· 57 comments · Save ·
For Sale Apr 24, 2026 at 4:12 PM

Widow's Bay Review - Apple’s Twisted “Widow’s Bay” is Like Nothing Else on Television

Posted by abucalves



🚩 Report this post

57 Comments

Sign in to comment — or just click the box below.
🔒 Your email is never shown publicly.
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 24, 2026 +154
Matthew Rhys? I'm in.
154
HooGoesThere Apr 24, 2026 +55
And Stephen Root
55
MeCritic Apr 24, 2026 +10
They will “team up” again, after they both starred in Perry Mason.
10
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 24, 2026 +9
They were both excellent in Perry Mason, and HBO should never have canceled it.
9
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 24, 2026 +2
And Justin Kirk (Uncle Andy from Weeds, Jeryd Mencken from Succession) played Hamilton Berger on Perry Mason. It'd be so awesome to have him and Matthew team up again too.
2
ImDickensHesFenster Apr 24, 2026 +13
Seconded. Stephen Root should be in more things.
13
MasterofPandas1 Apr 24, 2026 +6
So I looked this up cause I showed the trailer to my friend who is a Stephen Root fan and he’s actually in a f*** ton of things. A lot of voice acting and more minor characters, but his filmography is pretty wild.
6
ImDickensHesFenster Apr 24, 2026 +2
"Office Space" and "Barry" are two of my favorites.
2
Navitach Apr 24, 2026 +1
He was a Klingon in two episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation: Unification I & II, the episodes where Spock finally appeared on the show.
1
WoodpeckerGingivitis Apr 24, 2026 +1
Oh helllllll yeah
1
Navitach Apr 24, 2026 +1
Him as "town oddball" is all I needed to read. But If they don't do *something* with a red Swingline, even small or subtle, I'll be disappointed.
1
a-hthy Apr 24, 2026 +10
Always! I know a lot of people didn’t enjoy The Beast in Me but damn he was great in that! And of course the Americans.
10
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 24, 2026 +7
He was, for lack of a better term, a beast in The Beast In Me. Sly, seductive and incredibly maniacal towards the end.
7
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 24, 2026 +2
If you get a chance to check out Agatha Christie's Towards Zero on Britbox he's amazing in that one as well.
2
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 24, 2026
Yes he was. Everything he does is brilliant.
0
BroughtBagLunchSmart Apr 24, 2026 +1
F*** it took me years to pronounce Rhys Darby correct and I am now just thinking that Matthew Rhys probably pronounces it the same way.
1
SynthD Apr 25, 2026 +3
It’s the Welsh spelling of Reece, which is sometimes spelled Reese.
3
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 24, 2026 +1
Yes, he does.
1
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 25, 2026 +1
His full name is Matthew Rhys Evans. I read that the reason why he goes by Matthew Rhys is because there was another actor named Matthew Evans in the Equity union and he decided to use Rhys as a professional surname so as not to cause confusion between them.
1
Chad-GPT5 Apr 24, 2026 +1
Yeah that's all they had to say, really.
1
RentalGore Apr 24, 2026 +198
“ In a time when too many shows are content to do the overrated “10-part movie” thing, it’s so great to see one that echoes a structure close to “The X-Files” or “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” with single-episode narratives that add texture to the bigger one.” If this is true, I’m all in!
198
Regula96 Apr 24, 2026 +29
Hell yea me too! ''Stand alone'' episodes weekly with a few of them dealing with a bigger picture is my personal favorite tv format.
29
Axolotl_amphibian Apr 25, 2026 +2
This sounds perfect, I've been missing monster of the week so much.
2
Disastrous_Wing7084 Apr 24, 2026 +211
>The closest thing to it is the unforgettable “Teddy Perkins” episode of “Atlanta” Sold
211
theodo Apr 24, 2026 +27
Makes sense, since it's directed by Hirao Murai
27
DonChrisote Apr 24, 2026 +13
Jesus, that guy is a real SICKO *subscribes to Apple TV*
13
ArchDucky Apr 25, 2026 +13
If you really just joined Apple, check out Slow Horses. Its the best spy show. Stars Gary Oldman.
13
ithinkther41am Apr 25, 2026 +2
Even better, it has a consistent yearly release schedule.
2
Johnny_Blaze_123 Apr 24, 2026 +17
yeah, sign me up.
17
Saar13 Apr 24, 2026 +42
I love Slow Horses, which is an adaptation, but generally all the biggest Apple TV highlights are totally original shows with strange premises. That's where they stand out amidst the generation of IPs, prequels, sequels, and adaptations.
42
NorDub Apr 25, 2026 +9
Silo and Dark Matter are a couple off the top of my head that are also good and adaptions.
9
Saar13 Apr 25, 2026 +1
I also really like those shows. I'm not against adaptations; in fact, I'll definitely watch The Stormlight Archive show and the Mistborn movie trilogy that Apple is making. And it's obvious that established IP is important for a service that's still growing without a content library. My point is that there needs to be a better balance, because TV is too predictable and relies too heavily on expanded universes and established IPs, even on prestigious channels like HBO.
1
NorDub Apr 25, 2026 +1
I'm all for a good balance, too. And oh wow, I hadn't heard there were mistborn and stormlight shows/movies in the works. I like those books!
1
Regula96 Apr 25, 2026
Lessons in Chemistry is one of their very best shows too.
0
runwithjames Apr 25, 2026 +5
They don't get it right all the time but I'm always more interested in an Apple original show that just about anyone else right now.
5
Saar13 Apr 25, 2026 +2
As a service without a library, only with original shows, they grow more slowly, but I think they're closer to their ideal point than ever. I completely understand them acquiring the Cosmere universe, because it could be a big thing for them, but I still believe that total originality, and even strangeness, can be the biggest driver of the brand.
2
Self_Owned_Tree Apr 24, 2026 +55
So is this more horror, sci-fi, psychological thriller, dark comedy, or something else! If it’s more X Files than American Horror Story, I think I’m in. Edit: “if Jordan Peele decided to reboot “Northern Exposure.” I watched the trailer and assumed it was Best Medicine+X Files.
55
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 24, 2026 +6
I love Best Medicine. Definitely gives Northern Exposure vibes besides its origins in Doc Martin. Now if Jordan Peele decided to reboot that show and give it a dark, supernatural feel alongside the "case of the week" style typical of medical procedurals, that would be interesting.
6
myassholealt Apr 25, 2026 +2
Best Medicine is so fun. It took me a couple of episodes to get into the wide range of quirk, but now I love all the characters and get excited to see a new episode is out. Though I think it's done for this season now. Hopefully since it's a network show it gets the full 20+ episodes order next season. The amount of huge infections diseases that town is gonna face next year! It's also a US remake of the British series Doc Martin (the actor plays his father!) which is also great. Slightly more serious than Best Medicine, but the small town quirk is there just the same.
2
Horror_Ad_8149 Apr 25, 2026 +1
I love it. Josh Charles fits the character like a glove. I haven't seen the original series it was based on but I did watch the episode where his dad appears in it and that was very funny and charming. I definitely hope it gets a full season order next year.
1
ascagnel____ Apr 25, 2026
> If it’s more X Files than American Horror Story, I think I’m in. A quick look at the cast shows Dale Dickey billed fifth, and she was in an X-Files episode. 
0
ArchDucky Apr 24, 2026 +29
I heard it was very close to Atlanta and Fargo.
29
KonixSpeedking Apr 24, 2026 +30
Hmmm, St Louis seems about midway between the two, is that what you meant?
30
ArchDucky Apr 24, 2026 +10
No.
10
AlvinTaco Apr 24, 2026 +11
I was having a very bad day and this exchange made me laugh.
11
ArchDucky Apr 24, 2026 +3
Something that always helps me on a bad day is just binging sitcoms. Episode after episode after episode.. not sure why it helps but I rewatch sitcoms all the time.
3
Talentagentfriend Apr 25, 2026 +1
Atlanta and Fargo are very different though
1
Mentoman72 Apr 24, 2026 +12
Hiro Murai directing, sold
12
dagreenman18 Apr 24, 2026 +9
> what would happen if Jordan Peele decided to reboot “Northern Exposure. And look at that I’m so f****** sold. I don’t even need the rest of the article. Though now I’m bummed I gotta wait till Wednesday
9
Midnight_Oil_ Apr 25, 2026 +3
Hiro Murai don't f****** miss
3
[deleted] Apr 24, 2026 +4
[deleted]
4
________76________ Apr 24, 2026 +2
Article says it starts the 29th, which is wednesday
2
shadowdra126 Apr 24, 2026 +6
I’m very excited to watch this. The trailers grabbed me instantly
6
berlinbaer Apr 24, 2026 +4
so much exciting stuff on tv right now.
4
sarbeans9001 Apr 24, 2026 +3
ok the Teddy Perkins comparison sold me, that episode messed me up for like a week straight
3
Aarrrgggghhhhh35 Apr 25, 2026 +1
NGL when I saw the preview the other night, I was all in when I saw Hiro Murai’s name pop up since I am such a big Atlanta fan. I’m not a horror lover but I can leave the lights on for a few nights for Hiro. 😬😬😬
1
-Clayburn Apr 25, 2026 +1
Is it like Barry?
1
← Back to Board