Any other films that were based on books that were based on films that were based on different books?
A different complicated example that comes to mind is "The Fly II", which is a sequel to "The Fly", which was a remake of a movie which had a sequel called "Return of the Fly" , but the "The Fly II" is not a remake of the sequel to the original film.
Little Shop of Horrors (1986) is a movie based on the musical play from 1982 which is based on the Roger Corman movie from 1960 which was inspired by the story "The Reluctant Orchid" in 1956 by Arthur C. Clarke which was inspired by "The Strange Orchid" in 1894 by H.G. Wells.
1074
SeaPeepsMar 24, 2026
+152
More fun useless trivia: the 1982 musical was written by Howard Ashman, music by Alan Menken.
Based on the success of a horror musical about a talking plant, they would be recruited by a company famous for a mouse to write an animated musical about a red-headed mermaid (based on a Danish short story written in 1837); the musical would be turned into a book, a Broadway stage production in 2008 and a live-action movie in 2023.
...and that's before Aladdin, Beauty and the Beast, Newsies, and a bunch more.
152
orphankittenhomesMar 24, 2026
+85
And Alan Menken has himself admitted how musically similar "Somewhere that's Green" and "Part of Your World" are to each other, especially at the end. He (or someone else close to the production?) lovingly called the latter "Somewhere That's Wet."
85
JoshmoredecaiMar 24, 2026
+18
His reminiscences make the Little Shop Tiny Desk Concert must-see, tbh.
18
dasbtaewntawnetaMar 24, 2026
+12
this is definitely one of my favourite LSOH facts, Disney apparently loved it so much they hired the guy who wrote the songs haha
12
SeaPeepsMar 24, 2026
+14
Then they took the guy who wrote "The Internet is for P***" and a parody musical about an American church in Africa, and had him write an animated musical about bad weather based on a story by the same Danish author.
14
le_fromage_puantMar 24, 2026
+79
Huh. Today I learned about the Clarke/Wells origins. Time to head to the library, thanks!
79
Ched_FlermskyMar 24, 2026
+31
And the 1960 LSOH was made in a weekend, thanks to a bet between Roger Corman and Charles Griffith. They reused sets (and plot points) from the movie Bucket Of Blood. It was Jack Nicholson's first movie role.
31
GoatWithBeardofGreyMar 24, 2026
+29
I came here for the LSoH reference
29
WritingUnicorn2019Mar 24, 2026
+3
Oooohhh
3
WompatuckruleMar 24, 2026
+484
West Side Story is a movie based on a stage musical based on a Shakespeare play which is based on a long poem which was based on Italian & French stories.
484
MagisterFlorusMar 24, 2026
+124
And those Italian and French stories were based on 100ish lines of Latin poetry that were probably based on a lost story.
124
Jeff_goldfishMar 24, 2026
+11
Hmm still gonna need sources on all of those to confirm.
11
MagisterFlorusMar 24, 2026
+47
Here, I'm talking about Pyramus and Thisbe in Ovid's *Metamorphoses* Book 4, Lines 55-166. Same basic structure. Teens in love, fathers don't want them to be together, girl seems dead so boy kills himself, girl discovers dead bf and kills herself.
47
_PM_ME_PANGOLINS_Mar 24, 2026
+21
That’s also the play that the rude mechanicals stage in A Midsummer Night’s Dream.
21
Salt_Blackberry_1903Mar 24, 2026
+5
*Ninus’s tomb!!*
5
Jeff_goldfishMar 24, 2026
+9
Haha oh man I was just kidding! But thank you haha
9
kilkenny99Mar 25, 2026
+2
Unless if they were based on Layla and Majnun (7th century Persia), which is rather long.
2
MagisterFlorusMar 25, 2026
+3
I wouldn't be surprised if that shared the same origin as Pyramus and Thisbe as Ovid's story is set in Babylon.
3
nlodingMar 24, 2026
+22
Spielberg’s “West Side Story” is based on a movie based on a stage musical based on a play based on Italian and French stories …
22
noshoes77Mar 24, 2026
+3
Same lineage for Grease! The original play is very different than the film.
3
johndoenumber2Mar 24, 2026
+3
And isn't R&J based on Pyramus and Thisbe?
3
mr_jiMar 25, 2026
+3
Anything that went from Shakespeare to a modern play to a modern movie seems like cheating.
3
poop_monster35Mar 25, 2026
+3
Do you bite your thumb at me, sir!?
God I love that movie.
3
a20261Mar 24, 2026
+350
The Producers (2005) a movie musical, based on The Producers (2001) a Broadway musical, based on a movie, The Producers (1967) which was *not* a musical (and actually first conceived of as a novel).
350
Salarian_AmericanMar 24, 2026
+105
Hairspray (2007) pulled this one as well. John Waters' Hairspray (1988) was made into a Broadway musical that premiered in 2002, which was then made into a movie.
105
a20261Mar 24, 2026
+11
Yes! Unlike some of the Disney stuff, which is all based on the same source material. (Lion King animated, Lion King Broadway, Lion King "live action" all based on Hamlet, for example).
11
Solvang84Mar 24, 2026
+5
Same with Footloose, Valley Girl, and Mean Girls.
5
SylviSweetheartMar 24, 2026
+8
Mean Girls is yet another example, and that one goes a step farther because the original movie is based on a book.
8
mariusioannespMar 24, 2026
+6
And that book is non-fiction.
6
sharrrperMar 24, 2026
+52
>The Producers (1967) which was *not* a musical
The movie itself is not, but it's about the production *of* a musical and contains in-universe musical numbers.
52
drhunnyMar 24, 2026
+32
Used to work with two senior guys in a lab. One was a funny american. The other a stuck up german. Whenever the german would would pretentiously inspect and modify the equipment setup by the american (who was better at it) the american would start humming 'Springtime for Hitler' to rattle the german.
32
Uranus_HzMar 24, 2026
+15
Diegetic is the word you are looking for
15
grahampositiveMar 24, 2026
+10
Is the 1967 movie a movie about a musical?
10
a20261Mar 24, 2026
+12
Not a real musical, unfortunately. But *Springtime for Hitler* is a musical play in the world of the 1967 movie.
12
EdwardBilMar 24, 2026
+3
Which also contains a musical. Which I hope no one has adapted in real life...
3
CartoonWeeklyMar 24, 2026
+2
I saw the 2005 version for the first time not that long ago, and I was surprised to find out it was a musical.
2
le_fromage_puantMar 24, 2026
+198
My Fair Lady (movie)
⬇️
My Fair Lady (musical)
⬇️
Pygmalion (GB Shaw play)
⬇️
Pygmalion (Greek mythology)
198
ari-is-new-to-thisMar 24, 2026
+74
and you can go further and look at She’s All That
74
IHaveSpecialEyesMar 24, 2026
+20
And Not Another Teen Movie
20
glaziaMar 24, 2026
+7
And Educating Rita.
7
Archie_AsparagusMar 24, 2026
+23
This one is actually missing a step! My Fair Lady (1964 movie) is based on My Fair Lady (1956 musical), which is based on (or at least takes the ending from) Pygmalion (1938 movie), which was adapted from Pygmalion (1910? play), loosely inspired by the Greek myth
23
qeqMar 24, 2026
+38
This format is so much easier to read
38
BusybodiiMar 24, 2026
+4
You could start this at Pretty Woman
4
Basic_Seat_8349Mar 24, 2026
+266
Mean Girls 2024 is a movie based on a musical based on a movie (Mean Girls 2004) based on a book.
Which is funny, since in 30 Rock many years ago, a character received an award for Best Actress in a Movie Based on a Musical Based on a Movie. And of course Tina Fey was involved in Mean Girls.
266
jbogginMar 24, 2026
+127
And to complicate it even more, the book Mean Girls is "based on" is a non-narrative non-fiction book.
127
le_fromage_puantMar 24, 2026
+87
“Queen Bees and Wannabees” by Rosalind Wiseman if anyone is interested
87
DefiantEmpoleonMar 24, 2026
+21
Love the Mystic Pizza musical.
21
MaIngallsisaracistMar 24, 2026
+24
I'm more of a Rural Juror gal myself.
24
astroK120Mar 24, 2026
+11
They adapted The Rural Juror? I'm a huge Kevin Grisham fan
11
MaIngallsisaracistMar 24, 2026
+6
Jane Krakowski singing the song in the 30 Rock finale is one of the funniest/most touching moments in television history. I laugh and tear up every time.
6
DefiantEmpoleonMar 24, 2026
+5
I hear they’re working on the sequel: Urban Fervour.
5
ds0Mar 24, 2026
+11
🎵 When life keeps handing you anchovies
Just cover that up with some extra cheese 🎶
11
FX114Mar 24, 2026
+3
Which has become a real musical since that episode was made.
3
vikrambediMar 24, 2026
+59
The Princess Bride is a movie, pretending to be a book. The book it is pretending to be is real, and is a book pretending to be a different book.
59
FunkycoldmediciMar 24, 2026
+15
I always loved the movie. When I finally read it I was delighted to find that it is not a fantasy story book, it’s a weird story about a fantasy story book and including much of that book. It’s so damn funny.
15
vikrambediMar 24, 2026
+4
Definitely one of the rare "movie is better than the nmbook" instances, but really a delightful book as a companion to the movie.
4
jpterodactylMar 25, 2026
+3
I think the grandpa reading a storybook works better as a framing device than the book’s framing device.
But I do like that both are excuses to just give you the good parts. That’s very funny to me.
3
Sweeper1985Mar 24, 2026
+5
I like the part of the book where "Stephen King" (yes, that one) debates with the author about the significance of the expurgated chapters from Morgenstern, and how in his view they were important historical accounts of Buttercup's preparation for the throne.
5
SmokeyMcDooglesMar 24, 2026
+52
Wasn’t there recently a High School Musical: The Musical: The Series? So a show based on a musical based on a movie?
52
Salarian_AmericanMar 24, 2026
+37
I never watched it, but I was given to understand that High School Musical: The Musical: The Series wasn't actually an adaptation of the musical, but a mockumentary show about a group of high school students staging a production of High School Musical: The Musical, shot in the actual high school where High School Musical was originally filmed.
EDIT: I looked it up, that was definitely what it was. And there were four seasons and a different musical every season
37
SmokeyMcDooglesMar 24, 2026
+16
So the show was a fake documentary about the making of a musical based on a show? That’s even weirder!!
16
Salarian_AmericanMar 24, 2026
+7
Not about making the musical in the first place, it was about high school students putting the musical on as a school project
7
xwhyMar 24, 2026
+3
This is as silly as an actual TV game show (probably in the 80s, and it didn't last) based on the game Monopoly. They gave out a copy of their home game -- it wasn't the actual Monopoly game, but some simplification of the game show based on Monopoly.
3
SeaPeepsMar 24, 2026
+105
Leonard Cohens (late 2000s) posthumously charting Hallelujah is arguably a cover of Jeff Buckleys (posthumously charting) cover of John Cales (1991) cover of Leonard Cohens (1984) Hallelujah. (Rufus Wainwright probably goes in there too somewhere.)
It’s a reference to a set of psalms that are a few thousand years earlier.
105
DotquantumMar 24, 2026
+9
Probably soon to be a stage musical, then a movie (musical) coming to a theater near you. Then a play (non-musical) then another movie based on the play. A novelization is coming in there somewhere.
9
CalamityClambakeMar 24, 2026
+8
Don't forget the podcast about the making of the movie hosted by one of the actors from the stage musical, now available to stream as a limited series on Netflix.
8
SeaPeepsMar 24, 2026
+5
The board game based on the novelization of the stage musical based on the podcast has some amazing mechanics.
5
No_Hovercraft_2719Mar 24, 2026
+37
Cats is a movie based on a musical based on some poems by TS Elliot. It’s not that complicated but it is very silly
37
hnglmkrnglbrryMar 24, 2026
+33
We had to read those poems in high school and I remember thinking, "What the f*** is this nonsense?" Then we had to watch the musical and I thought, "No, what the f*** is *this* nonsense?"
33
Fritz5678Mar 24, 2026
+7
Loved the stage musical. Couldn't get through the first 5 minutes of the movie.
7
forever_erraticMar 24, 2026
+6
I have a book of TS Elliot cat poems with Edward Gorey illustrations. The illustrations are great, the poems are very boring.
6
JeffRyan1Mar 24, 2026
+67
["A sequel to a prequel to a spin-off of Air Bud:"](https://www.avclub.com/a-sequel-to-a-prequel-to-a-spin-off-of-air-bud-10-unli-1798272828)
67
Sic_Semper_DumbassesMar 24, 2026
+63
That reminds me of the Scorpion King 2, a sequel to a prequel of a sequel to a remake.
63
xwhyMar 24, 2026
+13
Now that’s what I’m talking about!
Hollywood is weird!
13
trialrun1Mar 24, 2026
+10
It's worse than that because the Scorpion King timeline is so convoluted. The Scorpion King: Book of Souls is a prequel to a prequel to a sequel to a spinoff of a sequel to a remake.
10
BitwiseBMar 24, 2026
+20
The Mummy - remake
The Mummy Returns - sequel to the remake
The Scorpion King - prequel to the sequel
The Scorpion King 2 - prequel to the prequel
The Scorpion King 3 - sequel (spinoff?) to The Scorpion King
The Scorpion King 4 - sequel to Scorpion King 3
The Scorpion King: Book of Souls - prequel to Scorpion King 3?
I think this is correct? I didn’t see anything past the first Scorpion King so this is my best guess based on Wikipedia
20
Ched_FlermskyMar 24, 2026
+8
Holy jesus, that's some Fast-and-Furious-level convoluted.
8
racer_24_4evrMar 24, 2026
+10
John Oliver yelling about how the new Air Bud is a sequel in a world where the Air Bud movie exists, and that they announced the movie, then found the dog, then asked for funding, then wrapped filming lives rent free in my head.
10
Careless_Wishbone_69Mar 24, 2026
+54
NIRVANNA THE BAND THE SHOW THE MOVIE
54
CartoonWeeklyMar 24, 2026
+6
A movie based on a TV show, based on a web series, based on (I think) a fake band that actually did live comedic performances.
6
strionic_resonatorMar 24, 2026
+28
I can't believe no one has mentioned this one, from WIkipedia:
***Rent*** is a 2005 American [musical](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musical_film) [drama film](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drama_(film_and_television)) directed by [Chris Columbus](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Columbus_(filmmaker)). It is an adaptation of [Jonathan Larson](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Larson)'s [1996 Broadway musical of the same name](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent_(musical)), in turn based on the 1896 [opera](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opera) [*La bohème*](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/La_boh%C3%A8me) by [Giacomo Puccini](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giacomo_Puccini), [Luigi Illica](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luigi_Illica) and [Giuseppe Giacosa](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giuseppe_Giacosa), which is itself based on the 1851 novel [*Scenes of Bohemian Life*](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scenes_of_Bohemian_Life) by [Henri Murger](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henri_Murger).
To add another layer of complication, the writer Sarah Schulman [alleges that the 1996 musical was also based on her 1990 novel *People in Trouble.*](https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2005/11/sarah-schulman-the-writer-rent-ripped-off.html)
Also, *Moulin Rouge* (2001) is also based on *La bohème* and it has, of course, spawned a musical of it's own.
28
Waste-Scratch2982Mar 24, 2026
+90
The Thing 2011 is a prequel to The Thing 1982 which has the same title implying it's a remake and the 1982 Thing is a based on a novella, but uses part of the title of the previous 1951 adaptation The Thing from Another World also implying that it's a remake.
90
CPTherptyderpMar 24, 2026
+23
TIL The Thing 2011 is a prequel. I wrote it off as soon as I heard about it assuming it was a remake to movie that absolutely should never be remade
23
sharkattackmiamiMar 24, 2026
+28
It's the story of the Norwegian base from the start of the 82 movie and them originally finding the thing
28
RecipeAsleep7087Mar 24, 2026
+12
I'd recommend giving it a watch if you like that kind of movie. It's not as good as the 80s movie, but it got the feel right. From what I can remember the main character was very competent, something they pulled from the original.
12
Waste-Scratch2982Mar 24, 2026
+13
It’s a spoiler that it’s a prequel since it’s not revealed until the end but it’s been 15 years since the movie, pulls the same ending as Rogue One where it leads directly into the original. Biggest issue is the use of CGI over practical effects.
13
MrJackdawMar 24, 2026
+6
Yeah, it's a real shame. I'd love to see a cut without the CGI. Apparently the studio insisted on it. :(
6
negcapMar 24, 2026
+3
It literally ends where the original starts.
3
xwhyMar 24, 2026
+3
My head hurts unraveling that….
3
EronamanthiuserMar 24, 2026
+6
See, the Thing is…
6
ArrakeenSunMar 24, 2026
+4
Nevermind the Campbell story lifts generously from Lovecraft's *At the Mountains of Madness*
4
luxmesaMar 24, 2026
+60
The Scorpion King is a spinoff of a sequel to a remake.
60
diego_simeoneMar 24, 2026
+30
More specifically it’s a prequel to a sequel of a remake. Scorpion king 2 is a prequel to the scorpion king so is a prequel to a prequel to a sequel of a remake. There are 5 scorpion king movies and I can’t be bothered to work them all out.
30
Ingavar_OakheartMar 24, 2026
+9
I need a corkboard with photos and red string and a wild-haired shut in waving maniacally to understand this.
9
LostinthebackgroundMar 24, 2026
+5
There are five???!!
5
us2bcoolMar 24, 2026
+19
Cabaret (1972) is a movie musical based on the 1966 stage musical of the same name, based on the 1951 play *I am a Camera*, which was based on the book *Goodbye to Berlin* written by Christopher Isherwood in 1939.
19
Showdown5618Mar 24, 2026
+38
300 movie is based after the comic book 300, which was inspired by the movie The 300 Spartans, which was based on historical events.
Edit: Wow, I had no idea that 300 was that complicated. I completely forgot about Meet the Spartans. I'm making a new list.
- Meet the Spartans is a parody of the...
- 300 movie was based after the...
- 300 comic book which was inspired by...
- The 300 Spartans movie was based on...
- Herodotus's retelling of...
- Oral history of the propoganda of...
- the Battle of Thermopylae.
Thanks to eveyone for contributing.
38
grahampositiveMar 24, 2026
+26
Well, the 300 Spartans was based on Herodotus's recounting of the historical events, which he wrote down 50 years after the battle of Thermopylae
26
insaneHoshiMar 24, 2026
+9
Which itself was based on what the oral history at the time was, which was based on propaganda from the war.
9
PavlockMar 24, 2026
+37
Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy has: A radio play, a series of novels, a television series, a video game, and a film. All written by Douglas Adams. Each based on the the precious and all are iterations of the story. It's very confusing if you're the kind of person who wants a canon story because all of them can be considered so.
37
sayitsoothMar 24, 2026
+19
Series of novels? Series of novels?
It is a Trilogy in 5 parts and that matters dagnabbit!
19
mildpandemicMar 24, 2026
+10
I loved that my copy of the 5th book had "The fifth book of the increasingly inaccurately named Hitchhiker's trilogy" on the cover.
10
Ched_FlermskyMar 24, 2026
+3
Going by the fifth book, you can consider it all canon, as part of the WSOGMM, or "Whole Sort Of General Mishmash." That book really dived into Adams's version of what we now call a "multiverse." And the radio adaptation took it further, by casting Sandra Dickinson, who played Trillian in the TV series, as an alternate Tricia MacMillan who meets the original radio Trillian, played by Susan Sheridan.
3
976chipMar 24, 2026
+3
This was my first thought as well. It baffled me that so many people complained that the 2005 movie it didn't follow the book precisely.
3
Ched_FlermskyMar 24, 2026
+3
The problem wasn't the changes - I actually liked the stuff with John Malkovich as Humma Kavula, and the casting was absolutely spot on. The problem was the everything was played too broadly. It seemed to be aimed at American audiences who need everything big and loud. It needed to be much more low-key. More British.
3
xwhyMar 24, 2026
+2
As far as movies go, though, they go back to the same source material, which is either radio play --> movie, or radio play --> book(s) --> movie
2
Ched_FlermskyMar 24, 2026
+2
I remember Adams talking about how each version of the story contradicted the others, but that the "upcoming" movie would be "specifically contradicting the first book."
2
Conehead1Mar 25, 2026
+2
Plus a short story (Young Zaphod Takes It Easy) and hints at a tie-in with the Dirk Gently series in The Salmon if Doubt.
2
Controller_one1Mar 24, 2026
+49
The Lego Batman Movie. Which references many of the previous Batman movies and shows but itself was a spinoff of a movie (The Lego Movie) based on various toy sets based on movies, books, cartoons, comics and the lego games themselves. A Gordian knot of influence and lineages.
49
mdmnlMar 24, 2026
+40
Commissioner Gordian
Sorry.
40
thugarthMar 24, 2026
+5
You never have to apologize for this kind of joke.
Not to *me.*
5
AvatarIIIMar 24, 2026
+3
Knot to me either
3
xwhyMar 24, 2026
+8
Bat-groan.
8
Anal_HerschiserMar 24, 2026
+11
It's even more complicated than that. Lego Batman existed as both a toy AND a video game before it was a movie. You go deep and the Lego video games are adaptations of other video games to make them child friendly. The video games they're adapted from are often adaptations of movies, which of course are often themselves adaptations of comic books and TV series.
11
scottyrobottyMar 24, 2026
+40
After seeing the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 Gerrard Way was inspired to start My Chemical Romance, which inspired Stephanie Meyers to write Twilight which inspired 50 Shades of Grey and the sequels.
40
goofy_witchMar 24, 2026
+23
To Ellen Degeneres' show getting cancelled
23
littledipper16Mar 24, 2026
+3
That's one of my favorite facts, that 9-11 ultimately lead to the downfall of Ellen DeGeneres
3
The-Ginger-LilyMar 24, 2026
+4
This is the one I knew but couldn't remember why Gerrard Way started it.
4
FrankfeldMar 24, 2026
+2
This is like Star Trek Voyager causing Obama to be elected president.
2
TheKiltedStrangerMar 24, 2026
+24
[Street Fighter](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street_Fighter_(video_game)) (1987 video game) > [Street Fighter II](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street_Fighter_II) (1991 video game)> [Street Fighter](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street_Fighter_(1994_film)) (1994 film starring JCVD and Raul Julia, among several other notables, based on Street Fighter II) > [Street Fighter: The Movie: The Game](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street_Fighter:_The_Movie_(console_video_game)) (1995 video game for Playstation and Sega Saturn based on the The Movie)
24
SfcHayes1973Mar 24, 2026
+3
>Raul Julia
"...for me, it was a Tuesday."
3
TheShishkabobMar 24, 2026
+3
To make this one more confusing: there are two different games named "Street Fighter: The Movie" with both releasing in 1995 but made by different studios. One was an arcade game (it's bad) and the other was the console game mentioned above (it's less bad).
3
GabelvampirMar 24, 2026
+3
Fun fact, the Japan release of the console game got the awesomely stupid name "Street Fighter: Real Battle on Film"
3
Victory33Mar 24, 2026
+10
Beavis and Butthead - Do the Universe is a sequel based on the first movie, based on the show, based on a short from a different show (Liquid Television).
10
joe12321Mar 24, 2026
+11
**For a Few Dollars More** and **The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly** are sequels to **A Fistful of Dollars**, which is a remake of **Yojimbo** (which has its own sequel, **Sanjuro**, another remake, **Last Man Standing**, and a couple more movies it inspired), which is inspired by the noir movie, **The Glass Key**, which is based on the novel, *The Glass Key*, by Dashiell Hammett.
Also I spelled Dashiell Hammett correctly on the first try, which I usually do not.
11
The_Celtic_ChemistMar 24, 2026
+9
In 1896 at the Palais Garnier in Paris, a several hundred pound counterweight to the chandelier broke free during a performance of *Helle*. A concierge was killed and several more were injured. Palais Garnier is also known for a cistern (an underground man-made lake) being underneath it. It was built in the 1860's to stabilize the structure, manage high groundwater, and serve as a water reserve for fire pumps. The Palais Garnier also had stories of a ghost who was believed to make things go awry and steal items gone missing. And it had rumors of an architect named Eric who asked to live under the structure and hadn't been seen since, along with a corpse found buried in the foundation. Furthermore, a Swedish, blonde haired, blue eyed Soprano named Christina Nielsson, who was the daughter of a poor man and forced to leave her home at a young age only to perform in Paris later, mysteriously cancelled her performance at the last minute before the Garnier Opera’s inauguration.
This all partially served as an inspiration to "The Phantom of the Opera" which appeared serially before publication as a novel in 1910, and Christine Daaé, the haunted protege, beared an uncanny resemblance to Christina Nielsson.
The novel and its story was made into a silent film in 1916 but the story did not achieve much acclaim until it was made into another silent film starring Lon Cheney in 1925.
In 1943 another movie was made that portrayed The Phantom as a sympathetic character.
In 1962 yet another movie was made that portrayed The Phantom as sympathetic *and* took place in London.
In 1986 Andrew Lloyd Weber crafted a musical stage production of the story, also set in London, and keeping with the idea of The Phantom being a sympathetic character.
Then in 2004 another movie was released based on Andrew Lloyd Webers musical.
9
Ok_Relationship_543Mar 26, 2026
+1
And then in 2009 Terry Pratchett published the novel Maskerade, based on a couple of the Phantom of the Opera stories.
1
SoufOaklinFoLifeMar 24, 2026
+16
Annihilation (2018) is based, in part, on a book (Annihilation) which is based on a movie (Stalker) which is based on a book (Roadside Picnic) and, in part, on a movie (Solaris), which is based on a book (Solaris).
16
CardboardWizMar 24, 2026
+7
12 Monkeys is a tv show based on a movie based on a short film based on a book.
7
ShyHopefulNiceMar 24, 2026
+2
Small note: The short film was very well regarded at the time. It is a “photo-roman” - a series of still images to tell the story rather than a normal “motion picture”
2
JTOC1969Mar 24, 2026
+7
Can we include TV shows?
"Good Times" is a spinoff of "Maude",
which is a spinoff of "All in the Family",
which was reworked from a failed pilot called "Those Were the Days",
which was reworked from ANOTHER failed pilot called "Justice for All",
which was the American adaptation of a British TV series called "Till Death Do Us Part."
7
countered_measuresMar 24, 2026
+6
Hitchhikers guide to the galaxy is a movie based off a screenplay (see below) based off a tv show, which was based off a radio show, which at some point was on vinyl, which was sorta based off a book.
Except then adams wrote this screen play that had literally nothing to do with any of the latter (well, except for parts the book) and the co-writer finished the screenplay based on adams' notes after he died, which included things that weren't in any other adaptation.
6
SeaPeepsMar 24, 2026
+9
Hm. I think the screenplay for the 2005 movie, the 1981 tv show, and the 1984 text adventure game are all loose adaptations of the 1979 book, which was in turn a loose adaptation of the 1978 radio show.
9
countered_measuresMar 24, 2026
+2
You know, it's so obscure, you're probably right.
2
bopeepsheepMar 24, 2026
+3
The vinyl is different from the radio, though the tapes/CDs aren't.
3
Son_of_KongMar 24, 2026
+2
The radio serial was the first iteration. Adams was supposed to be writing a series of skits about the earth getting destroyed in various ways, but he got carried away with the first episode and ended up making it the whole series.
2
latestagepersonhoodMar 24, 2026
+5
Wasn't there an article about how *Red One* was based on "The Rock's ex-brother in law being drunk at family chrismas" or something.
5
SaltyRaspberryMar 24, 2026
+6
Santa Paws 2: The Santa Pups is a sequel to The Search For Santa Paws which is a prequel to Santa Buddies which is a spin-off of Air Bud.
I don’t know how I obtained this knowledge.
6
seigezuntMar 24, 2026
+6
Dr Sleep is an adaptation of a book that is a sequel to another book, and it’s a sequel to a film adaptation of that other book, although that movie is different from that book in significant ways, and yet Dr Sleep manages to do both, incorporating things from that older book that weren’t in the original movie, and things from that original movie that weren’t in the book.
6
BlainethePayneMar 24, 2026
+12
How about the audiobook of the novelization of the movie Precious, based on the book Push by Sapphire?
12
sgarstMar 24, 2026
+4
Grey Gardens is a pretty wild ride. Insane documentary film, turned into a musical and then a tv drama. And a hilarious bill hadder mockumentary spoof.
4
Few_Mention8426Mar 24, 2026
+5
Les Misérables
The Original Book (1862)
The Films (1935, 1952, etc.)
The Concept Album (1980)
The Stage Musical (1985
The Novelization: Several books based on the musical's condensed plot, rather than Hugo's 1,200 page original.
The Movie Musical (2012) The Hugh Jackman film based on the musical
Multiple books (manga) that specifically use the visual designs from the 2012 movie.
5
No_Surround8946Mar 24, 2026
+5
Transformers (2007) is a movie that is based on a television cartoon series, which is based on a American toyline, which is a rebranded Japanese toyline for western markets.
5
VerbalAcrobaticsMar 24, 2026
+4
"The Thing" (2011) is based off of "The Thing" (1982), which is based off of "The Thing From Another World" (1951), which was based off of the novella "Who Goes There?" (John W. Campbell Jr. - 1938), which was based off of the novella "At the Mountains of Madness (H. P. Lovecraft 1931). Not to mention "The Thing" (1982) inspired the short story "The Things" (Peter Watts - 2010).
4
MoriturismMar 24, 2026
+6
a different kind of complication: Texas Chainsaw movies as a whole. you have all these different timelines:
1. Original movies: TCS ('74), TCM 2 ('86), TCM 3 ('90), TCM 4 ('95)
2. Remakes: TCM remake (2002), prequel to TCM remake (2006)
3. First requel: TCS ('74), TCS 3D (2013), Leatherface (2017)
4. Second requel: TCS ('74), TCM (2022)
6
JayTLMar 24, 2026
+3
Halloween is almost there too
3
AvatarIIIMar 24, 2026
+2
4 continuities I think, maybe 5
2
o_MrBombastic_oMar 24, 2026
+3
To jump the gun, It's not out yet (might never be) Paramount is currently working on a film adaptation of Spamalot they have the screenplay done. A movie musical adaptation of the Tony-winning Broadway show Spamalot—which is itself based on Monty Python and the Holy Grail.
3
grumblyoldmanMar 24, 2026
+5
And Monty Python and the Holy Grail is (loosely) based on Arthurian myth, which probably includes dozens of different versions stacked on each other going back to wherever it originated from. I'm no history expert, I'm mostly just here for the coconuts.
5
Salarian_AmericanMar 24, 2026
+3
Yeah "movie to stage musical back into movie" is becoming its own subgenre, including The Producers, Hairspray, and Mean Girls, and probably others that didn't come to mind just now
3
TacosAreJusticeMar 24, 2026
+3
In the recent remake of Duck Tales, they had an episode that was based on The Warriors, a movie based on a story out of Ancient Greece…
So it’s a remake of a TV show, based on a comic book, copying a movie that was based on actual events that happened in Ancient Greece…
3
insane677Mar 24, 2026
+2
The Warriors was a book too.
2
hawkman1000Mar 24, 2026
+3
How did no one post the movie Adaptation?
3
ThaCarterMar 24, 2026
+3
The Warriors is based on a book front the 1960s that is in turn based on the Anabasis by Xenophon, circ 3rd or 4th century bc.
A remake will likely incorporate the video game from 2006 in there too.
3
georgecm12Mar 24, 2026
+3
"Smash" is an off-Broadway musical about the making of the musical "Bombshell," based on the TV show "Smash" that isn't exactly a musical (but still features musical segments) about the making of the on-Broadway musical "Bombshell."
3
real_triplizardMar 24, 2026
+10
Technically the Wicked book was based on a book and not a movie since the Wizard of Oz book was in the public domain and the movie was not.
10
insertusernamehere51Mar 24, 2026
+28
And yet the most important trait that Elphaba has in Wicked is being green... which is from the Oz movie, not the book
28
xwhyMar 24, 2026
+7
Likewise, Glinda is NOT the Witch of the North in the book. She's the Witch of the South. The Witch of the North is never named. The movie combined the two characters.
And the shoes are silver. The movie had ruby slippers to show off Technicolor.
7
georgecm12Mar 24, 2026
+3
If I recall, they're silver in the stage musical as well. They use red accent lighting to make them appear ruby at one point, but the actual shoes are silver.
3
real_triplizardMar 24, 2026
+2
That's interesting - didn't know that. I wonder how they squared that with the public domain issue. Or maybe it wasn't a big enough issue to infringe on the movie copyright.
2
BranWafrMar 24, 2026
+5
I believe the copyright only applies to a specific shade of green, so as long as they use a different shade they are fine.
5
delsol10Mar 24, 2026
+3
yeah. but witch green? hmm....
3
johncostaMar 24, 2026
+6
My best guess is that witches are kinda depicted as having green skin in many different places so maybe it’s not copyright enforceable? Though who knows maybe that only became a popular depiction after 1939 anyway
6
trialrun1Mar 24, 2026
+8
While The Wicked Witch being green was something that came from the movie and not the books (probably to help show off the color film which was new at the time), green skin has become synonymous with witches in popular culture in the decades sense. If you look at any Halloween decorations of witches today, half of them are going to be green, to the point where the original movie can't really claim ownership over the idea of a green skinned witch, even though they were likely what popularized the look.
It's possible that if MGM wanted to try and claim the green skin of the Wicked Witch they could, but the fact that it has become so generic of a look would work against them. Plus the fact that they've let it go several times in the past means that they can't suddenly start claiming that this time around it would be infringing on their copyright. In the end it's really just not worth it, and they would likely lose anyway.
On the other hand, pretty much any depiction of Oz that isn't the original movie has the shoes being silver instead of Ruby, like they were in the book. The Ruby slippers (again changed because the color would show better with the new color film technology) have been much more guarded as unique to the movie interpretation and they probably would go after any movie that tried to give Dorthey red shoes.
8
sightlabMar 24, 2026
+5
Hairspray was a movie that became a musical that became a movie version of the musical. 0/10, lacks Devine.
5
Salarian_AmericanMar 24, 2026
+10
OK Sure it lacks Divine but John Travolta did okay and watching him in drag doing a romantic song and dance duet with Christopher Walken means I simply can't just dismiss it out of hand.
10
Few_Mention8426Mar 24, 2026
+2
plus A **2016 live TV production** based on the 2007 movie and 2002 musical.
2
akgiantMar 24, 2026
+3
The Magnificent Seven (2016) is a remake of a notable western, the Magnificent Seven (1960).
The 1960 Magnificent Seven was so popular is spawned a series of sequels: Return of the Magnificent Seven (1966), Guns of Magnificent Seven (1969), and the Magnificent Seven Ride! (1972)
It also spawned a TV series, Magnificent Seven (1998) and was even adapted to sci-fi with Battle Beyond the Stars (1980).
The 1960 film was itself an adaption of the Akira Kurosawa classic, the Seven Samurai (1954).
Interestingly, Kurosawa films have been adapted many times into other films (specifically westerns which Kurosawa was greatly inspired by), most famously; the Hidden Fortress to Star Wars. Yojimbo/Sanjuro films would go on to become the Man with no Name trilogy: Fistful of Dollars, For a Few Dollars More, and the Good, the Bad and the Ugly.
3
tfhermobwoaywayMar 24, 2026
+4
50 Shades of Grey is a movie adapted from a book adapted from a fanfiction of the novel Twilight, inspired by My Chemical Romance which was itself inspired by 9/11.
4
VariousTrash5110Mar 24, 2026
+2
bruhh my headd hurts
2
RyzenRaiderMar 24, 2026
+2
Well Creed 2 is the sequel to the spinoff of a sequel.
2
PsykpatientMar 24, 2026
+2
I recall the idea of Disney's Hunchback came from a "classics for kids" book which used the stage play adaptation as a basis.
2
Loki-LMar 24, 2026
+2
"The Birdcage" was based on Broadway musical, based on a European series of movies based on a play.
"Matilda" started out as a book, became a movie, then a musical, then a movie based on that musical.
The movie "Nine" with Daniel Day-Lewis is based on the award winning musical "9" which in turn is based on the Fellini movie "8½".
For a very weird and niche version of the concept, there is a French live action adaptation of the City Hunter anime. Since the Anime was known in France as "*Nicky Larson"* the movie is titled [Nicky Larson et le parfum de Cupidon](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicky_Larson_et_le_parfum_de_Cupidon)
The movie is very explicitly based on the French dub of the anime adaptation of the Manga. I don't know if the Anime movies made it to France and are included in this.
In any case the French movie is completely unrelated to the Hong-Kong made Jackie Chan live action adaptation (which containted the best Street Fighter adaptatio to date) of the original Manga or the more recent Netflix movie or the 2011 South Korean live-action TV series. Apparently there is also a musical in Japan.
Did I mention that in 2019 and 2023 two more anime movies were released one of which explicitly crossed over with the Cat's Eye anime which in 2025 got an remake on Disney+?
2
xwhyMar 24, 2026
+2
The Birdcage is also related in some fashion to La Cage aux Folles, which was an old movie and a later Broadway musical, but the musical wasn't made into a film (to my knowledge).
2
EatYourCheckersMar 24, 2026
+2
Last night I was daydreaming about making a novel out of The Big Lebowski, so I am enjoying this thread
2
the_daymanMar 24, 2026
+2
Not really as crazy, but I find it funny there is a Scorpion King 2 which is a prequel to the Scorpion King, which is a spin off prequel to the Mummy 2, which is a sequel to the Mummy - which itself could be considered some kind of remake.
There are also 3 more sequels after Scorpion King 2.
2
DaddiGatorMar 24, 2026
+2
Friday Night Lights has a movie on the way apparently that's based off of the tv show that was based off of the movie that was based off of the book.
2
withoccassionalmusicMar 24, 2026
+2
*A C*** and Bull Story* is a movie about trying to make a movie adaptation of a book that’s about trying to write a book.
2
xwhyMar 24, 2026
+2
Similarly, Noises Off is an American movie but an American theater trope putting on a play which is a British farce and its based on the play "Noises Off" which is a British farce about putting on a British farce.
Not quite the same parallel which is why the movie isn't quite as good as the stage show, but it makes up for it with its talented cast.
2
APartyInMyPantsMar 24, 2026
+2
50 Shades of Grey is based on a book that was written largely based from fanfiction about either the book or movie Twilight.
2
greg225Mar 24, 2026
+2
Disney's The Lion King is inspired by Hamlet, we all know that. But in the 1960s there was a play called Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead, which is based on two minor supporting characters from Hamlet, and mostly tells the story of Hamlet from their perspective. In 2004 there was a direct-to-DVD spin-off of The Lion King called The Lion King 3 (or The Lion King 1.5 in the US), which is based on *that* play and shows what Timon and Pumbaa were up to while The Lion King was happening, while they react to several scenes in a sort of meta-comedy format.
2
Ill-Elephant-9583Mar 24, 2026
+2
Hitchhikers guide to the galaxy
2
DrBootsMar 24, 2026
+2
Scorpion King: Book of Souls is the 3rd sequel in a series of prequels to the spin-off of a sequel to a remake of The Mummy.
2
mrbubbamacMar 24, 2026
+2
Street Fighter: The Movie: The Game, is a (terrible) game based on a movie based on a game
2
BurtRogainMar 24, 2026
+2
Not to be a “Well actually…” guy but the plot to The Fly 2 and Return of the Fly is similar enough that an argument can be made that it kind of is a remake.
2
Piscivore_67Mar 24, 2026
+2
Matilda the Musical (2022) is a movie based on a stage musical (2010) based on the movie (1996) of the Roald Dahl book Matilda (1988)
2
Ched_FlermskyMar 24, 2026
+2
The novel that became Die Hard was written as a sequel to a Frank Sinatra movie. Sinatra had starred in The Detective, based on a novel by Roderick Thorpe. Thorpe wrote the novel Die Hard in case The Detective was successful enough for a sequel.
Die Hard 2 was based on an unrelated novel. Die Hard With A Vengeance was taken from an unrelated screenplay. The fourth movie was based on a magazine article about cyber-warfare. The fifth one was the first Die Hard to be conceived *as a Die Hard movie*.
2
xwhyMar 24, 2026
+2
When Die Hard was going into production, the producers were required, by contractual obligations, to ask Sinatra if he’d be interested in the role. Being in his 70s (I think), Sinatra declined.
2
KieferMcNaughtyMar 24, 2026
+2
*AfterMASH*, *Trapper John, MD*, and *WALTER* are sell spin-offs of *MASH,* a tv show based on a film (by Robert Altman), whose final product was developed from, but not a direct performance, of Ring Lardner's script, which was based on the book by Richard Hooker.
2
Ched_FlermskyMar 24, 2026
+2
I always found it funny that there was the musical A Chorus Line, which was adapted into a movie, then more recently there was a documentary about the making of a new production of A Chorus Line. Next there should be a straight play about the documentary about the musical, followed by a podcast about the making of the straight play about the making of the documentary about the musical.
2
Comprehensive-Fun47Mar 24, 2026
+2
The Wild Party was a novella-length narrative poem published in the 20s.
It was made into a movie in the 70s.
It was basically lost to history until it entered the public domain in the 90s. A new edition was released with illustrations.
In 1999, TWO separate musical adaptations hit the stage. One opened on Broadway; the other off Broadway. People have *very* strong opinions about which is their favorite.
Both versions have been revived off-Broadway since, including one that is running right now for a few weeks.
It's not all that complicated, but it is interesting. It was the first time the same source material was adapted and staged at the same time on Broadway. The closest thing to happen like that since is the two different musicals based on The Great Gatsby, which entered the public domain a couple of years ago. One is going strong on Broadway. The other is still in development and likely won't attempt a Broadway run while the other Gatsby is still running successfully.
2
second_toastacctMar 24, 2026
+2
The King (2019) is my favorite example of this. A historical film re-interpretation of a play which itself was a dramatic re-interpreted historical events. So much more interesting that simply doing a historical film interpretation of a historical event. It gives the movie so much character.
2
SandsnakePrimeMar 24, 2026
+2
The most complicated of all:
Hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy
2
ComicBookDadMar 24, 2026
+2
Long running joke on my podcast....
"Precious based on the novel Push by Sapphire"
2
Codexe-Mar 25, 2026
+2
Not a long lineage but The Little Hours is based on a story from the middle ages. The story is considered a comedy, however, not in the modern sense. Traditionally, comedy was the opposite of tragedy. It just meant, "happy ending", not "funny". So, people were mad because The Little Hours wasn't funny, even though it's a "comedy." But that's because it's not a comedy in the modern usage of the word.
It's like Dante's Inferno, a Divine Comedy. It's not funny, it just has a happy ending.
Edit:
Eleven from stranger things is completely stolen from Firestarter, which was initially book, which was a rehash of Carrie, which has also had it's own film, and remake
2
NecroJoeMar 25, 2026
+2
There was a home video game based on the arcade video game based on *Street Fighter: The Movie,* which was based on a game (*Street Fighter II*), which was a sequel to the original *Street Fighter* arcade game.
2
Omni314Mar 25, 2026
+2
"I'm Christian Bocher. I'm portraying the character of Raymond Gunne, who portrays the character of Dr. Levant, which is based on the character Daniel Jackson, portrayed by the actor Michael Shanks, originally portrayed by the actor James Spader…in the feature film."
2
bigtcmMar 25, 2026
+2
"Street Fighter: The Movie" was a video game based on the terrible live action movie which is based on the video game.
Importantly, this game should not be confused with "Street Fighter II Movie" also confusingly known as "Street Fighter 2 the interactive movie" which is a video game adaptation of the Street Fighter anime movie.
2
Walter_ArmstrongMar 25, 2026
+2
Mame was a book first, then a play, then a movie, then a legendary stage musical starring Angela Lansbury, then a shit show of a movie that effectively killed Lucile Ball’s film career.
200 Comments