Not necessarily the best movie ever; but one where the performance of that actor is arguably the best or a personal favorite for you, of their career.
Or perhaps; a performance which resonates with you.
Examples for me are, Heath Ledger in the Dark Knight but tinged with such sadness.
And Emma Thompson, in ‘that scene’ in Love actually, (after she realises Alan Rickman has cheated.)
What are your gems?
Nicholas Cage in Raising Arizona.
I dislike Cage's acting and I don't like any of his other films that I've seen, but Raising Arizona is one of my top five favorite movies and that's largely because of Cage.
37
Jerome_Eugene_MorrowApr 2, 2026
+10
Funny story - Nic Cage didn’t like working with the Coens because they didn’t let him improvise as much as he wanted. He called them “authoritarian”.
10
iz-MoffApr 2, 2026
+12
That's funny, cause i always think of Cage in particular as the kind of actor who needs a good director to constrain him a bit.
12
UrguthaForkaApr 2, 2026
+1
>the kind of actor who needs a good director to constrain him a bit.
Or a lot!
1
YujiroDemonBackHanmaApr 2, 2026
+32
Jack Nicholson in A Few Good Men.
Just a few minutes of screentime, legendary delivery of his lines.
32
motophiliacApr 2, 2026
+3
His conversation with Markinson and Kendrick when they're talking about transferring Santiago is excellent. He lived and breathed authority for that entire scene. Actually for pretty much the entire movie.
3
ScarycloudsApr 2, 2026
+30
In Bruges really made me change how i thought of Colin Ferrell. Before watching it I didn’t really care for him, he always seemed to have a hammy role in hammy action movies. In Bruges definitely showed he had some real comedic chops and dramatic range.
30
Audacious_insolenceApr 2, 2026
+12
The multitude of facial expressions he does by simply moving his eyebrows around a bit are completely stunning. You can clearly see every emotion intended behind the faces he makes. Dude has insane range
12
ahorrribledrummerApr 2, 2026
+6
Banshees of Inisherin did it for me with Ferrell. Touching and sad but incredibly comedic.
6
RustySheriffsBadge1Apr 2, 2026
+22
I think Leonardo DiCaprio was phenomenal in Blood Diamond.
22
HarrisonRyeGrahamApr 2, 2026
+2
One of the best movies Ill never watch again lol
2
SwimmingllamaApr 2, 2026
+24
Adam Sandler in Uncut Gems. Brilliant performance in an amazing movie… even if watching it is like having a 2 hour panic attack.
24
Awkward_Bison_267Apr 2, 2026
+35
Raul Julia as M.Bison in “Street Fighter”. And I’m not stating this out of pity because he passed, no one could’ve carried that movie like he did.
35
patricksaurusApr 2, 2026
+14
He played a bad guy who was self aware that he was the bad guy and took delight in it… corny humor, inflated ego, exaggerated villainy. It really is like a character from Shakespeare. All the more impressive because it was in a “so bad it’s good” movie.
14
Awkward_Bison_267Apr 2, 2026
+3
Here’s the thing, he didn’t think he was the bad guy. Go YouTube the “Bisonopolis” speech. He thought he was taking over the world to make it better! Bison was nuts! And Raul Julia played it perfectly.
3
patricksaurusApr 2, 2026
+3
That is the single best piece of movie trivia I’ve ever heard.
3
Bigtits38Apr 2, 2026
+7
I’ll see that bet and raise with Addams Family.
7
xXSpookyXxApr 2, 2026
+13
The chemistry he had with Anjelica Houston was incredible. The entire idea behind the Addams family is that having an outward appearance that is unusual doesn't mean you can't be a good person, and Gomez and Morticia relationship are central to that. They are a devoted couple who are also engaged and loving parents.
So much of that performance is carried in the way Gomez looks at Morticia. Raul Julia somehow deliberately amps the performance up to ridiculous levels for laughs, but maintains authenticity at the same time. It's hard to overstate just how difficult it is to attempt both things at the same time and land them.
13
Awkward_Bison_267Apr 2, 2026
+3
The only issue there is everyone was good in the Addams Family. Raul Julia was great but he didn’t have to carry the movie.
3
Louloubelle1978Apr 2, 2026
+26
I usually cannot stand Tom Cruise as an actor or generally as a person, but absolutely thought he was brilliant in Tropic Thunder and (I’m probably one in only a handful of people with this next one) as Lestat in Interview With A Vampire
26
kojaakApr 2, 2026
+9
I feel the same way about him, but he was excellent in Magnolia.
9
_gegaApr 2, 2026
+10
He is excellent in every film where he actually has to act.
10
Flashy-Ebb-2492Apr 2, 2026
+5
Collateral is my favourite performance of his.
5
tisdueApr 2, 2026
+2
Jerry Maguire is another example.
2
HappyGilOHMYGODApr 2, 2026
+9
"Spotlight" is probably the best acting performance for a handful of people in that movie, but specifically I'm thinking Rachel McAdams'
9
UrguthaForkaApr 2, 2026
+8
Ben Kingsley in Gandhi (1982)
8
LallnerApr 2, 2026
+2
Greatest acting performance in history.
2
Mattloch42Apr 2, 2026
+2
Alternatively, him in S*** Beast as an absolute monster that scares the living shit out of everybody. He just *exudes* menace and violence.
2
The-BangaloreanApr 2, 2026
+14
Christian Bale in the Machinist
14
RegionComplex7304Apr 2, 2026
+8
dude went full method actor and basically destroyed his body for that role. lost like 60 pounds and looked like a walking skeleton but it made the whole insomniac thing feel so real and disturbing. bales always been intense but that level of commitment was just insane
8
eren_yeegarrApr 2, 2026
+6
And then immediately afterwards beefed up for batman
6
IHKAS1984Apr 2, 2026
+1
It's even more than that. Bale did Reign of Fire immediately before The Machinist, so he went from buff hunk to emaciated ghoul to buff hunk in the span of \~3 years
[The Hunk-Ghoul-Hunk pipeline](https://i.imgur.com/OqPKXFQ.png)
1
KeepGoing655Apr 2, 2026
+3
Thor 3 gets my vite. Everyone knows its a cheesy Marvel movie and phoned it in except Bale. The exposition scene where his character loses his daughter was so gut wrenching and memorable.
3
milmill18Apr 2, 2026
+23
Gary Oldman in Leon the Professional
Natalie Portman in V is for Vandetta
Heath Ledger in Dark Knight
23
uncertainmothApr 2, 2026
+8
Natalie Portman in V for Vendetta is always my post on these questions. So incredible. The scene when she come out and realizes, then goes into the rain, just... visceral.
8
CalleighGwynApr 2, 2026
+3
"I can't feel *anything* anymore!"
3
heartbreakkiddxzApr 2, 2026
+8
Charlize Theron in Monster
8
Subject_Customer3254Apr 2, 2026
+6
Stallone in Copland.
6
Lurking-TroutApr 2, 2026
+14
- Sally Field in Lincoln [The scene where she begs that her son not be permitted to enlist - wow]
- Daniel Day Lewis - Lincoln [Absolutely riveting throughout the whole movie]
- Liam Neeson - Schindler's List [that end of war leaving scene made me cry]
- Clint Eastwood - Unforgiven
- Gene Hackman - Unforgiven
- Denzel Washington - Man on Fire
14
xTVPxApr 2, 2026
+5
It’s funny because Neeson was originally cast as Lincoln. Wonder if he’d have had the same effect.
5
Lurking-TroutApr 2, 2026
+3
Oh, I forgot one of the finest... if any youngsters out there have never seen the Finale Episode of the TV series M**A**S**H** (Shot like a movie - at the time most watched show in the history of TV)... then if you can find it be prepared for a performance from Alan Alda that will be used by acting schools for decades to come.
3
mockteau_twinsApr 2, 2026
+1
Daniel Day Lewis - There Will Be Blood
Daniel Day Lewis - Phantom Thread
Daniel Day Lewis
1
Greenback5280Apr 2, 2026
+2
Daniel Day Lewis - My Left Foot
2
LLFD1982Apr 2, 2026
+1
Daniel Day Lewis - In The Name Of The Father
1
ResidentSea7632Apr 2, 2026
+10
Not a movie, but shows. But Bryan Cranston going from Malcom in the middle to breaking bad was crazy to me! He played both characters which were total opposites really well!
10
StahlmattApr 2, 2026
+6
Anthony Hopkins in The Father
6
Blueliner95Apr 2, 2026
+6
O Brother Where Art Thou is peak George Clooney. He’s the handsome hero but also (and mostly) a buffoon and weasel who thinks he’s brilliant. It’s such a great part and the whole ensemble is perfection
6
Takoshi88Apr 2, 2026
+9
Hugh Jackman in The Prestige.
Robert Angier is a tragic character, often thought of as the villain, but really he's just a broken man whom only has his tricks left, but giving what he has over to true magic is a deal with death and sooner or later, it ruins him.
Jackman's portrayal is a powerful depiction of a man who loses everything and then comes face to face with his own mortality, and with his own demons. You can see it in his eyes that somewhere along the line, has a very sobering, very gradual revelation that he has truly lost himself and the man he was.
9
SerWrongApr 2, 2026
+1
Jackman in The Son as well. You can feel him feeling so helpless.
1
eren_yeegarrApr 2, 2026
+12
Tom Green in Freddy Got Fingered
12
dakotanorth8Apr 2, 2026
+8
Rip Torn in Freddy got Fingered
8
diddleherontheroofApr 2, 2026
+3
Tom Cruise - Magnolia
3
Freethebirds11Apr 2, 2026
+4
Forest Whitaker in the last king of Scotland
4
Famous_Abrocoma_1335Apr 2, 2026
+3
Gena Rowlands in A Woman Under the Influence (1974). Cassavetes basically built the film around watching her fall apart and reassemble in real time. There's a dinner table scene where she's trying so hard to hold it together for her husband's coworkers and you can see every single thing happening behind her eyes simultaneously. No other performance has made me feel like I was intruding on something private the way that one does.
3
Choice-Wind-9283Apr 2, 2026
+5
Robin Williams one hour photo
5
BRUNO358Apr 2, 2026
+5
Tom Cruise in Collateral.
5
konoha37Apr 3, 2026
+1
Yes! This movie reminded all of us that he can actually act when he has to. He nailed all the little details here a delivered a perfect and memorable performance.
1
raulmonkeyApr 2, 2026
+3
Bruce campbell in bubba ho teph.
He is my favourite actor of all time , and the idea of this movie is soooo out there that most people probably haven't watched it but his acting and dialogue is brilliant.
3
keot2Apr 2, 2026
+3
Hugh Jackman - Prisoners
Samuel Jackson - Pulp Fiction
Christoph Waltz - Inglourious Basterds
Toni Collette - Hereditary
Val Kilmer - Tombstone
Ian McKellen - LotR FotR
Everyone in Boogie Nights
3
SeaworthinessKey3654Apr 2, 2026
+3
Al Pacino - Dog Day Afternoon
Al has so many brilliant performances, but everything I love about him is wrapped up in Sonny. He’s electric, a live wire. …yet also vulnerable, decent, and funny.
It’s one of the greatest performances ever
I’ll also mention Scarecrow, which is a completely different role for him.
Al’s character, Lion, is this gentle, goofy, naive soul who worms his way into gruff Max’s (Gene Hackman ) heart - and he suffers a trauma that is unbelievably harrowing. Afterwards, something in him had died, that bouncy, silly guy wasn’t really there anymore…the light had completely gone out of his eyes.
It’s then compounded on later, and it’s just beyond devastating. Al’s portrayal of a men who is completely broken is shattering and soul-crushing
3
DumptydoodleApr 2, 2026
+3
Humphrey Bogart in The Caine Mutiny
Gloria Swanson in Sunset Boulevard
Marilyn Monroe in The Misfits
John Wayne in Red River
Elvis Presley in King Creole
3
bloodshotforgetmenotApr 2, 2026
+3
I was impressed with Leto in Dallas Buyers Club
The movie was fantastic overall but it came to life with him.
3
CorollaSEApr 2, 2026
+2
Bruce Almighty
2
Madi473Apr 2, 2026
+2
Jeff Bridges in the Big Lebowski
2
Martag02Apr 2, 2026
+2
Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor in Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf. Some of the best acting in history in my opinion.
2
Fritzy0811Apr 2, 2026
+2
Honestly, for me its robert pattinson in the lighthouse… its kinda raw and unsettling but also weirdly human. like u can see every little crack in how he feels without him saying much makes me wonder if its easier to notice these things when the role forces actors to be that exposed or if some people just carry that intensity naturally..
2
xSugarHeatApr 2, 2026
+2
Emma Thompson’s crying scene in Love Actually is the most realistic 'heartbreak' ever filmed.
2
ahorrribledrummerApr 2, 2026
+2
Frances McDormand in Three Billboards
Jeremy Renner in Wind river
Josh Brolin in No Country for Old Men
2
UpalSecamApr 2, 2026
+2
You motherfuckers will be playing basketball in Pelican Bay when I get finished with you. SHU program, nigga. 23 hour lockdown. I'm the man up in this piece. You'll never see the light of... who the f*** do you think you're f****** with? I'm the police, I run shit around here
2
DovahkyngApr 2, 2026
+1
"You just live here!" Such a goated scene.
1
darkholemindApr 2, 2026
+2
Daniel Day-Lewis in There Will be Blood
2
throwaway_dlcdApr 2, 2026
+1
Had to scroll too far to find this
1
BobTulapApr 2, 2026
+3
Joaquin Phoenix in Joker. He was great in it, and he seems to be terrible in everything else.
3
Audacious_insolenceApr 2, 2026
+3
Her? Gladiator? Guy has some really respectable roles
3
Freethebirds11Apr 2, 2026
+5
He’s amazing in the master.
5
HoneyBucketsOfOatsApr 2, 2026
+2
I was gonna say he’s a much better in The Master
2
Freethebirds11Apr 2, 2026
+2
I wish he won the Oscar for that role
2
makan_nasi_kuningApr 2, 2026
+1
Morgan Freeman in Invictus, his appereance as Madiba made me forget how Nelson Madela look like. In fact, he has very similiar face with Nelson Mandela
NB : Yeah, there was an incident about this
[https://atlantablackstar.com/2013/12/20/morgan-freeman-mistaken-nelson-mandela-public-tribute-sign-india/](https://atlantablackstar.com/2013/12/20/morgan-freeman-mistaken-nelson-mandela-public-tribute-sign-india/)
1
Tight-Plum-3491Apr 2, 2026
+1
Al Pacino in Scarface and the Carlitos Way, and in so many other movies.
Robin Williams in Good Will Hunter ,Dead Poets Society, Mrs. Doubtfire, Moscow on the Hudson.
Daniel Day-Lewis in The last of the Mohicans, in the name of the Father, My beautiful Laundrette, Gangs of New York.
Michael Douglas in the Game, Falling Down, Basic Instinct.
1
rotatoApr 2, 2026
+1
Terry Crews in Idiocracy
1
match_Apr 2, 2026
+1
Jack Nicholson in As Good as it Gets.
He’s a proven actor, but his portrayal of the OCD guy filled with animosity to the world was delightful. And when he was delighted by the dog who shared (or mimicked) his OCD, you could feel his soul opening up just a bit to let the sun in.
1
StubbleWombatApr 2, 2026
+1
A lot of people saying Jack Nicholson but it's gotta be The Departed.
1
Beneficial-Mix9484Apr 2, 2026
+2
I thought Leonardo DiCaprio was more excellent in The Departed. The look of pain on his face. There was a lot of excellent acting in that film however as you mentioned Nicholson, Matt Damon, Mark Wahlberg and Martin Sheen.
2
Guile21Apr 2, 2026
+1
- Nicholas Cage : Pig
- John C. Reilly : Terri
- Tom Cruise : Born the 4th of July
- Toni Colette : Hereditary
- Jim Cummings : Thunder Road
- Adam Sandler : Uncut Gems
Not movies but in my opinion their best work:
- Tim Heidecker in his stand up special "An evening with Tim Heidecker"
- Colin Firth in the "Pride and prejudice" miniseries
- All the main cast of Better Call Saul in Better Call Saul, especially Reah Seehorn
1
AdkLoon2024Apr 2, 2026
+1
J. Lo in Out of Sight. I might actually go Clooney in that movie as well.
1
commissions-expertApr 2, 2026
+1
Casey Affleck, Manchester by the Sea. I'll be honest, when he won the Oscar I didn't fully get it. He seemed almost too understated, too flat. So I rewatched it. Then it hit me. That casual hospital corridor scene, where he's just existing in the worst moment of his life, no big speech, no dramatic breakdown. And by the time you get to that final confrontation with his wife on the street, you realize he hasn't been underacting this whole time but he's been playing a man who genuinely has nothing left inside. The performance doesn't ask you to feel sorry for him. It just shows you someone who's already accepted that he's beyond saving.
That's not acting, that's disappearing into a person.
1
Beneficial-Mix9484Apr 2, 2026
+1
Casey affleck's acting always looks so effortless That's why he's so good.
1
fzvwApr 2, 2026
+1
I don't think this is the right sublistnook to ask
1
Slammajadingdong69Apr 2, 2026
+1
Hate on Tom Cruise all you want, but the dude rode a motorcycle off a cliff and parachuted down to a ravine below in Mission Impossible.
That’s objectively badass in the absence of green screens and stunt actors.
1
Beneficial-Mix9484Apr 2, 2026
+1
Tom Cruise can show a lot of emotion just in his close-ups. He's a good actor. I'm hoping for the day he plays character roles as Ethan Hawk is doing now and in recent past Cruise. could do it.
1
Slammajadingdong69Apr 2, 2026
+1
He was a force in Magnolia. That scene with Jason Robards was intense.
1
MatthewHechtApr 2, 2026
+1
James Cromwell in Babe
1
Shevek99Apr 2, 2026
+1
James Cromwell in L.A. Confidential.
1
Greenback5280Apr 2, 2026
+1
Sleuth - starring Michael Caine and Sir Lawrence Olivier, the only two actors in the movie. Absolute epic acting from both. The movie was released in 1972 so it's old. Like fine wine, it ages well.
1
Greenback5280Apr 2, 2026
+1
Into The Wild - Emile Hirsch
1
Greenback5280Apr 2, 2026
+1
A Simple Plan
Billy Bob Thornton AND Bill Paxton at their best
An outstanding film also
1
IHKAS1984Apr 2, 2026
+1
Mia Goth in Pearl. The movie itself is great, but her monologue towards the end next level amazing.
1
musicjunkee1911Apr 2, 2026
+1
I have a happy one: How about Ellen Burstyn in Requiem For A Dream? A powerful and tragic performance.
1
peoplesmartApr 2, 2026
+1
Keanu in The Matrix.
1
KablefoxApr 2, 2026
+1
Midnight Cowboy.
Hoffman is such a presence, and the complete lack of Voight's acting chops makes it oh-so more evident that it's incredible to watch.
V for Vendetta.
The fact Hugo Weaving gave such a performance under a mask, with just his voice, it's absolutely insane and a testament to his talent.
1
tauntonlakeApr 2, 2026
+1
Ben Affleck - The Accountant.
1
WookieBaconApr 2, 2026
+1
I was introduced to Viggo Mortensen in Lord of The Rings. He seemed to have similar characteristics through Hidalgo and History of Violence.
It wasn’t until Green Book where my appreciation for him went beyond. It was so lively and entertaining from the quiet personality.
1
YelnikApr 2, 2026
+1
I would say almost every actor in The Departed was at their peak.
1
Mattloch42Apr 2, 2026
+1
Cary Elwes in **Princess Bride**. Master swordsman, wrestler, tactician, a Man in Black becomes the Hero in the blink of an eye. The movie would have completely failed if he was bad for even a second. He has a great movie career, but he played one of the all-time great characters and made the impossible believable.
1
LostNtranslation_Apr 2, 2026
+1
Mission: Impossible - Fallout: Henry Cavill
1
DogsBikesAndMoviesApr 2, 2026
+1
Say hello to my little friend!
1
Ok_Blacksmith1684Apr 2, 2026
Dicaprio: In Shutter Island and Wolf of Wall Street...pretty much most his roles.
Depp: Blow
Phoenix: Joker
Chalomet: A Complete Unknown and Beautiful Boy
Phillip Seymour Hoffman: Before the Devil Knows you're Dead and Owning Mahoney
Casey Affleck: Manchester By The Sea
0
Flashy-Ebb-2492Apr 2, 2026
-1
Emma Watson in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1.
108 Comments