· 199 comments · Save ·
News & Current Events Apr 14, 2026 at 2:02 PM

Syringe reuse at Pakistan hospital infects 331 children with HIV

Posted by RRaj007


Syringe reuse at Pakistan hospital infects 331 children with HIV, probe reveals
Gulf News: Latest UAE news, Dubai news, Business, travel news, Dubai Gold rate, prayer time, cinema
Syringe reuse at Pakistan hospital infects 331 children with HIV, probe reveals
Probe reveals 331 children infected with HIV at Pakistan hospital where staff were secretly filmed reusing syringes and flouting basic infection control rules.

🚩 Report this post

199 Comments

Sign in to comment — or just click the box below.
🔒 Your email is never shown publicly.
[deleted] 5 days ago +12859
[removed]
12859
Ultra_Metal 5 days ago +4473
It's criminal negligence and the perpetrators belong in prison.
4473
LeadingTheme4931 5 days ago +1297
Where’s Hammurabi when you need him
1297
sourisanon 5 days ago +2183
some kid shot him in the zoo
2183
conletariat 4 days ago +713
Dicks out for Hammurabi!
713
ConstantCampaign2984 4 days ago +287
Twice today I’ve seen something about whipping your d*** out for a dead gorilla. I’ve been awake 4hrs.
287
aikeaguinea97 4 days ago +29
good morning!
29
BuckledJim 4 days ago +40
Pros use live animals. Meet me at the zoo, let's carry on this great day.
40
PringlesDuckFace 4 days ago +324
That's Harambe. Hammurabi is a small bird that is capable of flying backwards and feeds mainly on nectar.
324
quacks4hacks 4 days ago +274
That's the hummingbird. Hammurabi is a well known brand of rugged, high-performance SUVs and pickup trucks known for their military-grade off-road capabilities and commanding, boxy, and wide design.
274
xylitol777 4 days ago +205
That's a Hummer. Hammurabi is the fish and sometimes used as as the term Red Hammurabi to mean distraction
205
bunkdiggidy 4 days ago +178
Nah man, that's a Herring, a fish. Hammurabi is a different animal, a young female cow that hasn't yet birthed a calf.
178
og_toe 4 days ago +154
That’s a heifer. Hammurabi is the tool you use to smash nails into objects or walls
154
Reyca444 4 days ago +149
No, that's a hammer. Hammurabi is a ground meat patty, usually beef served on a sliced yeast bun often with cheese and condiments.
149
EVIL_EYE_IN_DA_SKY 4 days ago +182
Goddamn, despite all the bullshit, this is why I love Listnook.
182
TappedIn2111 4 days ago +22
Nope, that’s a heifer. Hammurabi is the term describing a lack of organisation or planning.
22
Racine262 4 days ago +13
That's a Hummer. Hammurabi is sliced cured pork between two pieces of bread.
13
meat_ahoy 5 days ago +52
#JusticeForHammurabi
52
hotstupidgirl 5 days ago +126
Nowhere near Pakistan.
126
skyper_mark 4 days ago +163
I don't think they meant to imply that Hammurabi had anything to do with Pakistan, but rather that Hammurabi would have something to say because his code contains the first registered punishment for medical negligence
163
astral_crow 4 days ago +16
The first for pretty much anything it did to be honest.
16
lNFORMATlVE 5 days ago +285
Honestly should be treated somewhere close to manslaughter. I know HIV is pretty treatable nowadays but how many Pakistani kids have access to those kinds of meds?
285
Key-Rough-8346 4 days ago +210
Even if they have access, they’re condemned to lifelong medical treatment. I’d be pissed off.
210
ragun2 4 days ago +112
Yeah this is kinda how I feel about the California law change where purposely not disclosing being HIV positive and infecting other people was lowered from a felony to a misdemeanor. Like sure we have "access" to the meds here but it's still a lifelong, preventative disease that you now have to deal with because some a****** couldn't put their big boy pants on and have a serious discussion before hooking up.
112
Pizza_Low 4 days ago +51
My cousin did part of his residency for a few months in India. The main doctor told him not to tell the poor patients about the cocktail or whatever the meds were at the time. One week? Month? dose was more than their family annual income. So they were just given symptom management. I’ve heard that since then costs have come down but it still ain’t c****
51
Royal-Hunter3892 5 days ago +294
Disgusting, this is criminal negligence .
294
faultysynapse 5 days ago +7049
How the f*** does a hospital f*** up this badly? 
7049
mjmandi72 5 days ago +5420
Denial. The BBC got footage of them doing it and brought it to the hospital Manager. He said it was either old or faked.
5420
Captain_Legend 5 days ago +3166
He's for sure skimming from the hospital funds leading to an undersupply, theres no way he doesnt know this is happening under his watch
3166
jackbilly9 5 days ago +1237
It's so weird too because needles are dirt c****. Skimming off of that may get you a few bucks. 
1237
CotyledonTomen 5 days ago +1891
Needles are just what resulted in people noticing. Imagine what other corners are being cut.
1891
Darthcookie 5 days ago +406
In Veracruz Mexico a decade ago or so the governor replaced children’s chemo with what was basically distilled water. On top of that there were using expired medications. All of these were from public funds, mind you since healthcare is subsidized. He was also charged with corruption and relationships with organized crime. Him and his then wife (who also embezzled public money) ran from the country, he was eventually extradited and convicted to 9 years in prison. Yup, nine f****** years in prison for being responsible for how knows how many kids’ not getting treatment or potentially died. His now ex wife was granted political asylum in the UK so she won’t be facing any charges for diverting money from an organization whose sole purpose is to help children, families in need and other vulnerable groups. It’s disgusting.
406
dandelion-heart 4 days ago +120
This is extremely evil, particularly considering most childhood cancers are very curable with chemo. For standard risk leukaemia the chance of survival is like 90% with modern treatment (other cancers like solid tumors gave worse outcomes, but leukaemia is much more common).
120
Martha_Fockers 5 days ago +113
If needles are being cheaped out as the cheapest supply everything else above them also is . From treatments and diagnostics to maintenance on mris machines etc. So likely this lead to more issues we don’t see like misdiagnosis or no diagnosis for a disease etc
113
dark567 5 days ago +46
I mean Pakistan has less than 20 MRI machines and they are only available to the rich. It's not a rich country and they simply don't have the ability to do the slate of diagnostics that the west does. That's no excuse for reusing something as c**** as needles but of course Pakistan is cheaping out on maintenance to MRI machines, they are too poor to do anything but!
46
Kespatcho 5 days ago +55
And yet they have nukes, such a brilliant way to spend their money.
55
morganmachine91 5 days ago +66
Needles are dirt c**** for a developed country, but Pakistan is very poor. Just back of the napkin math, but let’s estimate that a single disposable hypodermic syringe costs $0.15 USD. If we assume that the 331 kids given HIV were the ONLY, this incident saved somebody about $50 USD. $50 is only 0.06% of the median household income in the US, but in Pakistan, it’s a whopping 8.6% of the median annual household income. If the problem were systemic at the hospital, which it probably was, it’s still not a TON of money, but it definitely seems like enough to make it worth a staggeringly evil and greedy person’s time.
66
cahagnes 4 days ago +73
I work in a hospital in a poorer country than Pakistan and even here needles and syringes are dirt c****, and ironically, imported from Pakistan and India.
73
21Rollie 4 days ago +21
Same thing for razors, my razors are from Pakistan. Every barber I’ve ever been to (including 3rd world countries) disposes of razors after one use, I hope to God no barber is out there reusing razors to save a couple cents, they come in giant packs.
21
trydola 4 days ago +19
basic stuff like this is even cheaper in developing countries. $15c USD will get you many syringes in Pakistan
19
[deleted] 5 days ago +116
[removed]
116
mrbombasticat 4 days ago +45
I second this, automotive parts sector. Blatant lies to your face with refuting evidence half a page down in the outlook inbox.
45
MrStu 4 days ago +47
There's a cultural attitude of "no, I know those are the rules, but I'll do it this way, it'll be fine, bad things happen to other people, not me". I deal a lot with Indian/Pakistani businesses in tech too, and see it all the time.
47
witchofpain 5 days ago +237
This happened to me in Las Vegas in 04. I had to have an endoscopy. No problem, went fine. Imagine my absolute shock 5 years later when I saw, ON THE NEWS, that the clinic I used has been shut down for reusing needles during the time frame I was a patient. I had to get tested for everything. I was so pissed.
237
topdownyeti 5 days ago +484
Pure negligence. I remember my school had a nurse come and do vaccinations when I was in 1st grade. My mom was over at the school and I asked her to be in the room with me when I got the shot. I guess the nurse didn’t change the syringe and my mom started arguing with her how dangerous it is to use the same syringe for everybody. The nurse started arguing with her that it’s not and my mom doesn’t know what she’s talking about. I ended up not getting my shot that day.
484
Dopamineagonist21 5 days ago +241
What!?!? How many decades ago was this? Should have reported the nurse
241
topdownyeti 5 days ago +223
This was about 23 years ago in the middle east so even if you reported her, nothing would have happened lol
223
paninna 5 days ago +79
Lol that happened to me in 1989 in Yugoslavia. One syringe was used per two kids in school for vaccination. A syringe was used on me after it was used on other kid 🤷‍♂️.
79
Square-Turnip-6558 5 days ago +75
1989 Yugoslavia still having better needle practice than modern day Pakistan
75
mrgonzalez 5 days ago +31
That's different though - blood bond, every child has a lifelong bond to another they have to share diseases with. It encourages cooperation.
31
RBeck 5 days ago +87
Besides all the obvious risk factors, syringes aren't as sharp after a use or two so they hurt a lot more. Any diabetic can tell you.
87
SoHereIAm85 4 days ago +38
I know it's stupid, but I reuse my own needles a fair number of shots until it seemed time to break out a new one. The BBC video I saw, and what was written in the article I read this morning, explained that the needles were (sometimes?) being changed but not the syringe. Apparently the syringe itself gets backwash and therefore becomes very dangerous with pathogens like HIV. I actually didn't know that and always thought it was the actual needle. Apparently they also rely far more on injections of medications that could be given orally due to a heavy perception that injections are better. It's a complicated clusterfuck of ignorance, poor practice, and lack of repercussions. :(
38
Extension-Toe-7027 5 days ago +324
Corruption? If you are in charge of ordering supplies and said supplies are not used you might be able to get creative with the paper work. Or just plain incompetence based on the fact that this are kids and there is no way any of them can have DST's.
324
dattokyo 5 days ago +70
I'm assuming you're young, and just don't know/remember all the times in history stuff like this has already happened? While horrific, it's ***by far*** not the first time something like this happens. I remember years ago the same thing happened with blood transfusions, just as an example.
70
swrrrrg 5 days ago +82
It happened with blood transfusions initially because people didn’t know. It was bad but you can forgive science and a lack of understanding to a degree. We’ve known not to reuse needles or in countries where resources are sparse, to sterilise needles between patients. HIV is not a strong virus in general and we’re talking about 331 people. The sheer number of times they had to be doing this in order for that many people to have become infected is significant.
82
cannotfoolowls 5 days ago +44
>because people didn’t know and then continued after they knew https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contaminated_haemophilia_blood_products#Continued_sales
44
PrairiePopsicle 5 days ago +42
It happened after they knew too.
42
ComradeGibbon 4 days ago +11
Used to be a lot of people would get hepatitis from transfusions. because commercial blood banks were buying blood from junkies. And they knew that. Their solution wasn't to ban junkies from giving blood it was to develop tests to detect infected blood. And when they did that they were confident the problem was solved. And people still were getting hepatitis. Which is how they found out about Hep C.
11
polocinkyketaminky 5 days ago +3355
1 time accidentally using the same needle or syringe is a monumental fuckup. using 331 time a used needle or syringe is more than a monumental f*** up, its just plain psychopath behavior. and who knows how many times they did this. thousands? tens of thousands? the whole system is compromised when such a basic and extremely important procedure goes south.
3355
LuxTheSarcastic 5 days ago +1687
Assuming a 2% transmission rate from a needle stick that means the same needle was used over 16000 times and the first patient had HIV. HIV isn't very contagious which makes this whole case absolutely baffling.
1687
wowyoustoopid 5 days ago +1307
After a few uses the needle is fucked. After just one its noticeable in how much more it resists the pull out. Theres no way it could be one source/needle/patient. Something very weird going on. Thousands of infected instruments.
1307
Enlight1Oment 5 days ago +402
From the article: >Experts say the practices seen in the footage could easily spread infections. “Even if a new needle is attached, the syringe body can carry the virus,” said Dr Altaf Ahmed, a consultant microbiologist. In one instance, a nurse was filmed retrieving a used syringe containing leftover liquid and handing it to a colleague for reuse — an act he described as violating “every principle” of safe injection.
402
MrStu 4 days ago +138
Wow, so they were likely changing the needle but reusing the syringe, Jesus. That syringe could have had anything in it. I wonder how many infection cases they've had too.
138
Nvenom8 4 days ago +15
But that also reduces the transmission rate even more which means the practice was even that much more widespread.
15
LuxTheSarcastic 5 days ago +455
There's the medication vials being reused too but that's probably even less likely to infect than a reused needle... this is like some "entire blood bank is sourced from an AIDS clinic" sized outbreak.
455
wowyoustoopid 5 days ago +172
Its such a large amount for such a low rate of infection, I dont see how it couldn't be something like that. Or the testing equipment is wrong.
172
MadamPardone 5 days ago +157
Other comments are saying it was the actual body of the syringe. It's impossible to reuse a needle more than about 20 times.
157
i_am_icarus_falling 4 days ago +38
Even then, The virus doesn't stay alive for that long outside of the body, the syringe would have to be constantly reloaded with live virus from a source to keep spreading with each needle use.
38
BillysBibleBonkers 4 days ago +56
Could be something like Factor VIII, basically a medication for hemophilia that was made from Plasma pooled from 10,000s of donors. It was early in the aids crisis and they infected tons of people. But don't worry, when the company learned about it they did everything in their power to stop the spread... Just kidding, they lobbied to keep using it, and when there was finally no possible way to keep selling it in the US they sold it overseas to countries that didn't have regulations against it yet. Super fucked up, great episode about it on the Swindled podcast. Don't think I've ever gotten so angry listening to a podcast in my life.
56
xcassets 4 days ago +70
I watched a BBC report on this last night. They were both reusing the same needle sometimes, or reinserting a used needle back into a multi-use vial. One time they were filmed picking up a used needle off the floor and giving it to a colleague to be reused. Additionally, this was systemic and disturbingly common on the children’s ward. They recorded staff admitting that they regularly injected kids with paracetamol regardless of triage to get them to “leave them alone” and stop bothering them.
70
LookAlderaanPlaces 4 days ago +42
This isn’t a hospital then. It’s a f****** biochemical warzone. Who the f*** works there?
42
kkeut 4 days ago +21
how did they know to come there and film this? were there rumors about this in the recent past or a whistleblower or what?
21
mageskillmetooften 5 days ago +35
The numbers add up rapidly over the large period of time. If you would use 100 Needles 10 times that's one thing. But now imagine doing this every day for a whole year.
35
mageskillmetooften 5 days ago +77
Nobody says it was one needle, one source or one patient, the article is also incredible clear that this was not due to one needle. The problem here is that for a long period they re-used needles without cleaning them in between. (re-using sucks, but hey at least clean them)
77
NotLunaris 5 days ago +49
Syringe, not needle. It's in the headline.
49
John_Tacos 5 days ago +39
They used the infected needle(s) to draw from multi dose vials.
39
BoomerSoonerFUT 4 days ago +72
It doesn’t say needle reuse though. It says syringe. Needles are not syringes and syringes are not needles.
72
Gopu_17 5 days ago +17316
Horrifying.
17316
samanime 5 days ago +6492
Infuriating.
6492
SELECTaerial 5 days ago +4030
Yea I’d probably go to jail if this happened to my child
4030
Braindead_Crow 5 days ago +1174
Who do you lash out at? A) The worker who treated your kid. B) Their supervisor for likely enforcing this practice. C) The leadership of the hospital who likely started this practice. D) All the above.
1174
BetweenTheWickets 4 days ago +970
The person at the very top of the chain who greenlit/pushed this practice is the one that deserves the harshest penalty. That may or may not be the supervisor. It could be the health minister himself. You never know. Problem is that Pakistan is riddled with poverty, so perhaps this came about due to dire lack of resources rather than corruption or pocket-lining. In that case, you'd tend to feel a touch sorry for all involved.
970
Braiseitall 4 days ago +313
This is absolutely the result of pocket lining, probably several pockets along the way. Want to do business in Pakistan? The hands are out!
313
wildcatofthehills 4 days ago +177
It reminds me of Duarte, a governor in Veracruz, Mexico that was so corrupt, he replaced the medicine of children with just plain water. Corruption can lead to some huge evils in this world.
177
SunshineAlways 4 days ago +27
Yes, all chipping away at both the money they have to spend, and the actual resources they’re supposed to be receiving.
27
Steamwells 4 days ago +13
Yes, riddled with poverty, but they are one of seven countries in the world with nuclear weapons. They also have a space programme. Ultimately, this is definitely a corruption issue driven by greed, which on the surface appears to be a poverty/lack of resources issue.
13
Bubbly_Style_8467 4 days ago +55
That's what I think. It's not that there's not enough to go around. There are greedy people all over the world, not caring one bit.
55
HurtFeeFeez 4 days ago +59
D all of them. Unless they were somehow fooled into believing they were using new, never used needles than they are all responsible. At some step along the way just one of them needed to do the right thing, they chose not to.
59
EvilDan69 5 days ago +765
I definitely feel what you're saying.
765
codemonkey985 5 days ago +269
We'd be bunkmates for sure!
269
EvilDan69 5 days ago +180
Agreed. if this was some cost saving measure... wow that was indeed horrifying.
180
dineramallama 5 days ago +8889
Remember that time a Chinese baby milk company used known toxic ingredients in their formula to bulk up the product and increase profits? Thousands of babies got hospitalised and 6 died. Two people were executed and several others received life sentences as a result of this. Same thing needs to happen here.
8889
Count_de_Ville 5 days ago +3137
It was melamine. A company (actually at least 20 companies) was caught putting it in baby formula because the tests which determine how high the nutritional protein content was could be fooled by adding melamine. Which is toxic. Even more than 10 years later, Chinese parents still pay a massive premium for formula from Australia, Taiwan, or anywhere they trust better than domestic. Whenever I traveled, I brought as many canisters as possible back with me to China for people I knew who had small children. Always super appreciated.
3137
LtRavs 4 days ago +286
This event created a baby formula mania in Australia. For years supermarkets had to try to police Chinese people from buying it in bulk and shipping it back to China for a premium. Was a real problem for a long long time.
286
ScammaWasTaken 4 days ago +86
Interesting! This also happened in Germany. Must've been a world wide thing, just to supply the Chinese market.
86
Ok_Telephone_8987 4 days ago +33
Yup, i remember working in a supermarket in The Netherlands and there was a max of 2 cans of baby formula per customer precisely because of this
33
StubbornKindness 5 days ago +221
>It was melamine Holy shit, that's atrocious. For anyone who doesn't know, melamine is what is used to make "plastic tableware"
221
tesconundrum 5 days ago +169
It's also what Mr. Clean Magic Erasers are 🙃
169
censored_username 4 days ago +86
Yup. It's a great structure material. Combining it with formaldehyde makes melamine resins, which can indeed be used to make plastic tableware, but really it's biggest applications are in making water-resistant top coatings for particle board. That's how you get melamine boards, which makes up the bulk of material in modern kitchen cabinets. It's pretty inert chemically, and decently non-stick so in that aspect it's a really cool material. And while it's toxic, you really do need significant amounts for that to happen. Scrapings shouldn't cause any issue But as an actual ingredient in baby formula? What the actual f***?
86
Black_Moons 4 days ago +45
Yep, It forms plastic in the kidneys and then you get a melamine baby to bury. All because some CEO wanted more money. The rich get richer and the poor get... deader.
45
PropJoesChair 4 days ago +40
This explains so much. I did a temp job at a warehouse here in Europe, owned and operated by Chinese people. I built pallets and pallets of baby formula every day to be shipped to China, the owner just told me that the Chinese like western formula as they think it's better. I found it strange we were shipping this much baby formula to China, I was thinking surely they have some over there?? She never mentioned this!!
40
un-glaublich 4 days ago +78
It wasn't _just melamine_, it was recycled melamine from furniture coatings.
78
AltruisticTomato4152 4 days ago +32
Jesus
32
windsockglue 5 days ago +413
Weren't others found putting it in dog food as well?
413
NightEnvironmental 5 days ago +519
Yes. But that was regulated. It was ok for them to add up to a certain percentage. It may still be going on for all I know. Lesson = don't purchase pat foods or treats made in China. We use Addiction brand - made in New Zealand.
519
Martha_Fockers 5 days ago +442
The name of that is not confidence inspiring lol
442
nmorguelan 5 days ago +113
I mean its gotta be good with a name like that...
113
msc1 5 days ago +131
Business idea: Dog Crack, Cat Meth
131
PiccoloAwkward465 4 days ago +47
Parakeet Jenkem
47
Proof-Highway1075 4 days ago +20
I worked in a supermarket in Australia when the baby formula started flying off the shelves. We implemented restrictions on how many an individual could buy, but still barely had any on the shelf. Had several mothers distressed and in tears unable to find food for their babies over the years. Was really f****** frustrating and sad.
20
radioactivecowz 4 days ago +20
It’s created significant shortages in the past, but now the Australian companies love the additional demand and even sell the products at airport, post offices etc so it can be sent straight to china upon purchase.
20
Few_Advisor3536 4 days ago +13
There was a shortage in australia at one point because of this. I remember an asian guy had tge back if his car full. What was happening was people here were selling it online to the chinese at an inflated price.
13
planck1313 4 days ago +9
At one stage here in Australia supermarkets had to introduce limits on the amount of formula that anyone could buy at once because the shelves were being emptied by Chinese visitors.
9
BangerSlapper1 5 days ago +1222
I’ll give China credit.  I’m no fan of the death penalty but faced with the audacity and avarice and callousness of the crime, they didn’t f*** around with the punishment. 
1222
EgoTripWire 5 days ago +760
In the US it would have been a $20k fine and jail time for some low level peon.
760
ineververify 5 days ago +221
.43 cent check in the mail. Jail time for no one as they investigated them selves.
221
crabby_old_dude 5 days ago +152
And then a presidential pardon for a political donation.
152
Flyinmanm 5 days ago +35
I suspect only an arrested CEO could afford that. Helps to look tough on crime if you keep the odd poor person locked up. Which reminds me didn't the US's head honcho just accuse the Pope of being weak on crime? I wonder at what point releasing con artists and violent insurrectionists becomes tough on crime. The hypocrisy is maddening.
35
mujhe-sona-hai 5 days ago +48
Trump was literally bombing random boats in Venezuela because they were "smuggling drugs" to America when he had just pardoned Ulbricht Ross the founder of the Silk Road the biggest drug marketplace on the dark net. Hypocrisy knows no end.
48
Renuwed 4 days ago +17
Alyssa Shepherd hit and killed 3 children, a 9 year old and twin 6 year olds, the 4th sibling survived, at a bus stop in Indiana when she 'didn't realize she was approaching a stopped school bus'. She ultimately served slightly over 2 years, having 6 months taken off her sentence for "completing a bible study course". I certainly hope the perpetrators in OOP get more (legal) justice than that
17
Martha_Fockers 5 days ago +99
Are they executing the actual perps tho or just fall guys Cause it’s hard to believe from 20 companies doing the same thing in China at the time that only 2 men are found guilty. When this is a issue that involved way more than 2 guys
99
EugeneNicoNicoNii 4 days ago +28
They executed 2 who created the formula and decided to add melamine in to the milk and sell it off to the companies, like the ones who started it all, they are the original manufacturer where the company source the milk from, they know what they are doing and kick started the entire disaster iirc it's originally 3 but one of them were actually less involved so they turned it into a life sentence along with a shit ton of CEO and government officials who tried to cover this up... surprise surprise, who would have expected Ceo and government officials are never worth trusting Edit: Thought I may add on the reasons why the Ceos and government officials got charged, they peeformed a internal investigation after noticing how some of their customers complain about the milk, and realized someone is shoving melamine on purpose into their products, they then surpressed the news and told the local government, they then tried to do a recall quietly, and due to it not being a public recall many who already bought the milk consumed it anyway leading to another group getting affected, the Ceo tried to suppress the news to save their stocks and the local government officials after receiving the news from the Ceo decide to suppress it as well because the Olympics was in progress and don't want this to go international...So the whistle blower went straight to the Chinese Ambassador which returned during the Olympics and skipped the local government and notify the CCP
28
BallsInSufficientSad 4 days ago +114
They executed the most senior person in both companies that knew about it - the CEOs.
114
Hopeful_Solution5107 4 days ago +46
It says they executed a farmer and salesman
46
GailaMonster 5 days ago +12
The baby food scandal was after the 2007 pet food scandal, where the exact same adulterant, again added by Chinese companies, killed thousands of pets across Europe and North America They didn’t care to do much in reaction to that. Not sure I feel like giving credit, they literally didn’t care to stop selling poison as food until they did it to themselves…
12
MechanicalHorse 5 days ago +149
I’m in the same boat. I’m fairly anti-death penalty, but there are some crimes so heinous that there really is no path to rehabilitation.
149
Bishopjones2112 5 days ago +1296
Not only is this completely inexcusable the sheer volume of children infected is astounding. No reuse of needles should happen in a hospital, ever. But to re use the same needle to cause spread of infection to 331 known cases is beyond comprehension.
1296
ElleHopper 5 days ago +312
The same needle isn't even required to be reused for this. Even if needles were discarded, the syringes being reused or the vials being contaminated could have contributed to this. > Staff were seen using the same syringes across multiple patients, including drawing medicine from multi-dose vials that were then administered to other children — raising the risk of widespread contamination.
312
John_Tacos 5 days ago +81
This is what caused the high numbers right here.
81
LuxTheSarcastic 5 days ago +511
HIV is a bit of a weakling of a virus as far as transmission goes too. A needle stick from an infected person is a 1-2% chance of transmission and while an injection is probably a bit more this is like "every needle or almost every needle in the hospital is contaminated" levels of infections. And also if you left a contaminated needle out for a day all the HIV on it would be dead. The Hepatitis C won't be dead but the HIV will. I genuinely wonder if this was bioterrorism.
511
semimute 5 days ago +135
I was wondering if they were too lazy to even make any attempt to sterilize the needles, this makes it even worse.
135
LuxTheSarcastic 5 days ago +95
Yeah a 1-2% rate is like "you messed up handling the needle that was just in an HIV patient and now it's in your arm and also you didn't do anything about it other than pull it out". So even if they didn't sterilize the needles the numbers are ridiculous.
95
ILookLikeKristoff 5 days ago +94
Yeah that's what I was gonna say. You'd need to stick thousands of kids to infect 330, right?
94
LuxTheSarcastic 5 days ago +106
Thousands of kids and also the needle has HIV the entire time.
106
Quirky-Glove-3199 5 days ago +49
That is really strange. It seems so unlikely unless HIV is endemic in the population the hospital serves 
49
LogFar5138 5 days ago +97
Imagine how dull that needle was.
97
Albert14Pounds 5 days ago +32
Yeah needle tips are blunted after the first use and become "maximally blunted" after only about 5 uses. Pretty crazy to see what they look like under a microscope. I imagine getting poked with a blunt needle sucks.
32
New_Libran 4 days ago +15
It says syringes, why is everyone fixated on needles. So this is definitely a mass reuse of syringes and other equipments without sterilising
15
bluepie 5 days ago +11
It’s the syringe being reused not the needle. The same syringe could have infected blood remnants in it and even if the use new needles it’ll still spread the HIV
11
daviss2 5 days ago +141
BBC World Service on YT posted a documentary on this today for anyone interested and it is shocking. They have a desk with a couple open cardboard boxes and they're just putting used needles in the boxes with no gloves and rummaging around in there, leaving used needles on the desk.. Injecting through clothes.
141
MercantileReptile 5 days ago +262
Syringes are seriously not an expensive item. Especially in bulk purchase, such as hospitals do. >The footage also showed staff administering injections without gloves, leaving used needles on countertops, and failing to properly dispose of medical waste. Parents reported witnessing syringes being reused across multiple patients, further underscoring concerns over systemic lapses. Seems to be less about money, more about people not being trained even a little. I once had a dead end job packing cosmetics and even for that I used gloves. What on earth.
262
inoutupsidedown 5 days ago +78
Yeah this sounds more like systemic incompetence.
78
HigherandHigherDown 5 days ago +48
It's malicious disregard for the welfare of their patients. The guy leading the hospital was removed and then allowed to return. When shown video evidence of the needle reuse he just refused to acknowledge it was happening. He should get life in prison, see if the next guy can do better.
48
Anxious-Slip-4701 5 days ago +19
It's why a lot of foreign aid goes towards such things. Flood the market with so many syringes people can't even resell them.
19
TactitcalPterodactyl 5 days ago +1173
They... Reuse syringes in Pakistan? Sweet baby Jesus.
1173
Tobikage1990 5 days ago +559
Surely not every hospital, or the count would be a lot higher. Sounds like a case of insufficient funding or a greedy hospital manager. Or both.
559
Pcriz 5 days ago +339
Or worse. This is the currently known infection numbers.
339
Benmarch15 5 days ago +124
Ohhh f*** please let it be 1 greedy manager and not a systemic issue...
124
nezroy 5 days ago +54
Hugely systemic. And this is the *improvement*, because at least these babies were tested and, theoretically, may have access to treatment as a result. The previous social norm in Pakistan was to completely ignore HIV testing entirely and pretend there was not a problem.
54
NoKatyDidnt 5 days ago +58
Seriously, right away, my jaded brain jumped to, “Probably just the tip of the iceberg.”. And I hate that. I really hope it’s not.
58
barath_s 5 days ago +20
> Or both. Or what is worse, neither. The state government suspended the hospital head when infection count reached 100. The BBC checked months later, and they still were using the bad old needle practices.
20
Autumnrain 5 days ago +35
I remember reading the same thing happened a couple years ago. Maybe also in Pakistan maybe.
35
ApplicationMaximum84 5 days ago +78
Back in 2019 the BBC reported on it in a village called Ratodero in Pakistan when 900 children and 200 adults were also infected with HIV due to needle reuse.
78
GaeilgeGaeilge 5 days ago +29
It happened in Libya in the late '90's and of course, rather than accept fault, the government blamed foreign nurses whom they tortured. Medical evidence later showed the outbreak had been going on before the foreign nurses arrived. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HIV_trial_in_Libya
29
Spoztoast 5 days ago +51
Youd think they'd at least sterilise them first
51
Tibbaryllis2 5 days ago +80
Unfortunately, the actual metal needle can be sterilized with heat but not the plastic components. So autoclaving (pressure sterilization) would make the needle safe but unusable. There are glass syringes that could be sterilized, but they’re not really readily used anymore and they’re not as durable as plastic syringes. The damndest part of all of this is that syringes are probably one of the cheapest disposal components in a healthcare setting.
80
SouthEastSmith 5 days ago +22
It is possible to make the whole thing out of metal. With a heat-resistant o-ring.
22
Tibbaryllis2 5 days ago +20
Interesting. I was a lab professional for over a decade and had never came across that style in modern use. I knew they existed at one point (I have my grandfathers *embalming* syringes that are stainless), but it didn’t really matter how sterile you could get them….. edit: fun fact: he had a separate set of embalming syringes that he used exclusively for injecting marinades into meats way before it was a common practice. Man knew how to properly saturate a muscle and could cook a damn good roast. It makes sense that it could be made out of stainless steel and survive autoclaving. A lot is riding on that gasket, but I suppose you could make it replaceable. Do you know of any modern applications in living people/animals?
20
vini_2003 5 days ago +28
Right?! Surely, whilst still horrifying, it would at least stop spreading HIV to children?!
28
deft-jumper01 5 days ago +230
Bloody hell…the horror
230
barath_s 5 days ago +52
> The Punjab government had intervened earlier in March 2025, when reported cases crossed 100, suspending the hospital’s then head. However, BBC findings indicate unsafe practices continued months later, raising serious questions about oversight and accountability. It's always sad, but this is particularly frustrating/infuriating
52
Eze-Wong 5 days ago +323
"Despite the evidence, hospital authorities have denied wrongdoing. Medical superintendent Dr Qasim Buzdar questioned the authenticity of the footage, suggesting it may have been staged or recorded before his tenure. He insisted infection control remains a top priority." Bro sounds like he graduated from Trump U
323
SoCalThrowAway7 5 days ago +84
“Bide- I mean Oba- I mean the last guy did it”
84
fk334 5 days ago +207
One disposable syringe costs 20 Pakistani Rupees ($0.072). Current conversion: 1 USD = 278.85 Pakistani Rupees. Why is no one being held accountable for this?
207
who_you_are 5 days ago +127
I don't want to be that jerk but your conversation rate is useless. That is if somebody is giving them money from the outside from a "first world country" (which we all probably don't. And for those who do, I guess most of the money go away anyway) Within the country, I will guess their typical monthly wage suck like hell as well?
127
Minterto 5 days ago +50
Minimum wage in Pakistan is a bit average 1500 PKR a day.
50
terminalzero 5 days ago +30
>Within the country, I will guess their typical monthly wage suck like hell as well? shallow googling says the average monthly wage is around $2-300 USD, which is important context for those numbers to mean anything, but kinda makes it worse honestly
30
Desiman4u 5 days ago +66
Now use the same syringe on people making the decision to reuse the syringe.
66
MrBuckhunter 5 days ago +64
My goodness, i did not want to hear/read this horrible nightmare.
64
swrrrrg 5 days ago +23
How is this happening in 2026? I truly do not understand. This is an unbelievable level of misconduct, negligence and sheer incompetence. Those poor children.
23
analyticalchem 5 days ago +61
Didn’t this happen in Romania years ago? They used the same syringe for childhood vaccinations or something and started a HIV epidemic among children.
61
ApplicationMaximum84 5 days ago +41
Yeah, back in the late 80's and early 90's leading to kids getting hiv and hepatitis.
41
jolhar 5 days ago +11
I’ve seen footage of it happening in several countries. But that was years ago. Didn’t think it was still happening.
11
exciting_one2005 5 days ago +49
The cost of a disposable needle will be payed through human lives. Greatness u see....
49
rygelicus 4 days ago +17
There is nothing accidental about this. This requires an intentional refusal to do things correctly. Whether this is due to slumlord levels of hospital management or someone rejecting modern (meaning the last 300 years of experience) medicine knowledge, this is a choice to do things wrong knowing it is wrong. Even if forced to reuse needles they can be sterilized before reusing in various ways. But these people were just grabbing known dirty needles and even syringes that had not been cleaned and using them. Dipping that dirty needle into the bottle for a new load. Absolutely unforgivable.
17
BangerSlapper1 5 days ago +141
Good lord.  What is this, 1982?  I mean Pakistan isn’t some barely functional place like Somalia.  They have doctors with degrees and training that work in modern hospitals with international level safety standards.  WTF.  
141
Any-Calligrapher2866 5 days ago +87
Pakistan has a very poor population out of which millions are living in Somalia level living conditions. They might have some good doctors and all but they're simply too less for that large a population. And the entire subcontinent is full of corruption at every level.
87
tinkthank 4 days ago +10
The top 1-5% have access to great hospitals and doctors. The rest are fucked.
10
DrZedex 5 days ago +110
Actually, it kinda is like Somalia. We give them like a billion a year for their military, but other than the F16s they're a standard shithole like any other
110
peetad 5 days ago +32
Also lots of western countries pouring foundation money into Pakistan but seeing shit like this and that the western companies which are managing the funds not showing the results of the programmes I can just guess if they are laundering mouney out.
32
BroccoLeee 4 days ago +10
It’s corruption top down, the only people who see none of that money are the ones the NGOs are supposed to help
10
makethislifecount 4 days ago +54
Yup, Pakistan is very much a barely functional country. They have always been on the brink of collapse since I can remember. Just held up by loans and aid.
54
StaticSystemShock 5 days ago +45
If this happened in west, kids would at least get care and normal life. For these kids it's a cruel death sentence.
45
R2CX 5 days ago +13
I must have doomscrolled enough shit for the rest of year and yet more are coming.
13
Agreeable-Match-2633 5 days ago +14
WOW!! Too bad we didn't know how devastating sharing needles could be DECADES AGO! Fuckin stupid, ignorant people.
14
isekai_cheese 5 days ago +40
disgusting
40
dlampach 5 days ago +39
Super criminal. The people who are responsible for the decision to allow this should never see the light of day again. I am wondering how any of the kids died though since HIV is pretty treatable these days
39
Objective_Bear4799 5 days ago +54
It’s only treatable if you have the means and access.
54
JEEvanNEETi 5 days ago +12
Countries be unlocking a new low everyday
12
landofschaff 5 days ago +33
That is f****** tragic
33
ronweasleisourking 5 days ago +32
With all of the doctors coming out of Pakistan, this is very alarming
32
Tricky_Potatoe 5 days ago +11
please let me unread that...
11
rghaga 5 days ago +9
oh my god no this is so f****** sad
9
LongjumpingPilot8578 4 days ago +10
You know somewhere in the shadows, there was some level of corruption. Someone has been pocketing the cost of the new syringes and now children will die.
10
BimmerAddict 4 days ago +10
Pakistan, are you surprised?
10
HappySummerBreeze 4 days ago +8
As soon as the hospital denied it I lost all respect for their humanity. Children are dying because those in charge are too proud to do their jobs
8
vivi_le_serpent 4 days ago +11
Has nukes but reuse syringe ? Holy hell
11
adlopez 5 days ago +17
Last week I was talking to a friend about having read an article a few years ago about ~500 infected from needle use in Pakistan, and now this article pops up. Horrible. Inexcusable for this to happen multiple times.
17
PMmeIamlonley 5 days ago +8
Whoever made the choice to reuse needles should go to prison for life or just be executed as an example. What an avoidable tragedy 
8
← Back to Board