Hi everybody! I’m just trying to start a casual and positive conversation. I’ll do my best to be responsive 🫶🏼🍪 What would you say your three favorite Girl Scout Cookies are? Mine would be
1. Lemonades
2. Caramel DeLites
3. Adventurefuls
I just had two of each of several different ones 😵💫 and that’s my vote.
Bonus question: what do you wash them down with? Most times for me it’s water or milk, maybe a fruit juice.
Also, I don’t want to support a big chain or corporation over a Girl Scout, but has anyone else noticed the same cookies are on the shelves in grocery stores 😅 I am guilty and bought a pack of “Lemons” when I was craving them in a pinch.
yeah i used to love samoas but upon discovering just now they've been renamed "caramel delites" they just lost a customer lol. all those names suck
3
mazerbrownMar 30, 2026
+2
Had this discussion on another thread. There are two bakeries that make the cookies. One calles them caramel delites and the other samoas. It depends on which region you're in on which ones you get.
2
lurkermurphyMar 30, 2026
+1
oh ok whew because last time one of those girls was staked out outside my walmart, i did ask for samoas and she did not flinch, and i saw this post and was like "do they even know what girl scout cookies are?" haha
1
luminousobliqueMar 30, 2026
+1
Yep, there are two companies that bake the cookies, ABC Bakery and Little Brownie Bakery. Every year, each council (regional Girl Scout organization) gets to decide which to buy from. They do this on purpose to create some competition between the commercial bakeries. Some of the cookies have the same name no matter which bakery, but a few names are copyrighted by one or the other, so the names change depending on which bakery your local girl scout council is using this year. Tagalongs and Samoas and a few others have different names.
They (the GS council) can also choose which varieties to offer (there is a core group of cookie types they have to offer, and then some options for other types). This is why you can travel to a different area and sometimes find different types of cookies for sale by Girl Scouts in the next county over.
1
SpiritualVodkaSauceMar 30, 2026
+1
I think they are actually called different things in different areas which is extremely confusing and I also don’t like… like just call them one or the other haha
1
mazerbrownMar 30, 2026
+3
They have some new ones out this year, Rocky Road flavor based. They're not to bad. Favorites are the Samoas though.
3
SpiritualVodkaSauceMar 30, 2026
+2
I actually snagged a box of those rocky road inspired ones and I’m not sure how I feel about them. I don’t think they are bad at all I just don’t know if I like them myself.
2
noelleparrishhMar 30, 2026
+3
The peanut butter stuffed chocolate ones are like crack to me. The red bag. And freezing them is a game changer !
3
SpiritualVodkaSauceMar 30, 2026
+1
I’ll have to snag me a box of those next time I get some!
1
TheFursOfHerEnemiesMar 30, 2026
+2
I really haven't had Girl Scout cookies for over 20 years. I always liked Thin Mints..
2
SpiritualVodkaSauceMar 30, 2026
+2
My mom and dad always bought thin mints so I started out and grew up on those. I’ve heard they are good if you put them in the freezer
2
TheFursOfHerEnemiesMar 30, 2026
+2
Oooh that sounds amazing!
2
Jumpy_Chard1677Mar 30, 2026
+2
As a girl guide (canadian) oh to have enough options to ask for top 3. If you count the chocolate and vanilla sandwich flavours we technically have 3... Out of those I think I might actually say the vanilla sandwich to be my favourite, Though probably because my parents like the mint ones best so I have those more often than the sandwich cookies, it's always fun when I get to have the sandwich ones.
2
topazcoMar 30, 2026
+2
Coconutties
2
LokiLostInDreamsMar 30, 2026
+2
Tagalongs, Samoas, thin mints. I used to love do-si-dos, but the don’t make those anymore
2
gimpisgawdMar 30, 2026
+1
Tagalongs, Samoas, and Thin Mints.
1
ididreadittooMar 30, 2026
+1
Thin mints and both peanut butter flavors (the chocolate covered and the sandwich cookie type, I don't remember the names).
1
luminousobliqueMar 30, 2026
+1
1.Thin Mints
2.Thin Mints
3.Thin Mints
And yes, you can buy Keebler knock off versions of a number of flavors of Girl Scout cookies. If you want to support Girl Scouts, you could buy the knock off version for less, then donate the difference to your local troop in cash... The Girl Scout troop makes about $1-$1.20 profit per box selling the official cookies.
1
glauriebMar 30, 2026
+1
Samoas and shortbread.
I am guilty of buying store brand samoas. I relieve my guilt by donating boxes to the troops when the Girl Scouts come around.
24 Comments