I honestly thought it would have been either mid or just good but I really loved almost every moment put to screen. I wasn't familiar with the cast really outside of Zlatko Buric and Victoria Pedretti, but I am so happy that I loved the cast. The cinematography was also tremendous to me.
If anyone has seen it, what are your thoughts?
I am currently watching it. I realize I may have an unpopular opinion, but I thought all of the setup was horrendous, no one behaved like any normal person would, and I found it very jarring and hard to get through. The dark lighting did not do it any favors.
78
Calcutec_1Mar 29, 2026
+26
this is not a series based in reality , there are no normal people there
26
Really_McNamingtonMar 29, 2026
+11
I switched to looking at Jo Nesbo's detective hole. Went through six out of eight already.
Edit - I can't count, apparently There are nine.
11
Facemanx64Mar 29, 2026
+16
How was his hole?
16
Underwater_KarmaMar 29, 2026
+9
Dark and jarring
9
fiercetankbattleMar 30, 2026
+3
Have you watched Brand New Cherry Flavour? It has the same “alt universe” vibe that show has. I love it but I can see how it’s polarising
3
The_Vampire_BarlowMar 29, 2026
+4
I watched the first 2 episodes today and the dark lighting is killing me.
4
americanslang59Mar 29, 2026
+2
I quit on episode 4. I couldn't watch any more, "Wife is alone with family member, orchestral score increases, family member is creepy, wife tells husband." scenes. Felt like rehashing the same scene over and over.
2
Really_McNamingtonMar 29, 2026
+31
Does it pick up speed? I watched episode 1 and was yelling at them to get on with it.
31
Sad_Argument5109Mar 30, 2026
+3
Would have been a great movie, didn’t need to be 8 hours
3
GeriatricPineconesMar 30, 2026
-3
It goes down hill from Episode 3 on
-3
Hosni__MubarakMar 29, 2026
+27
The series should have been a two hour movie. It was kinda a drag.
27
PhotographMother253Mar 29, 2026
I dont feel like it should have been a movie but it should have been a 6 episode series instead of an 8 episode one
0
legendary_spongeMar 29, 2026
+12
smells like a bot
12
mudukeMar 29, 2026
+8
One episode left. Wife and I are loving it. It's super weird but also super fun.
8
smile_soldierMar 30, 2026
+3
I thought the first two episodes were fun. Unfortunately it slows down significantly after that, and it seemed that so much of the set-up from the first episode was completely abandoned as it went on. The first episode seemed completely disconnected from the rest, which is too bad because that seemed like an interesting spookypasta type story.
3
ProtectionOld5006Mar 30, 2026
+3
Nope, this ain't it.
3
lourenslokiMar 29, 2026
+3
Not done with it, but enjoying it so far.
3
tannerkistMar 29, 2026
+3
Watched with my girlfriend, and by watched I mean I fell asleep after episode 2 after nothing had really grabbed me in the show. Then she watched the other 5 filler episodes, and I enjoyed the last episode.
3
Calcutec_1Mar 29, 2026
+4
Just finished, pretty good. It’s on par with the best seasons of AHS
4
Curious-Device-9582Mar 29, 2026
+3
Just finished episode 2. It's likeable enough but if it was real life , episode 2 is as far as it would get. The characters and plot are unbelievable . The bride to be would be in Chicago and it would be a wrap.
If you don't mind characters that WILL go into the proverbial basement/loft/outhouse/ not stop and question what'shappening, then enjoy 45 mins of disbelief suspension.
3
fiercetankbattleMar 29, 2026
+3
She literally tries to escape in episode 2…
3
JackSpadesSIMar 29, 2026
+2
I have no clue what happened at the end. No part of that made sense to me. Fill me in if you can I guess.
2
ChartreusePeriwinkleMar 30, 2026
+3
same. i didn't completely follow how they decided who lived and who died.
3
Sl8rboi41Mar 29, 2026
+1
I'm planning to watch it just bc someone said there's a scene where a character is listening to Animal Collective.
1
loetzMar 29, 2026
Welp, now I'm in.
0
Calcutec_1Mar 30, 2026
+2
Adam DiMarco is doing a very similar character to his White Lotus one; like this surface level super nice but actually toxic and bit of a creep without trying or realising it.
2
mollsballs_xoMar 30, 2026
This show was dumb and a waste of time. It started off good, but I thought the “big reveal” was stupid and lost interest from then on.
0
lokintomaisMar 30, 2026
+2
Yes it was amazing. Even the marriage story-eque last episode
2
msr400Mar 30, 2026
I’m glad I didn’t waste 8 hours of my life watching it and instead read the plot online
0
Lost_Kaiju_SlippersMar 29, 2026
+1
So sloooooowww. Should’ve been a movie.
1
Muldoon713Mar 29, 2026
+3
One of the best pilots I’ve seen in a minute
3
useyourelbowMar 29, 2026
+1
I'm looking forward to watching it but that is a truly AWFUL title. I mean really, really bad.
1
PhotographMother253Mar 29, 2026
-1
You could say… something very bad happened to the title
-1
ForgivenessIsNiceMar 29, 2026
+2
Agreed. My wife and I are having a great time with this show.
2
nyc_ifyouareMar 30, 2026
+1
It’s a solid B- for me. Some great ideas, and bears particularly in the first half. It was a movie that had an opinion and I appreciate that. Some things didn’t work but at least the director went for it, at a time when so few movies try to do something new.
1
ILoveRegenHealthMar 30, 2026
+1
Their trailer annoyed me with the misleading "From the director of Baby Reindeer", making you think it was the same creator. It just happened to be one director who happened to do 1-2 episodes. That show was amazing because of the *creator/writer,* not a random director for hire.
1
HomesickpilotsMar 30, 2026
+1
I thought overall it's good. And I like that they didn't settle for a happy ending.
1
loves_to_splooge_8Mar 29, 2026
-5
God what happened to coming up with good titles
-5
ForgivenessIsNiceMar 29, 2026
+7
Seems like a joke of a title was what they were going for.
7
The_Vampire_BarlowMar 29, 2026
+2
Man, I love a good Giallo style title.
Give me Your Vice Is A Locked Room and Only I Have The Key over single noun or adjective titles.
2
mollsballs_xoMar 30, 2026
+1
Could also be the title of a panic at the disco song.
1
obitonyeMar 29, 2026
-8
I M currently watching it and in first episode she was stroking his hair while driving and next second she doesn't. But she didn't remove her hand. Production error?
Same for billiard balls moved when she entered the bar while nooone was playing. Also production error.
Otherwise I feel so scared I can hardly watch it. But I enjoy it tho.
44 Comments