and just today the probable CM's PA was probably shot dead by the previous ruling party workers. That state is wild west of India in terms of lawlessness
59
No-Coffee22003 days ago
+6
Bengal is politically lawless
but it's much better at law and order than UP and Bihar
6
RossTheLionTamer2 days ago
+4
Lmao what?
How many people have been killed in post-poll violance in UP/Bihar in the last three election?
Bengal is like Gaza in terms of government
4
TryJolly14732 days ago
-2
Bs. Tmc were raping child and babies of suspected bjp voters after they won election in 2021.
-2
Traditional_Stick4814 days ago
-40
It’s West Bengal specific. culture of extreme political violence because of long term control of the far left. The rest of India doesn’t have election season murders.
-40
NotAnUncle4 days ago
+20
Mate as an Indian, up and Bihar already have had an interesting history with crime in politics and elections
20
Traditional_Stick4814 days ago
-8
But they no longer have this issue, in WB it has persisted despite a change in admin
-8
MammothHusk4 days ago
+85
Population higher than Germany, GDP smaller than Hungary.
85
Party_Violinist7354 days ago
+9
Thanks to England.
9
ShvetaHuna2 days ago
+19
Yes, let's blame the English for leaving Bengal the richest and most industrialized state with the richest and most industrialized and developed city as its capital instead of the absolute political mismanagement of the communists that bankrupted the State, followed by the TMC, both parties which literally had people brought over from East Pakistan / Bangladesh to influence elections, and actually threatening entire minority groups in the state into staying at home and casting votes under their names.
Heck, after the last elections, Mamta lost, forced an elected member of her party into resigning, getting elected from that location to maintain her grip on power, and followed up the victory with a literal party ordained o*** of massacre and gangrapes of entire villages she thought had voted for the BJP. Have people forgotten Sandeshkali where the state police under the TMC turned a blind eye to the TMC running a gang r*** organisation, refusing to so much as file an FIR. Bengal and Kolkata have no one but themselves to blame for their poverty and decline.
Salem prospered, Chennai got richer, Mumbai got obscenely wealthy, Pune is getting developed, Baroda rose, Ahmedabad rose, Ludhiana is prospering despite being on the frontlines of a militarily active border. Srinagar is recovering from the lost decades of 1980-2000, even absolute shitholes like Mathura, Lucknow are on the march of progress. Aizawl is slowly getting industries in, so is Manipur, and even the worst off of Naxal controlled territories are slowly crawling back from the morass of Maoist depravity. Kolkata has been in visible decline and every year brings forth a new exodus of businessmen and industrialists, and now, even the farmers in rice paddies have been up and packing and filling trains headed to the Deccan. The English, for all the psychopathic masscres and famines, left in 1947, left the Republic in 1950. It is 76 years since the day the Republic came into existence. Bengal and Bengalis have agency.
19
Hashfyre1 day ago
-2
Wow a combo of colonial apologist and a fascist hindu nationalist. Who could have guessed those two can fuse together?
Oh! Only the founders of the RSS who copied Italian Nazi manifestos.
-2
RailFan653 days ago
-14
Thanks to years of commie rule.
-14
Fun_Dragonfruit79714 days ago
+3
so what?
3
Hayabusa_Blacksmith3 days ago
-3
So what to any of this?
-3
Appropriate_Art_69094 days ago
+50
This man is a psychopath and India, like other failing democracies, will pay the price for decades.
50
marcthe123 days ago
+27
I mean I am not a fan of Modi. But WB under TMC was straight up a mafia state. Hell the previous CM is atm trying to pull a Trump in an effort to keep power. I mean if compare Modi vs Mamta Banerjee, model is the lesser of the evils. Other parties i will disagree though.
27
HumongousSpaceRat4 days ago
+28
I think people overrate how much Indians are in love with the BJP. If India had even a decently capable opposition, he would be out of the office by now. Unfortunately, India got stuck with Rahul Gandhi and his circus
28
rahulrossi4 days ago
+27
Failed democracy is what led India here in the first place. All the options are shit. The MPs that make up the current government were mostly part of other parties previously. The moment someone wins they all change sides, this happens in every state too. It's useless to even discuss democracy in India.
27
MRCROOK23013 days ago
+18
He's best of the worst.
18
faith_lover_3 days ago
-12
A tall f****** claim to make without any data or evidence to back it up.
-12
Exact_Package_72643 days ago
+3
probably because ur uninformed
3
Screye3 days ago
+18
Why do you believe that ?
He's been a generally stable centrist his whole time in power. Elections are fair . Economic growth is stable. Urbanization and infrastructure development is on track.
Compared to the likes of Trump, Boris and populist crazies in stable democracies, Modi is about as even tempered as they come.
His overwhelming popularity has to do with the opposition being so incompetent that people would vote for a scarecrow in the field before they vote for him. Imagine if the Democratic candidate for every year from 2010-2025 was Kamala Harris. And she lost every year, and again she remained the only candidate on offer. That's the Congress (primary opposition) in India.
18
Adept_Havelock3 days ago
-5
And how do Muslim citizens feel about the BJP and Modi?
-5
Screye2 days ago
+16
No worse than any other group when an opposition party comes to power in a democracy. No politician is loved universally.
Sunni Muslims don't like him, but their life isn't meaningfully changing with him in power. A majority of Shias and Ahmedias vote for him. Generally speaking, stable economic development is more important to poor people of all denominations. Policies have been even handed without special bias towards or against hindus.
16
GomuGomuNobukkake2 days ago
+8
Can't wakeup someone pretending to be sleep
8
norcalfiend2 days ago
+7
The BJP and Modi objectively suck for Muslim citizens.
The prior ruling parties courted the Muslim minority and providing them religious-based concessions in land management, the legal code, affirmative action, etc. A secular state should have similar rules for all of its citizens not based on religion. Add the checkered history of Islam on the Indian subcontinent, the BJP attacks of minority appeasement and pandering from the Left resonates nationwide.
Barring a massive BJP screw-up much worse than demonetization and COVID, I don't see a path for India's opposition parties to become relevant again until they can abandon the status quo. Yet, instead they're doubling down - I get it though since it's hard to push your core constituencies to abandon concessions they were given for decades, but the math does not work out to win elections.
I don't think Indians love the BJP as much as there's no alternative option that isn't following the old status quo in policies. It frankly will involve parties on the Left having tough conversations with the Muslim community on what is viable / is not viable. But until that changes, the BJP is going to keep winning by default with the only question the margin.
7
joozyan2 days ago
+5
Poverty has dropped substantially in India since Modi took over.
5
Lase1894 days ago
Shows how democracy itself is no guaranteed path to progress
0
Centeredrightbhakt052 days ago
+4
I love it when a non Indian whine about Modi winning in India. Its a pure joy.
4
Gandalfthebran4 days ago
-7
Nah. I hope more states turn saffron in India.
-7
Recent_Risk_32424 days ago
+3
sorry man, but we love Democracy.
3
Gandalfthebran4 days ago
+4
Oh? So if people vote for BJP for their state, it’s not democracy?
4
Accute-CET3 days ago
-12
rigging it?
-12
KRyptoknight263 days ago
+8
I dislike BJP too bro but shit like this makes you sound like MAGA republicans. It's embarrassing. That's why this moron keeps winning states. The opposition just isn't interested in improving
8
KRyptoknight263 days ago
+3
I dislike BJP too bro but shit like this makes you sound like MAGA republicans. It's embarrassing. That's why this moron keeps winning states. The opposition just isn't interested in improving
3
Gandalfthebran3 days ago
+8
That's called sore loser behavior. Something something 2020 US election behavior.
8
Nasha2103 days ago
-4
Modi is the perfect combination of pragmatism and xenophobia.
37 Comments