I think it's a sloppy mess that was carried by charismatic performances and great special effects.
5
tultommyApr 2, 2026
+3
Even that's a stretch. It was ... fine. It certainly doesn't justify the cult following it has gained since then.
3
GrunklsnortApr 2, 2026
+1
The cult following is exactly what it deserves, but the thing about a cult following is that it's essentially just a vocal minority and that's okay.
1
AnxiousBurroApr 2, 2026
+9
My takes:
People complaining about long gaps between seasons often make it sound like they’ve put their lives on hold for two years, doing nothing but waiting for a next season. In reality, most people, who actually touch grass, just live their lives and when the show returns they pick it up again. It’s really not that deep.
"I completely forgot what happened last season, so I’m not interested" excuse is one of the laziest arguments out there. Just watch a ten-minute recap on YouTube or something.
MCU take: The supposed "reliance on watching other media" to understand a specific show or movie is overblown. You don't actually need to watch Ms. Marvel or know who Kamala is to understand The Marvels. Almost every project includes a perfectly clear exposition dump to get the audience up to speed.
9
monsieurxanderApr 2, 2026
+2
Long gap discourse is so goofy. People were glazing Fallout for coming out in the next calendar year, even though it still took 20 months between seasons... the same amount of time as various shows that were criticized for it.
2
ChataboutgamesApr 2, 2026
+3
I'm a thousand percent convinced it's just the internet feeding on itself. No one IRL cares about this, people aren't bitching at happy hour after work about the time between seasons.
It's something so petty and meaningless that it could only thrive on social media, where people manufacture outrage for approval more than because they actually give a shit when Stranger Things comes out.
3
Upbeat_Tension_8077Apr 2, 2026
+1
Lol ngl I actually agree with the first take, because I can easily check out several other shows in the meantime while I wait for a particular show I'm following to return (& also rewatch that show during the wait or revisit discussion posts to keep refreshed on the story), plus I don't want a show to feel the pressure of returning the next year if there's the possibility the quality feels rushed as a result (but I still acknowledge that it could take its time & could end up with the same feeling).
Also, I do also see the sentiment of people wanting more shows with seasons running over 10 episodes in general, and I think that's not necessary for specific shows that could end up having episodes that might feel like it's stretching out storylines too long.
1
ChataboutgamesApr 2, 2026
+1
>
> MCU take: The supposed "reliance on watching other media" to understand a specific show or movie is overblown. You don't actually need to watch Ms. Marvel or know who Kamala is to understand The Marvels. Almost every project includes a perfectly clear exposition dump to get the audience up to speed.
You're not wrong, but when they entire IP puts *so much* weight on the interconnectedness and context it's nor surprising that people feel deflated when they're lacking that context. It's like, the number 1 thing Marvel markets.
1
TheShowLoverApr 2, 2026
You say:
> People complaining about long gaps between seasons often make it sound like they’ve put their lives on hold for two years, doing nothing but waiting for a next season. In reality, most people, who actually touch grass, just live their lives and when the show returns they pick it up again. It’s really not that deep.
But then you say:
> "I completely forgot what happened last season, so I’m not interested" excuse is one of the laziest arguments out there. Just watch a ten-minute recap on YouTube or something.
It's because we touch glass and fill our lives with other activities and responsibilities, that the details of a show we watched **2 to 3 years ago** slipped from our memory. It's not enjoyable to be temporarily lost when watching new episodes when a show finally returns. A ten minute recap is not going cover every single thing especially for a show with numerous characters and subplots.
0
kingofwaleApr 2, 2026
+8
Love is a blind is an interesting concept. But completely pointless when everyone is fairly attractive….
Do 50/50 of attractive and unattractive people and it will be infinitely more entertaining
8
j_b_1983Apr 2, 2026
+5
Been telling my wife this for years. Throw in some ugoos and some womps.
Then we will test this entire Love is Bling concept.
5
IrrelevantPuppyApr 2, 2026
-3
That would be torturous to watch.
-3
kingofwaleApr 2, 2026
+1
Why….
1
IrrelevantPuppyApr 2, 2026
What if it isn’t serendipitous? What if they’re not attracted anymore because of looks?
I don’t want to watch people have to go through “oh shit, I did like you, but now I can’t because of how you look. And that makes me upset with myself”. And that’s the mature take, keep the cameras on and let emotions run wild to see how awful it will get.
Even if the couple continues to work well together the fans will accuse them of pretending to be ok with the “ugly person” for the sake of the cameras. Imagine what it’d be like to be the “ugly person” and read the discord online, reducing you to a prop in the “pretty person’s” life.
This would make this show even more toxic. It might make it a more viable relationship study experiment. But it would be toxic as f***
0
ChataboutgamesApr 2, 2026
+2
I think there's a pretty wide variety of attractiveness levels on there. Sure they've never included someone awful looking but it's hardly Love Island or some shit.
There have been numerous plotlines where people struggled with physical attraction after they left the pods, which pretty much demonstrably proves the blind part isn't "pointless."
2
BrakaFlockaApr 2, 2026
+9
It's asinine for people to say "I'm not bothering with Game of Throne because I heard how bad the ending is."
It's about the journey, not the destination and the journey was some of the best television to ever exist (S3-S5 especially)
9
QyzykApr 2, 2026
+3
Season 5 was the season I quit watching the show.
3
EnzhymezApr 2, 2026
+1
Idk man I feel like the destination mattered a lot here. I can’t explain how jarring it was for my favorite show to be reduced to dog shit at the end.
A wound that will truly never heal for me .
1
ChataboutgamesApr 2, 2026
+1
> It's about the journey, not the destination
I mean, you don't get to decide what entertainment is "about" for other people, and it's absurd to pretend that foreknowledge about the ending doesn't impact the journey.
1
IrrelevantPuppyApr 2, 2026
+1
“Journey, not the destination”? Sound like a bridge 4 some kind of overarching moral message.
1
BrakaFlockaApr 2, 2026
+2
My crem knows no bounds
2
mjknlrApr 2, 2026
I don't know why people keep saying that, [it ended after season 6.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GoCqIB1ufr0)
0
monsieurxanderApr 2, 2026
Also just asinine for people to outsource their opinions to the internet like that.
0
ChataboutgamesApr 2, 2026
+2
Do you consume every piece of media ever created? Or do you generally filter what's worth your time based on some amount of consensus?
2
cinnawars123Apr 2, 2026
+2
While Kim Bauer made stupid decisions, she wasn’t actually that bad of a character like how everyone made her out to be.
2
djkhan23Apr 2, 2026
+2
I think Deadwood is better than The Sopranos and Breaking Bad. Deserves to be ranked 2nd after The Wire.
2
motherofmoonzzApr 2, 2026
+7
The Pitt should not have beat Severance at The Emmy's....it's not that amazing of a show as everyone praises it to be
7
Jr05sApr 2, 2026
+5
Ehhh. Severance doesn't flow as good or have a consistent tone/setting. It became a lot of "tell" don't "show" this season. The scene where adam Scott argues with himself is the only thing that was memorable for me.
5
monsieurxanderApr 2, 2026
+1
Severance has higher highs and lower lows. The Pitt is more consistent.
1
Leading_Apricot6346Apr 2, 2026
+2
The Pitt was solid but yeah Severance was on another level entirely. That show messed with my head in ways I'm still processing months later
The workplace horror combined with the sci-fi elements just worked so perfectly, meanwhile The Pitt felt more like standard prestige TV even if it was well executed
2
j_b_1983Apr 2, 2026
+2
The Pitt is INSANELY overrated.
2
new_handleApr 2, 2026
As is Severance.
0
whatsupeveryone34Apr 2, 2026
right? I don't usually watch hospital dramas... (got burned out around House), but I gave The Pitt a shot and was totally underwhelmed.
The acting is good, but it's hard to find ER dramas compelling anymore. We have been desensitized.
Also, Severance is amazing, but sci-fi/fantasy will always get snubbed.
0
Mother_Ad_3561Apr 2, 2026
+4
Could tell from the post title a hot take wouldn’t be found inside
4
Thefilmcritic52Apr 2, 2026
Do not disrespect me boy
0
Mother_Ad_3561Apr 2, 2026
+2
Command respect by knowing the difference between a hot take and an unpopular opinion
2
donglover2020Apr 2, 2026
+3
I've said this a lot, but the ending of How I Met Your Mother makes perfect sense, and is aligned with the writing of the show as a whole.
anyone who didn't like it needs to rewatch the show, with the ending in mind.
but that's not say it wasn't a frustrating ending. I totally get it watching the show every week for years, having like tens of episodes focusing on Ted letting go of Robin to only then get it all thrown out the window.
3
IrrelevantPuppyApr 2, 2026
+2
I think they were “damned if you do, damned if you don’t”. Can you imagine the outcry if the mother was just some random lady we know nothing about?
2
shakalacApr 2, 2026
+2
I think a lot of people's issues with the ending wasn't that he ends up with Robin, but they basically did it all in a single episode, and wasted the rest of the season covering the wedding weekend.
2
Petrichor02Apr 2, 2026
+1
I think you're right about that being the issue for the majority of people, but (and maybe this is my hot take on the show), I think the issue for the majority really should be the other way around.
With all of the show's flashbacks, flashforwards, and general framing device, the show has a pretty tight timeline. And by that I mean that we knew that Ted's daughter was born in 2014, which means the Mother probably got pregnant in 2013, and Season 8 ended in 2013.
The writers wanted to end the show with Season 8, so when they got the renewal for Season 9, they had limited options. Since the show is called How I Met Your Mother and is all about how Ted eventually met the mother, that was obviously going to be where the story ended (barring any epilogue). They couldn't have Season 9 be a standard year without breaking their timeline.
So Season 9 had to be a bunch of stories crammed into a short timespan unless they got really creative with it and had most of the episodes be flash-forwards to after Ted's meeting with the Mother in such a way that didn't ultimately devalue their meeting. So spending the whole season covering the wedding weekend made perfect sense (even if it didn't lead to the most interesting stories all of the time).
But Robin and Barney getting divorced when the show had been building up that relationship since Season 3 and shown both Robin and Barney improving for one another during that time... Ted and Robin ending up back together after Ted was shown to have moved on from her three separate times... Those elements are what didn't feel earned, IMO.
Granted, I'll give the writers credit to an extent because I don't feel like Robin was ever greater to Ted than the Mother was. I fully believe Ted when he tells his daughter at the end that she missed the point of his story, and it wasn't told to them just so that he could get their permission to date Robin. So I do think audience reaction that the Mother was Ted's consolation prize that just gave him kids so he could eventually move on to be with Robin is a mistake. But I do think him ending up with Robin undercuts a lot of emotional moments from the show like the fantasy sequences we see in "As Fast As She Can" and "The Time Travelers".
1
ChataboutgamesApr 2, 2026
+1
The Ted/Mother/Robin ending was ballzy and great. What sucked was the wedding season and the coupling of Robin and Barney generally. It played in to the show's worst instincts and being beat over the head with "they're right for each other, they're right for each other" just for narration to say "surprise they weren't" sucked.
1
saintashApr 2, 2026
+2
Supernatural 100% catered to the gay undertones of the show. And forced the cast to deal with rabid fans.
2
whatsupeveryone34Apr 2, 2026
+1
I feel like this isn't a hot take and is just obvious.
1
tultommyApr 2, 2026
And it dragged on for about 10 seasons longer than it had any right to.
0
Zestyclose-Height-36Apr 2, 2026
+2
the worst part of the walking dead is realizing Shane was right, and only the people who put their own survival first make it through. Eli Wiesel wrote about surviving the Holocaust that only the worst of people survived, the ones who snatched a morsel of food from other starving people.
2
ChataboutgamesApr 2, 2026
+3
That's pretty incompatible with the entire survival/prosperity of our species being built on community buildings.
Like I'm not arguing with Wiesel, but a very particular manufactured situation creating an environment where only the worst survive doesn't make for a universal truth.
3
QyzykApr 2, 2026
+1
In Vikings, Lagertha should have died during the big battle of the Season 4 mid-finale. The writers of the show were desperately trying to hype up that big fight between Ragnar and Rollo, but it was obvious that neither of them could die in that fight. As a result, the whole thing feels a bit toothless. But if Lagertha was killed, they would both have good reason to mourn, and Ragnar has a whole other reason to disappear into the wilderness afterwards. Not to mention that I did not like Lagertha's storylines after that Season 4 midpoint, so I wouldn't miss them at all.
1
tultommyApr 2, 2026
+1
The real hot take about the Walking dead is admitting that nearly everyone on that show was a an absolutely awful human being. Shane and Rick were some of the better ones and they were both awful as was CORALLLLL. Dale and Glen were about the only half decent folks on the show and we saw what that got them.
1
NewKidOnTheBlankApr 2, 2026
+1
Married with Children got better over time, not worse. I love how it basically became a live action cartoon!
1
kinisonkhanApr 2, 2026
+1
Orville would be a better show if it didn't try so hard to mimic Star Trek The Next Generation.
1
Mysterious_Ant8200Apr 2, 2026
+1
lowkey agree with that, Shane was messed up but it never felt like pure hatred, more like he thought Rick was in the way of what “needed” to happen. my hot take is that Breaking Bad peaked way earlier than people admit, like season 4 was the real high point and everything after just rode that momentum. also I’ll die on the hill that Skyler gets way too much hate compared to what Walt was actually doing lol
1
phantombrick22Apr 2, 2026
+1
Velma is a decent show that gets way too much hate
1
TheNerdChaplainApr 2, 2026
+1
The Klingons in Star Trek Discovery look cool and are perfectly canonical. They actually seemed more alien with an alien culture than just binge drinking Samurai Viking Bros.
1
ChineseCosmoApr 2, 2026
-2
Michael Schur comedies aren’t that funny and certainly not *good*.
-2
HAMforPastryApr 2, 2026
-5
Taskmaster is shite
-5
whatsupeveryone34Apr 2, 2026
-5
I mean you are certainly entitled to your opinion. My opinion is that your opinion is stupid.
-5
HAMforPastryApr 2, 2026
+1
It's hot takes obviously I know I'm in the minority
1
SacriliciousQApr 2, 2026
-2
Shohreh Aghdashloo's acting ruins every *The Expanse* scene she's in. Her cadence is like that of a below-average reader reading the script for the first time. People chalk this up to her accent, but it's more than that. Other actors with strong accents don't stumble so awkwardly over their delivery.
-2
DeeDeeD1771Apr 2, 2026
I HATED Shane. Such a d\*%k.
0
Jedi71Apr 2, 2026
+1
"You can't protect her, Rrrriicccckkk!"
1
WySLatestWitApr 2, 2026
Friends has aged worse than almost any other famous long running American sitcom that came before it.
62 Comments