You've probably heard about the Invincible animation complaints by now and the recent reveal of a grand total of **4** VFX people on the team. There's been a whole debate about what people should be realistically expecting from animated shows. I got curious and watched some stuff about Robert Kirkman and it does seem like he *really* wanted a live action adaptation and is trying to twist the animated series to fit that vision. So now I want to know what you all think.
Let's say that I want to make an animated adaptation of an action comic similar to Invincible. The most important factors are time, staff count, and what I envision the show to look like (I'm not entirely sure how to best describe this one - maybe "direction"?).
I have a few options:
1. Small staff, but much longer timeline and longer gaps between seasons (let's say 2-3 years)
2. Large staff, shorter timeline (6-8 months between season releases)
3. Small staff, mid timeline, but taking a lot of shortcuts, cutting out or abstracting a lot of stuff, and/or hiding the deficits where I can
In your opinion, which of these options would make for the best final product? It'd be cool to see examples if you have any too.
My examples I think would be The Legend of Korra for option 2 and Playing Death Games to Put Food on the Table for option 3 (sort of. The limitations worked around well enough early on but later episodes get a little wonky even with the direction that they went with). Both have flaws in different areas.
Well I think if one’s motivations are having a sweet final product…they should look deeper. I don’t think anyone’s dream is to create a final product. There’s no motivation there. You’d have to determine more why you really want to make something of that nature. That’s way more important than the logistics
2
[deleted]Apr 15, 2026
+1
2 of course why would it even be 1 or 3
1
EmergencyHungry6425Apr 15, 2026
+2
Option 1 actually works great if you look at something like Attack on Titan - they took their time between seasons and animation quality stayed consistent through the whole run
2
-space-your-face-Apr 16, 2026
+1
Either option 1 or 2 depending on the focus of the teams. Idk why option 3 would even be considered?
4 Comments