old they think we should think Kristen bell is for exactly this reason.
16
lalalandbeforetimeApr 9, 2026
+9
They’re supposed to be late 30s which just does not translate to how they’re acting.
9
ChataboutgamesApr 9, 2026
+13
But they're supposed to be relatively immature for their ages, just kinda doing a podcast and partying in LA.
13
lalalandbeforetimeApr 9, 2026
+2
I still think they’re acting younger than their age. I live in LA, am younger than the characters, and don’t know anyone as immature as them.
2
nonsensestuffApr 9, 2026
+1
Then consider yourself lucky. Cause immature and self absorbed people are plentiful in LA (source: me, lived there for almost a decade)
1
thatshygirl06Apr 9, 2026
+11
There are people their age in real life who act like teens.
11
DapaaadsApr 9, 2026
+9
Have you hung out with late 30s people? This show isn’t far off
9
lalalandbeforetimeApr 9, 2026
+5
I’m early 30s in LA and don’t know anyone this immature. I believe they exist but it’s just not my experience.
5
DapaaadsApr 9, 2026
+1
It’s more stupidly selfish more than immature. People don’t think beyond themselves
1
LongjumpingChart6529Apr 9, 2026
+11
Thank you for summing up why this show felt weird! I couldn’t put my finger on it!
11
RealSunglassesGuyApr 9, 2026
+11
I still enjoy it though.
11
bitchbananaApr 9, 2026
+2
45 year olds seriously discussing whether to have kids or not and not adopting was wild. Like ok, maybe you’ll have a kid at 46-47?? Lmao
2
Old-Way-5529Apr 10, 2026
+2
it def feels like this show was written for people in their 30s
its hard for me to buy that a rabbi in his 40s would get freaked out when his longtime GF wants to marry him- how has that not been discussed before, especially when they dated for years lol.
2
attheeveApr 9, 2026
-3
Hence the title, *Nobody Wants This*
-3
IndignantHootApr 9, 2026
+25
Sarah Silverman will play a quirky character? Now I've seen everything.
25
Quick-TimeApr 9, 2026
+8
I’m interested in seeing what Avan Jogia will bring to the show.
8
Signal_Reputation640Apr 9, 2026
+19
"Sarah Silverman" - and I'm out.
19
SpiritedTechnician63Apr 9, 2026
+4
Yep they lost me. I’m a champion of the all Jewish people aren’t Zionists argument against anti-semitism. But when Zionists are platformed and protected, they’re making a pretty clear stance.
4
Exciting_Marzipan_19Apr 9, 2026
+5
I hope Kayla plays Maria Sofia Estrada again.
5
fcatwApr 9, 2026
+4
This show should have ended after season 1. These people are old and pretending like they’re in their 20’s, but this entire show is just boring. How many seasons can you tell the same boring story about this girl that doesn’t want to convert to Judaism for the “cool rabbi” that fkks and does drugs lol
4
FanofKApr 9, 2026
+2
This will be the first time I’ve seen Sadie Sandler in something that’s not her father’s
2
ALRTMPApr 9, 2026
+1
Season 2 was unbearable. Pass
1
Razzler1973Apr 9, 2026
That's a hell of a lot of new people for a show that doesn't really have a huge class to begin with
0
GregSaysApr 9, 2026
+1
They're unlikely to all be in multiple episodes
1
AndrewHeardApr 9, 2026
+1
Absolutely love this show and I can’t wait to see where it goes.
The most ironically named show.
1
bananaslug178Apr 9, 2026
+1
Stephanie Koenig is an awful human being. Season 2 was already disappointing but now I'm definitely out.
1
weirdsignal45Apr 9, 2026
+1
RIP The English Teacher. Could've been the funniest show on TV
56 Comments