· 32 comments · Save ·
For Sale Apr 19, 2026 at 1:05 PM

The TV series Buffy The Vampire Slayer and the spin off Angel really struck gold with the writing and casting

Posted by James-Samuel17


I was just looking through the acting careers of some actors like Mila Kunis, Viola Davis, Andrew Scott and such and it made me realizes how fascinated i am by acting. I mean, writing is extremely important to me and I want to be that but I also want to be an actor (kinda like Phoebe Waller Bridge who is both and excellent at both.) I think i’ve done my fair part of praise for the writing on both shows, which is phenomenal, like top tier writing style by Whedon and the writers team but this whole deep dive into actors made me realizes how insanely talented the Buffy cast is, like they struck gold with the writing and the cast, which is what makes Buffy one of the greatest TV shows ever made alongside The Sopranos or The West Wing (mentioning them because apperently back then Buffy was considered as good as those two) despite not having big budget or whatnot. The actors are so good with a few standout to me like Sarah Michelle Gellar (amazing lead god. She’s so good in everything, Cruel Intentions she’s a sociopath but looks so good doing it and even on some not so great movies like The Air I Breathe, she still shines. She should have won an Emmy for Buffy and an Oscar for Veronika Decides to Die. Glad to see her having a Renaissance and I hope to see her on some Vanity Fair video where she breaks down her career a bit, she’s one of my all time favorite actress along Kristen Bell, Michelle Williams, Viola Davis, Shannen Doherty, Amanda Seyfried, Meryl Streep, Kerry Washington, Reese Witherspoon, Edie Falco...), Anthony Head Stewart ( i first saw him as Uther in Merlin and GOD this man knows how to be d*** but still have depth and he elevated the material given by the writing on that show, that was sometimes quite rough. And then I saw him in Ted Lesso and he was amazing as usual) , Alyson Hannigan (best tv crier hands down and was equally amazing in How I Met Your Mother, she’s a natural at this. Her dark willowarc, especially the Warren scene made me with she played some villains in career because she can be chilling as hell but that’s what I love about Buffy, it’s that some of those actors had some opportunities stretch out their acting skills and range with Buffy/Angel more than with a ton of movies), James Marsters (turned a short term villain into one of the most iconic TV characters ever. He gave Spike so much layers and from season 5 onwards he’s nothing short but spectacular. The fact that he initially took the job because he was a starving father but then the show ended up being a role of a lifetime is so crazy to me. He just had charisma, comedic timing and then proved to have such range in drama and an excellent love interest), Emma Caulfield (the most underrated one among the cast because this woman is a BUCKET of talent but didn’t get half of the career a lot of them had. She really initially came on for one episode but was so good, the writers had keep her. ), Nicholas Brendon (I know some people don't like him and his character and for good reasons don't get me wrong but he was really talented. Buffy was his very first role and he nailed it so much. He just go Xander right and while I don't like his character, he embodied the role so well, I can't see anyone playing him. His comedic timing, especially physical comedy is really impressive. Physical comedy is something I came to appreciate more and more as I was watching Jason Dohring as Logan Echolls in Veronica Mars. I was watching Coherence with Nicholas and he was so good, such a shame what he became. May he rest !) Michelle Trachtenberg (she was nothing short but awesome. It’s especially impressive considering her young age but she was holding her own against a much older and experienced cast. She gave some really incredible performances like in Conversations With Dead People, she was so chilling in it. Obv, I found her also so great in Gossip Girl where she played a similar character to SMG’s Kathryn, Georgina Sparks. May she rest in peace !), David Boreanaz (this guy has been the leading man of three long running TV shows and is about to get into another show soon, which is so surprising when you see how weak his acting was in season 1 but season 2, for me and Whedon apparently from what I heard, confirmed me that he was a good actor like his switch as Angelus was masterful, again the writing was on fire too but David just blew me off. Obv, that’s when he got his own show that he got to shine and some of his scenes are Emmy worthy, the one coming to my mind is the hospital scene where he yells at Wesley he won’t forgive him for taking his son in Forgiving. My sister and I were introduced to him in Bones and he was really good in it too), Eliza Dushku (it’s crazy to think that Faith wasn’t in that many episodes but each time I think of Buffy/Angel, she’s one of the first things to comes to mind because that’s how good Dushku was the role. I think a lot of the roles she was given wasted her talent because they were focused on making her the typical hot brunette girl, kinda like Megan Fox to some extend but in Buffy/Angel she was so good. Her whole episode Five By Five stays one of my favorite TV episodes ever and part of that is her masterful performance like her breakdown at the end or the torture scene with her and Wesley. I also love how well she went into a manic state from Consequences onwards, she was so good. Dollhouse was also a good show for her acting skills and Tru Calling too), Alexis Denisof (another powerhouse in acting and his developpement as Wesley is nothing but mind-blowing. He handled his character like no other and I could not see anyone in his place but to be fair J couldn’t imagine anyone for the other characters too. I also saw him in the Shakespeare adaption of Whedon and he was also so stellar in it. He was also on Legacies and god this show was horrible and a Buffy knock off but he managed to stand out, that’s how good he is), Amy Acker (if Fred is sometimes a hit or miss for me as a character, it was NEVER an Amy problem because she was always amazing in the role. Her and Denisof killed me in A hole in The World, such monumental performances. Fred’s death may have been tragic but it allowed me to see the greatness that is Acker because the way she switched her entire persona is just.. WOW. Just give her an Emmy right now. Also found her amazing in the adaptation and jn Persons of Interest, where she plays an amazingly chilling character), Charisma Carpenter (just like Eliza, I feel like a lot of projects I’ve seen her in capitalized a lot on her beauty and she would often play the hot bomshell or hot stepwife or something but I found her really amazing in Buffy. Her comedic timing is so good and then on Angel, she can get so good with the dramatic, especially in the last episode of season where she get so many visions, god this scene is hunting. And speaking of the visions, she really sold them half of the time, with the episode That Vision Thing where they get physically harmful on her and it’s just heartbreaking. She was also quite good in Charmed where she played a little character but give it depth, enough so that it’s one of the most memorable side characters despite being in 3 episodes). I think there’s probably more but feel free to add. I just love this cast so much !!

🚩 Report this post

32 Comments

Sign in to comment — or just click the box below.
🔒 Your email is never shown publicly.
Circle_Breaker 6 days ago +54
Josh Whedon's casting in general was brilliant. His strength is his ensemble casts. Having distinct roles and how the characters interact. The casting is half the battle in making that work.
54
makuXrosu 6 days ago +39
To this day the Angel theme is still my ringtone
39
DrSpacemanSpliff 6 days ago +17
Same first four chords as the Buffy theme
17
Kinsbane 6 days ago +34
Mentioning Eliza Dushku and Dollhouse made me sad, but mentioning Michelle Trachtenberg made me even sadder. :( But, yeah, both Buffy and Angel had amazing casts.
34
shinyhpno 5 days ago +3
Eliza Dushku will always be my queen for Tru Calling.
3
LowCalligrapher3 5 days ago +1
I love the cast of Tru Calling, Eliza was a phenomenal lead for them and they all knocked the ball out of the park.
1
TyposIncoming 6 days ago +33
This is pretty unrelated but you talking about Buffy and Angel made me think of it. When a streaming service has shows like these two that have crossovers between them they should have a combined feed option where you can have all the shows involved in release order so you don't have do the extra work of flipping back and forth to get the full picture.
33
thecoffeefrog 6 days ago +14
This is one reason why I stopped watching Chicago PD/etc on streaming. There were too many episodes where it was started on one show, continued on another, and finished on a third. There were even crossovers with Law and Order. It was too much work to try to figure out which show to watch in what order.
14
Morgan-Moonscar 6 days ago +2
And if that's not headache off, then they crossover with another network (on D*** Wolf's FBI shows over on CBS)
2
dballing 6 days ago +2
When I did a rewatch of Stargate I did it using a “canonical watch order” between SG1 and SGA to ensure that it all makes sense.
2
LowCalligrapher3 5 days ago +1
Although at least the concurrent SG-1 and Atlantis seasons were light on crossovers, they certainly mattered to each other, but they also weren't super heavily impactful (as the Buffyverse and Arrowverse events would be). Kinda like the 2000s style of how Star Treks TNG and DS9 had lighter crossovers with each other.
1
Rea-301 6 days ago +13
Think about the writers directors and producers and what they’re doing now Drew Goddard, Steven Deknight, Jane Espenson. That’s just the three off the top of my head. They really hit magic with their casting and talent pool across the board.
13
Surullian 5 days ago +9
It should be noted that Charisma Carpenter and James Marsters had a mini Buffy reunion in an episode of Supernatural (S07E05 Shut Up, Dr. Phil). They were great together.
9
VisibleFiction 6 days ago +16
Even if Whedon is kind of ass that man knew how to write tv scripts and build his casts. In fact I really wish we got a new tv show from him. Producing studio just needs to make sure he's followed by chaperone eveywhere whenever he's visiting the set.
16
Dogbin005 6 days ago +9
I'm actually surprised he hasn't done much since the allegations came out, considering his stuff is generally pretty bankable. It's not like he got me too'd or anything, he's just a c*** apparently. Usually studios will look past that sort of thing if the person can bring in cash.
9
HazelCheese 5 days ago +5
Yeah he basically just yells at people a lot. People who do way worse are still working.
5
cyke_out 5 days ago +3
He was a power tripping control freak that took out his anger on his employees. So, basically just about half of my bosses I've had over my entire life.
3
Grundlage 6 days ago +12
I truly despise Spike's later-season plotlines (>!the whole "he didn't *mean* to r*** me he is actually a good guy deep down trust me you don't understand he has *totally* changed" plotline should maybe have been handled with more complexity!<), and yet even I like Spike against my will because of how excellent James Marsters is. Truly a genius.
12
Vioralarama 5 days ago +3
You should watch Dollhouse. Hm, maybe you don't have to fully pay attention to the first five episodes. Alan Tudyk and Amy Acker, plus some extraordinary acting from secondary characters. Eliza Dushku is weak, but not offensively so. I have to reply to the commenter from another thread who thought the problem with the show was wardrobe, thinking they were providing skintight club wear. Ha, as if. Dollhouse is by far the worst wardrobe I've ever seen, but not because it was s***; it was trying so hard to be quirky and just failed on every level. But the rest of the time the Dolls were naked so there's that.
3
oldspice75 5 days ago +6
And Juliet Landau as Drusilla
6
DrewDan96 6 days ago +5
in the wake of Nicholas Brendon's recent death i've seen a lot of comments to the effect of "his character wasn't loved" type stuff, which really surprised me, i always liked his character. what was it that turned off fans about Xander? i dunno about OP trying to put Buffy on the level of some other top all-time shows, but i'd definitely give it props for being a little Thrones-ian in terms of killing off main characters. i think the first "WHOA" one for me was i think Giles had a female love interest and she got killed, then another major one was when the co-slayer Kendra was killed. hell they killed Buffy early on but clearly that was a fake-out, and then she died a second time and they needed a bigger story arc to resurrect her. definitely an enjoyable show with a great ensemble.
5
James-Samuel17 4 days ago +3
I mean, the writing and the acting are enough to make it one of the greatest TV shows of all time. Many media outlets considered it to have changed television forever, The Body/Once More With Feeling/Hush are all times great. Buffy is EASILY top 10 female characters. Even David Simon (creator of another all-time show, The Wire) said that Buffy was the best show in years. Also, the show is often on every lists of "greatest of all time". I will argue Angel deserves a spot too but Buffy's impact on TV and overall quality is on the level of some top all times shows.
3
DrewDan96 4 days ago -1
i appreciate your passion. i've seen the entire series so i was definitely a big fan of the show. i think maybe i have an unconscious bias in the same way like the Academy Awards rarely recognizes the comedy or horror genres even when there are deserving films/performances. i just cannot put it on the same level as say The Wire, for instance. i think the quip-heavy Joss Whedon style also drops it a bit, cuz just like in the Marvel movies there's all these jokes even in life-or-death moments, kinda diminishes the danger/seriousness element (even though Buffy to its credit DID kill important characters)
-1
zeroxray 6 days ago +5
Idk I thought everyone loved Xander and sympathized with him for his relationship with anya who was a wildcard. I know in the last season people really hated what the Nathan fillions character did to him too
5
DavesWorldInfo 5 days ago +6
It's a very modern, Twitter-mob kind of thing to hate on Xander. At the time, the fanbase generally liked Xander. He was *super loyal* to Buffy and the Scoobies. Whatever it was, whatever the odds, he *always* threw down against evil for the Scoobies. I mean, at the very end, he talked down you-know-who with the memory of the broken yellow crayon. It's *this* generation who's decided Xander must be drawn and quartered. The generation that watched Buffy during release was down with Xander, not down on him.
6
TributaryOtis 5 days ago +2
I hate the notion that Xander was a horrible character because of his flaws, like every single character on that show didn't do awful things at some point.
2
princess_platinum8 5 days ago +1
My mom always had Buffy on when I was growing up and I couldn’t figure out why I didn’t like Xander. Once I watched Buffy during COVID I realized that he was terrible at accepting that Buffy didn’t like him as anything but a friend and that’s when I realized what I was picking up on. His character development in the show was amazing but thinking about that still grosses me out to this day. Though I gotta give it to him: Xander absolutely was the best hero to villain arc in the episode The Pack in season 1. Nicholas Brendan’s acting was absolutely phenomenal. 
1
Bostonterrierpug 6 days ago +2
Kitten P**** carried the show
2
VivianDiane 6 days ago +2
Perfectly said. Especially agree on Emma Caulfield, Amy Acker, and James Marsters' origin story. That cast really was lightning in a bottle.
2
productjunkie76 5 days ago +2
Great casting for sure!
2
PeaceSim 6 days ago +2
I’m on season 7 of Buffy now. No shade to the actors/actresses you listed (all incredible) but Amber Benson has made more of an impact on me than anyone else. From their very beginning, she made Tara feel so authentic and real. Her brief appearance recently in *I Saw the TV Glow* hit me straight in the heart, it was an absolutely perfect place for her to make a cameo like that.
2
Jarita12 4 days ago +1
Agreed. the only thing I cannot forgive Whedon is what he did to Charisma Carpenter and an awesome charater like Cordelia
1
← Back to Board